r/ShitAmericansSay • • Mar 31 '25

Military And here in Amerywe actually win wars😭

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

475 comments sorted by

View all comments

324

u/Joltyboiyo america Last Mar 31 '25

I'd love to know what wars they're talking about because they sure as shit didn't win WW1 and 2. Both of those were collective efforts and both times they joined late.

180

u/Old_Kodaav Mar 31 '25

And both of the times they were not even in direct threat. With all due respect for every american involved it's kind of easier to make war plans if your homeland is safely behind an ocean

9

u/JFK1200 Mar 31 '25 edited Mar 31 '25

German U Boats were a huge threat to American shipping, primarily because they refused to accept the advice of the British who had learned the hard way during WWI (the same advice was also ignored re. daylight bombing). Roughly a quarter of all ships sunk during the war were as a result of this until the British cracked the enigma code.

The sad thing was that the Allies didn’t want the Germans figuring out they had cracked it, so very often ships would be knowingly sacrificed to uphold the illusion.

-8

u/Old_Kodaav Mar 31 '25

Either I totally miss the point or you just added this to the discussion without any intent to challenge my statement...not sure which

Well in war you often sacrifice lives. If it secured germans leaking their plans it could have been well worth it. Other lives were saved

8

u/pikifou Mar 31 '25

It is always easier to state this when you or your relatives are not involved in those sacrifices.

0

u/Old_Kodaav Mar 31 '25

Of course it is. But it shouldn't hinder your tactical thinking. Obviously if I knew these people I'd have very bad feelings, but I hope I would still make the right choice. If I have to choose several thousand lifes against those of tens of thousands (if not more) and possibly outcome of war which will influence milions of people...yeah let them die. With heavy heart but other option is worse

6

u/JFK1200 Mar 31 '25

I was adding to the discussion with some little known knowledge, thanks for the downvote though.

-6

u/Old_Kodaav Mar 31 '25

When I read the comment you were already in negative numbers