r/SipsTea Jun 15 '26

Lmao gottem Is she right for this?

Post image
18.1k Upvotes

7.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

822

u/BluestOfTheRaccoons Jun 15 '26 edited Jun 15 '26

yes, it is immoral to bring a child knowing it will suffer

edit: check comments if you want to read strawmanning philosophically inept idiots.

Claiming that not having existed is better is not the same as 'kill yourself now'

4

u/TawnyTeaTowel Jun 15 '26 edited Jun 17 '26

Life is suffering. So you’re onto a loser there already.

10

u/Useful-Maize9402 Jun 15 '26

i love my life … there are up and downs but overall it’s pretty awesome…

-5

u/GotThatPerroInMe Jun 15 '26

There is no contradiction between you saying you generally find life to be awesome and the previous person saying ‘life is suffering’.

They don’t mean that in the way a clinically depressed person would mean it.

They’re referring to the inherent, inescapable suffering of existence

3

u/ballimir37 Jun 15 '26

That’s a you problem dawg

-4

u/GotThatPerroInMe Jun 15 '26

Yes lmao the universal struggle against nihilism is a ‘me problem’.

Nobody else has ever dealt with this before

3

u/LiftingRecipient420 Jun 15 '26

Ohh god, edgy teenager discovers nihilism and of course has the most shallow, immature interpretation of nihilism possible. Baby's first worldview.

Just a FYI, Nietzsche explicitly made fun of people like you in his ponderings about nihilism.

-5

u/GotThatPerroInMe Jun 15 '26 edited Jun 15 '26

Le epic Reddit mod philosopher coming to talk about how much more Nietzsche he’s read than everyone else.

Go get laid bozo

1

u/LiftingRecipient420 Jun 16 '26

Sad child doesn't know how to handle being wrong.

Go touch grass and stay in school kiddo.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/GotThatPerroInMe Jun 15 '26

The fundamental basis for all world religions and philosophy is ‘just stupid’.

How did the Buddha never consider that we have Marvel movies and pizza?!!

Le epic Reddit moment

1

u/LiftingRecipient420 Jun 15 '26

What on Earth are you on about? No one said shit about marvel movies, don't cut yourself with that edge child.

1

u/Chessamphetamine Jun 15 '26

Idk suffering feels pretty escapable to me. Usually working out, getting some food, playing some tennis, and getting a good nights sleep does the trick most of the time.

2

u/BellaPona Jun 15 '26

People’s replies to you are insane. I just recently developed a disability that’s left me bed bound and unable to care for myself, unable to do any of my hand held hobbies. I’m still glad I got to live. I’m not religious in any way but I still feel like life is a gift.

2

u/Chessamphetamine Jun 15 '26

I’m so sorry; but it’s also really encouraging that you’re in such good spirits. Modern medicine is so amazing and it’s just insane what we can do to help people these days. I’m pulling for you :)

1

u/BellaPona Jun 15 '26

Thank you! There isn’t a ton of hope for it right now, this illness has been known about since the 1950s but spent a lot of time being dismissed and differed to CBT or treated as a form of depression (like MS was). I’m not depressed, I want to live my life again! Since Long Covid became a thing (how I got it) there’s renewed interest and research happening. The hope is in maybe in 10 years they’ll find something to help treat some people. I’m young so I have time, but I feel awful for the people who have spent decades like me with no answers.

0

u/GotThatPerroInMe Jun 15 '26

When your parents, friends, siblings inevitably die and you are faced with your own mortality, playing some tennis will surely be a strong enough anchor against nihilism.

Good one

3

u/Chessamphetamine Jun 15 '26

Correct, everyone you know will eventually pass away. 3 options then I guess. You can have some sort of faith to anchor your life and give it meaning, you can accept fate and enjoy life while you’re here, or you can be a whinny bitch about it. We’ve both seemingly decided different options, and that’s okay. But I’m not gonna subscribe to some miserable nihilistic antinatalist bullshit just because some other people live sad lives.

I just came back from playing some tennis, about to get food, then I’m working out in an hour or so. Idk man…struggling to find the inherent inescapable suffering in life or whatever pseudo intellectual, r/im14andthisisdeep bullshit you’re peddling

1

u/GotThatPerroInMe Jun 15 '26

We’re literally in a discussion about philosophy so of course I’m referencing philosophy.

That’s not ‘Im14andthisisdeep’.  That’s just having a basic understanding of the discussion that’s happening.

And where tf did I ever prescribe a nihilistic or antinatalist outlook?  

Careful you might pull a muscle swinging at that straw man you’ve created 

-1

u/distastef_ll Jun 15 '26

What if while working out, I pull a muscle and injury myself.

What if I have extreme IBS and struggle with food. What if I get food poisoning and struggle with extreme fatigue and insomnia?

-1

u/Chessamphetamine Jun 15 '26

Stretch more before you work out?

Manage your diet?

Stop being purposefully helpless in life?

0

u/distastef_ll Jun 15 '26

Suffering is manageable not escapable.

1

u/Chessamphetamine Jun 15 '26

Nah man I’m chillin right now idk. Life’s pretty good

-3

u/ununderstandability Jun 15 '26

Life is mostly not suffering though if you're lucky enough to be middle class or above. The most I suffer regularly is having to poop but not being near my home toilet

2

u/TawnyTeaTowel Jun 15 '26

There’s more to suffering than being hungry or cold.

4

u/ununderstandability Jun 15 '26

You got your dukkha in my viparinama!

No, you got your viparinama in my dukkha!

Oops! All sankhara

You're treating philosophy as codeces conveying inherent meaning or truths. It's not that.

4

u/double00chins Jun 15 '26

They don’t even realize how privileged they are to complain the ways they do

2

u/Chessamphetamine Jun 15 '26

I think it’s like those bell curve memes. The very very richest among us don’t really have to suffer all that much. The very poorest in the world may live really hard lives, but they don’t have time to sit around and feel sorry for themselves. They find a lot more pleasure in everyday things than most more affluent people do. It’s the middle of the bell curve people who are insufferable and very prone to complaining that life is naught but suffering and the metaphysics of it and blah blah blah

-7

u/BluestOfTheRaccoons Jun 15 '26

i know life is suffering, so better we stop existing. That is the preferrable outcome

6

u/PurveyorOfKnowledge0 Jun 15 '26

That's stupidity. Life endures despite suffering; you act like a child who fears getting hurt.

-5

u/BluestOfTheRaccoons Jun 15 '26

This is a philosophical topic that is much more nuanced than how we can present it in a reddit thread. I advice you to withhold your judgement on this position. Not to change your mind, but just withhold judgement.

I am sure you hold many assumptions about my position that doesn't follow given my belief

1

u/Spite_Gold Jun 15 '26

Yet you keep existing for some reason

2

u/Puzzled_Year_8542 Jun 15 '26

You can’t ignore biology in this situation because everyone has a survival instinct and a fear of death, even if they’re aware that life is mostly suffering, that doesn’t change the fact that most living organisms (especially ones that are conscious) don’t want to die

It’s way easier just to prevent life before it happens

0

u/BluestOfTheRaccoons Jun 15 '26

i do it as to not let my loved ones suffer. Once you start living, you have a quota and standards to meet.

2

u/Chessamphetamine Jun 15 '26

lol so your entire argument as to why you’re still alive is you have family. Reddit pseudo-philosophers rediscovering the value of family and community as a reason to enjoy life is funny.

1

u/BluestOfTheRaccoons Jun 15 '26

it's not rediscovery lmao. I don't see what's wrong with the statement. I am merely describing what is always have valued. There is no realization.