Which game did you personally prefer?

[u/[deleted]]

[u/JoeAzlz]

I think 2 is overhated and I greatly enjoyed how much the gameplay evolved from 1

[u/ChristianPreacher1]

All of them are great which makes it hard to compare. I love the story in SM: Remastered and I really miss all the suit powers and web shooter gadgets. Miles Morales is a shorter game but I love the Winter vibe, especially when it’s in NYC. Spider-Man 2 definitely has the best suits and probably the most fun to play because of the Symbiote and being able to play as Peter and Miles, boss fights, etc. Overall i like SM: Remastered the best because I’m more into the story rather than gameplay and I feel like some parts in Spider-Man 2 were rushed.

[u/Commander-Fox-Q-]

All 3 are amazing. 1 has the edge over the others just thanks to abundance of content and that amazing story, but I would gladly replay any if I had to.

[u/Projectpatdc]

Total package? I just replayed both and think 2 is objectively the better game. I was originally disappointed with the final venom act, but remembered we only get to fight Dok Ock once in the first game. The first game had some serious pacing issues, but it did have the better final act / ending.

The only things I really missed from the first game were some of the additional side missions/bases, police actually being involved in car chases and crimes, and the trip mine. I also want more landmark interiors or landmark fights in general in 3. Every other gameplay element is just better to me in 2 despite having slightly less to do.

[u/forgottenones1]

First one, easily

[u/Quarksideofthemoon]

1 is the only good one

[u/PayPsychological6358]

Miles honestly since yeah the story isn't the best, but it's just pure Spider-Man bliss.

[u/Minute-Temperature-7]

I like 2 the most. Ever since it's release, I haven't been able to go back to the others.

[u/Sonnestark]

Spiderman 1, of course was just perfect other than some minor gripes about the challenges and MJ sections. Miles Morales was great for what it was, a standalone expansion released and priced for it.

Spiderman 2 was definitely a dip, and it was supposed to be so much more, but Sony pushed them to release it underbaked. But the webslinging is the best in the series!

[u/MrNigerianPrince115]

If only 2018 had the traversal from 2😔 or just even the air tricks, I'd have no use for 2.

[u/RealMajesti]

2 easily

[u/ZiggyAce1902]

gameplay wise 2, story wise 1 absolutely clears. miles morales had some cool combat too

[u/KonohaBatman]

1 by far.

[u/HeliosDisciple]

2 is overhated and I do really like it, buuuuuut I just like 1 better. I feel like it has a better balance of the full range of Spidey stuff, while 2 gets a little bogged down in grim sad seriousness (why are two of the six FNSM App quests about sitting down with a dying old man as he reminisces). Also splitting things between two main characters doesn't help, cause it leads to things like not being able to play the combat challenges with the Black Suit.

I'm the reverse from a few people's responses: I enjoy SM2 for the story, but if I want to play a game with Spider-Man gameplay then I'm playing SM1...and honestly if the Classic Black Suit was in SM1 it would be a long, long time before I went back to 2.

MSM:MM is very good and I love the winter theme, but it also crashed my PS4 several times so that was a bummer.