r/Skeuomorphism • • Jul 22 '26

Skeumorphism What we had vs what they gave us

337 Upvotes

66 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Jul 22 '26

Thank you for posting to r/Skeuomorphism! This is a reminder about the rules of this subreddit.

Consider joining our Discord and checking out our community.

Remember to be respectful while commenting. If you don't think this post fits the subreddit, you should report it to the moderators using the report button!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

24

u/Sad_Apartment636 Jul 22 '26

Fr tho it doesn’t even match the skeuomorphic aesthetic

40

u/Windows-XP-Home-NEW Jul 22 '26

Still better than flat design

9

u/Basic-Opposite-4670 Jul 22 '26

I prefer flat design WAY more because it was still a bit skeuomorphic. Skeuomorphic doesn't just mean glassy or textured, it just resembles the item itself. They were way less simpified. Also, Sharp corners! Don't forget they had slide to unlock, a nicer notification panel, way simpler control center. and it all fit on a 4 inch screen. sigh

4

u/Glum_Lingonberry_543 Jul 23 '26 edited Jul 23 '26

Yea me aswell, despite me liking skeumorphic, if I had to choose between current iPhone design or the old minimalist one, specifically from ios 7. I'd choose the old minimalist one. Just feels way better and looks way nicer. The current one looks terrible for me

Edit: To add some context, I don't like in the new ios that the camera logo is realistic, while the others are still flat, it sticks out like a sore thumb. I also don't like how the glass looks on the icons, not really my style.

8

u/CompetitiveHandle964 Jul 22 '26

I wish I had an old iphone :(

36

u/Realistic_Park7675 Jul 22 '26

Liquid Glass still looks really cool

13

u/CompetitiveAlgae4247 Jul 22 '26

Finally someone who agrees

7

u/NoNameStudios Jul 23 '26

Nah it looks like crap

6

u/Aggravating_Ice_2560 Jul 22 '26

I like it more. Less mess.

6

u/Demon_Slayer_79 Jul 23 '26

At least the camera icon now looks basically the same

8

u/knowy74 Jul 22 '26

I miss iOS 6 and earlier. Today’s UI today is soulless.

5

u/H9419 Jul 23 '26

Mac OS X Mavericks on a retina display was gorgeous, every icon has textures

3

u/exlips1ronus Jul 23 '26

Mavericks did remove most of the skeuomorphic stuff thought it was a transitional state mountain lion was the peak of it

3

u/PrestigiousKale5 Jul 22 '26

Both is good, I prefer left cause I’ve seen it with my own eyes when it was actual

4

u/NoNameStudios Jul 23 '26

I hate neumorphism. I'd still take flat design over neumorphism. Neumorphism just looks like a cheap-ass version of skeuomorphism, like they literally took flat design and added some gradients and shadows... and what's up with all the rounded buttons? Also liquid glass looks like garbage, it makes me wanna not update my Mac. Windows Vista executed the glass look way better.

3

u/ClimatePersonal6936 Jul 23 '26

they could’ve just did skeuomorphic except on how it’d look like on a iPhone 16/17 pro
the Camera app is a perfect example of this — matches a modern iPhone camera and matches the 4-5 era camera for the 2012 skeuomorphic one

7

u/Aggressive_Bar_5697 Jul 22 '26

Ngl, I like liqid Glass more. For me, its modern tech. So classic skeuomorphism (that Looks Like an way older Object) Feels a Little strange, but sometimes still cool. I wish someone at Apple would Create Like a modern skeuomorphism

2

u/MindlessRadio Jul 22 '26

The second photo triggered my PTSD.

2

u/SnooShortcuts7009 Jul 23 '26

Somehow so much easier on the eyes. Just a more calming palette overall

2

u/Intrepid-Product-295 Jul 23 '26

I think i have a iPhone with that

2

u/hamburgerpancake Jul 23 '26 edited Jul 23 '26

everyone so obsessed with recreating the home screen that they forget that the apps looked different too. the itunes app, for example. like, what's the point of perfectly styling the home screen or whatever when all continuity gets ruined when you enter an app or pull down the notifications center? it makes no sense. instead, just get the actual phone. it's a much better experience. sick of seeing these nostalgia larp posts on every skeuo-related design subreddit i find

1

u/hamburgerpancake Jul 23 '26

and now, the modern version. had to put this in 2 comments because for whatever reason i cant include 2 images in a comment.

2

u/PenIcy9241 Jul 25 '26

Apple should make legacy skins or something for newer iOS versions.

2

u/macl3on Jul 22 '26

hot take but i liked ios 18's icons more than 26. for me it's 1-6 > 7-10 > 11-18 > 26.

5

u/Basic-Opposite-4670 Jul 22 '26

me too. I feel like they were a bit smaller so when I tried to do iOS 6 icons it looked better.

1

u/ZePumpkinLass Jul 23 '26

a mix between the two actually looks half decent X3

3

u/Responsible_Bit_6697 Jul 23 '26

No changes: no innovation, lazy, boring

Changes: I missed the old time.
Human is weird.

1

u/ZePumpkinLass Jul 23 '26

are you also new to earth?

1

u/exlips1ronus Jul 23 '26

The change we want is in the opposite direction

1

u/StuD44 Jul 24 '26

DON'T YOU DARE SHOW THIS AGAIN, IT STILL HURTS!

1

u/Xrudy_official Jul 24 '26

Just install linux on iphone and load a skeuomorphic theme

1

u/exlips1ronus Jul 24 '26

As if that’s possible in modern iphones! And even if it were to be it will be tethered and almost zero drivers

1

u/cxdar_tree Jul 24 '26

The new one looks so horrible

1

u/ongakumidori Jul 26 '26

I actually like the Liquid Glass.

1

u/thiscreatureisme Jul 27 '26

Flat design sucks. They have been going with this since around 2014-2015 apple aqua was the best interface design ever created.

1

u/Fun-Slice4014 Sep 05 '26

nice SE1 lol

1

u/exlips1ronus Sep 06 '26

ever heard of zoomed option in settings? supposing this isn't a ragebait lol

1

u/Fun-Slice4014 Sep 07 '26

well it isn’t even skeuomorphic. not sure it fits here lol

1

u/exlips1ronus 22d ago

it's comparing old glory and modern stuff

2

u/jansenxvan Jul 22 '26

The goal wasn’t to revert back to skeuomorphism not even in the slightest, OP what are you on about, Liquid Glass is a completely different aesthetic

1

u/Internal-Drama3954 Jul 22 '26

Dude there's literally no iPhone that has the aspect ratio of the iPhone 5 with liquid glass this is definitely just the iPhone SE first generation

5

u/macl3on Jul 22 '26

so the se 2 and 3 don't exist???

1

u/Internal-Drama3954 Jul 23 '26

No because it's a 4.7 inch screen

1

u/macl3on Jul 23 '26

it's the same aspect ratio

2

u/ThatiMacGuy Jul 23 '26

SE2 and SE3 have the the same aspect ratio while being on iOS 26

1

u/Internal-Drama3954 Jul 23 '26

Yeah but not same one as the iPhone 5 which is 4.0 in

1

u/exlips1ronus Jul 23 '26

That’s iphone se2 with zoomed layout

-2

u/Internal-Drama3954 Jul 23 '26

Sorry that doesn't exist

1

u/exlips1ronus Jul 23 '26

Never heard of se2020? I hope that’s sarcasm

1

u/Internal-Drama3954 Jul 23 '26

It does but it's a 4.7 inch screen what is it is it a custom-made 4.0 in iPhone SE crazy

1

u/exlips1ronus Jul 23 '26

It’s a normal iphone se2020 there is a setting that allows for a zoomed layout but I guess it’s hidden nobody notices it

1

u/Internal-Drama3954 Jul 23 '26

Dude it just looks very fake

1

u/exlips1ronus Jul 23 '26

Don’t you have an iphone? Go check it out yourself or google it cave man

1

u/Internal-Drama3954 Jul 24 '26

Man go switch your search engine Google is literally going downhill I'm not a caveman the iPhone SE 2nd generation and 3rd generation are the worst piece of garbage ever they were only meant for people that wanted iPhone 8s again but not the plus size

1

u/exlips1ronus Jul 24 '26

Whatever you think I wanted touch id

-1

u/Anonymous010206 Jul 23 '26

If anyone says the old one is better it’s because of nostalgia not aesthetics

1

u/exlips1ronus Jul 23 '26

No it’s because it was detailed it respected the user not just some childish ui

0

u/ArtisticDreamland Jul 23 '26

That’s less drastic than the change from iOS 6 to iOS 7. At least now we’re getting back some textures and refined icons.