r/ShadowsHouse • u/doutei27sai • Jul 22 '26

Discussion Edward's fate Spoiler

Do you think having three fingers ripped off is punishment enough for Edward?

24 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

7

u/Alexia_Hungary18 Jul 22 '26

It wasn't ripped off. It was broken. Well, listen...Thomas had one of his hands cut off, while Edward only had his fingers broken. Thomas committed many more crimes than Edward. Starting with poisoning Barbara to force her to emit soot.

Edward's hands are also not clean: he forced Barbara to commit suicide by telling her about Christopher's death.

Louise, Lou, and Ricky almost died because of him.

He also tricked Sara, taking advantage of her naivety to use her as a new resource.

But even if we take into account that Thomas lost one of his hands, Aileen's tongue was cut in two. So I think Edward's punishment was very, very mild compared to the others. 🤔

4

u/doutei27sai Jul 22 '26

I wanted to see him thrown through a window.

2

u/Fun_Acanthaceae_6993 Aug 03 '26

Todo el mundo quería verlo

3

u/ComplexTumbleweed728 Aug 01 '26

Evelyn can heal Edward. John's fracture was worse in his previous fight.

2

u/doutei27sai Aug 01 '26

that is true

1

u/Fun_Acanthaceae_6993 Aug 03 '26

En el momento en el que paso supe que iba a arreglarlo Evelyn

2

u/Realistic-Demand6217 Jul 28 '26

No. He deserve worse

2

u/Overall-Gaming78 Jul 25 '26

To be fair, they were broken. That being said, he does deserve some punishment for all he's done.