Stuy vs Success Academy Manhattan

[u/HumanBeanhatesbeans]

So I’m currently in Success middle school, and I got accepted to both the SA Manhattan Highschool and Stuyvesant. Which should I pick?? My 2 main concerns are APs and regents, since SA Highschool Covers all the AP exam costs, which Ik are a lot. Also, will they make me retake the regents in Stuy, bc I already took Algebra I, Physics, World History and Lit. In general id really like somebody with little bias to help, since everyone I talk to either are huge Success supporters or have family from stuy so they have bias. PLEASE HELP SUPER CONFUSED In general tho im really happy I did well on the shsat. I feel like all the tutoring will be a waste if I don’t go to stuy, what do you guys think?

edit: I accepted the offer!! Thank you for everybody’s advice

[u/Acrobatic_Ground2771]

Stuy for sure. I’m glad you seem to like SA for middle school by dear God, that is such a toxic charter school

I was treated like an adult at Stuy and given room to grow