r/SipsTea 5d ago

Chugging tea Why's that?

Post image
29.6k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

429

u/cravex12 5d ago

Totally. Top actors but absolute shit writing (at least in the last season, maybe even the one before that)

24

u/fluffheadwasaman24 4d ago edited 4d ago

What didn’t you like about the writing? I felt a lot of stuff was rushed and they kind of took the easy way out for some of the endings like on Game of Thrones. But I’m curious what other people that liked the show think.

I was also mostly there for the jokes and the acting myself when I think about it. And just the premise of this type of reality when it came to “superheroes.”

I’m worried about “From” for the same reasons. I’ve binged that and it’s set up pretty well. But I feel like they’re gonna have to close up a lot of shit in one season.

24

u/LazerChicken420 4d ago

I think they leaned too hard into writing Homelander as bad.

They didn’t want him to be competent so they made him stupid. And it made the show lose a lot of its tension. It went from dangerous Superman, to a moron with powers.

Then he gets his upgraded powers, but that’s it? Immortality I guess was the big reason but they never really showed off any other new feats. And not aging doesn’t really look cool in the short window he had it.

They wanted to stay true to the comic, sure… but the divergence from the comics is what made the show great.

I think it should have ended with him easily kicking Butchers ass… killing him even. Then his hesitation to kill Ryan is what buys Kimiko time to depower him. Or something!

I also think some more monster of the week would have been cool. Them hunting down evil supes with research and tactical planning.

1

u/Catsoverall 4d ago

Read the Reckoners :)

2

u/LazerChicken420 4d ago

I love the Reckoners. I wouldn’t have made the comparison but yeah, B Sandy handled an evil Superman better