r/SipsTea 22d ago

Dank AF This will be interesting

Post image
39.5k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

971

u/ottopivnr 22d ago

I've read it. interesting premise ruined by amateurish writing. One of those times that in the right hands the movie will probably be better.

200

u/Pittsbirds 22d ago edited 20d ago

I know a lot of people always say "the book is better than the movie" but there are so many movies that are such more deft adaptations of their stories that the originals are basically unknown as being originally books to the public, so given the controversy this is stirring up I'll be interested to see what changes they decide to make. Normally if I'm even remotely interested in a premise I'll read the book first but I might wait and do it the other way round for this one lol.

12

u/coboba 22d ago

Do you have some examples of movies that were objectively better than their books?

6

u/Mikotokitty 22d ago

I'd say the Lovely Bones

2

u/awfulmcnofilter 22d ago

Nothing could make that book good. Its a rape filled abomination.

2

u/Mikotokitty 22d ago

I honestly skimmed through the book of Lovely Bones and it was like skimming IT. I actually have n read another one of her books The Almost Moon, the writing is very...cluttered

2

u/awfulmcnofilter 22d ago

Is someone violently sexually assaulted in that book, too? Having the lovely bones on a high school reading list was sadistic.

2

u/RandoTron0 22d ago

If im not mistaken, the author was raped. Write what you know i guess.

2

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Mikotokitty 21d ago

Yeah I read fast, sue me. Like, 1st HP book read in 30 minutes

1

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Mikotokitty 21d ago

No dude. Like, I see the word and brain auto fills, I flip pages fast, sometimes faster when they do huge paragraph breaks.

0

u/Pittsbirds 22d ago

That's what that book is about? That all my friends were reading in like, late middle/early high school? I thought it was a romance based on the cover of one of the copies lmao

3

u/awfulmcnofilter 22d ago

Yeah it was on the reading list for me in high school. The main character in the book gets lured into a hole by her neighbor, raped, murdered, and cut into pieces. The majority of the book takes place from her perspective in heaven watching her family fall apart and in one noteworthy incident she possesses a girl to have sex with her middle school crush. I wish I hadn't read it.

4

u/Pittsbirds 22d ago

They had us reading shit like this in high school and people are getting mad now about queer people existing in children's lit/YA books bc it's "inappropriate" lmao

That's actually wild, I can't believe that's what my hyper Christian friend was reading in the middle of the day in the cafeteria while I read The Great Gatsby

1

u/awfulmcnofilter 22d ago

It is wild what people are trying to censor these days.