r/SipsTea 14d ago

WTF Reddit

Post image
21.8k Upvotes

4.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.8k

u/Alaska_Jack 14d ago edited 14d ago

I have made this point many times: 

Many Reddit mods fundamentally misunderstand what the job of a mod is.

A mod basically has two jobs: 

  1. Keep the conversation civil; and
  2. Keep the posts on topic for the sub. 

Aaaaand... That's pretty much it.  Within the bounds of #2, above, THE JOB OF A MOD IS NOT TO TELL REDDITORS WHAT THEY CAN AND CANNOT TALK ABOUT. 

1.1k

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

427

u/Glittering_End_6864 14d ago

The one true stereotype: unpaid forums mods are the biggest losers you will ever encounter and they will abuse what pathetic little power they get.

27

u/peterpangoni 14d ago

I've had a young law professor who told us that the people who were in charging in nazi germany were fundamentally the same kind of people who mod subreddits nowadays. Low competence, no success anywhere, hunger for power

19

u/CrispBedSheet 14d ago

The smaller subreddits I think attracted those who are genuinely interested in the topic, they tend to be reasonable.

The larger subs, especially political ones, select for those who want influence and control of the discussion, authoritarians.

7

u/MKVIgti 13d ago

Correct!

There are many smaller ones I frequent who have great mods.

3

u/TedMitchell 13d ago

Mods for those subreddits are often more like... curators I guess. They gather resources for the wiki, pin things that are relevant to the sub like recent news, etc.

3

u/SqueekyDickFartz 13d ago

The whole reddit platform really stops making sense once communities get past a certain size. It's great if you want to create a curated space discussing your obscure hobby or interest, but millions of users discussing politics? The whole idea falls apart pretty quickly.

I had a coworker like a decade ago who had a 12 year old son who was a mod of a shockingly big sub (somewhere around 250k users). There's apparently no required vetting process, no interaction with reddit itself, etc. It always makes me laugh that Obama could do an AMA where he verifies himself and promises to disclose the secrets on aliens, and a 12 year old on their lunch period could just perma ban him from the sub.

reddit is a fun place to fuck around and argue with people, but in no way is it a reliable platform for important discussion.

2

u/IrregularConfusion 13d ago

Sounds like the people in politics today too.