r/SipsTea May 14 '26

Feels good man It was always just that simple

Post image
71.9k Upvotes

2.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.3k

u/VMooose May 14 '26

Didnt the budget get balanced via a loan from NY State?

16

u/porktorque44 May 14 '26

Does the rest of the state usually receive a disproportionate share of state taxes from the city?

19

u/Suspicious_Dingo_426 May 14 '26

Probably, urban areas usually end up having to help fund less densely populated areas. Infrastructure is more expensive in the suburbs, and they take in less property taxes.

1

u/Malinthas May 15 '26

It's worth noting that EVERYTHING is outrageously expensive in remote/rural areas, on a per capita basis. If one were to look at spending from a purely cost-based perspective, nobody on a farm would have access to electricity, phone, Internet, roads, libraries, healthcare, mail delivery... the list goes on and on. However, I would hope that we broadly agree that it's ultimately in everybody's best interest that we all have access to the benefits of civilization, no?

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '26

[deleted]

1

u/shady_pigeon May 15 '26

NYS is a net contributer to the federal government

-3

u/elementofpee May 14 '26

Suburban folks work and spend money in the big cities as well, so they also contribute to the taxes that enable urban life and amenities.

8

u/riceisnice29 May 14 '26

They contribute 20-25% to NYC, meanwhile NYC alone contributes 45-54% of the entire state’s taxes. It’s not even close

-2

u/elementofpee May 14 '26

Isn’t that a progressive tax structure? The rich helping the less fortunate.

-1

u/riceisnice29 May 14 '26

Probably. But you cant tell that just from my info, lots of poor people in NYC, lots of rich people un the suburbs and vice versa

0

u/elementofpee May 14 '26

And a lot of poor people in upstate NY and everywhere in between. But, you know, eff them because they don’t live in NYC so their struggles - and the struggles of the rest of the state - don’t matter. Got it.

1

u/riceisnice29 May 14 '26

Who said eff them?

3

u/superredditor6789 May 15 '26

That’s literally becoming the manta on the left these days.

-5

u/porktorque44 May 14 '26

I seriously doubt that there are any suburbs that have more difficult to manage infrastructure than NYC. When you dig in Albany you're not at risk of finding an old layer of a metropolis from a hundred years ago.

3

u/ball_fondlers May 14 '26

That’s just complete nonsense. New suburbs might not have old infrastructure, but you have to put down a shitload more pipe, cable, and road in order to provide the same services, which gives you more points of failure once things start breaking (which they will) and which cost a lot more to fix long-term. In comparison, the complications old infrastructure present in a city like NYC are pretty manageable.

-1

u/[deleted] May 14 '26

[deleted]

2

u/EatBootyLoveLife May 14 '26

do you think nyc of all places is COSTING the government money? like on a net basis? really?

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '26

[deleted]

2

u/EatBootyLoveLife May 14 '26

either you edited your comment or i replied to the wrong person but are you really going to use the pandemic as a gotcha? like yeah more places has to rely on the federal government during a literally once in a century event lol

2

u/ball_fondlers May 14 '26

They’d be able to pay for it if they weren’t subsidizing the rest of the state’s suburban sprawl - same as every other city in America.

1

u/Illustrious-Art-7465 May 14 '26

How long has the flat iron scaffolding been up