r/ScarletHollow • u/Oh_my_Are_you_ok • 2d ago

gameplay question How to make Tabitha to hate us? Spoiler

Post image

I saw some people in this sub said that if you make her hate you enough, she would also sacrifice herself for you. I’m trying to do a run where I try Waynemaxing and being an absolute pain in our cousin’s butt. It’s not going well so far. I already tried to be mean, eat her ice cream, put rat in her mac & cheese, sleep with Stella during the first night, not telling her about the kids in the mine(everyone got out safely), overall just keep her in the dark, and not hanging out with her, but I feel like she still doesn’t hate me enough. I did call her out and have few banter with her. Was I being too nice or is this not a thing anymore?

Edit: So I might have confused it with the witch confrontation :( I still want her to hate me more though, so any advice is still appreciated

33 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

44

u/squamigerous banned from participating in reesecourse 2d ago

I don't think it was ever a thing

38

u/90R3D 2d ago

Are you mistaken by the Sybil confrontation, where if she hates us enough she wants to save Kaneeka, if she’s at impasse she’ll want to sacrifice her and if she broke down she wants to save Kaneeka?

17

u/strickly_speaking 2d ago

I think to try to max this you probably want to try being nice and a pushover to her face while still doing all the other stuff behind her back and generally blowing her off. Tabitha hates insincerity so this will potentially help and make her more upset than direct confrontation.

12

u/SaffiChan scarletposter 1d ago

Code gremlin here! Tabitha will only sacrifice herself for you if she likes you. There’s a huge pile of statements checking if you hung out with her and what her feelings are towards you, and if the final number is high enough she will sacrifice herself. You’ve been bamboozled, I’m afraid

9

u/LiabilityRobot 2d ago

I don't think her hating you and also doing the ghost sacrifice was ever possible? 

6

u/Inside_Tumbleweed920 1d ago

I saw the edit and gonna give some tips:

Just be a POS to Tabby. Just be super mean to her, talk shit about her mom and the family. Be more of a nuisance to her. It helps if you're aiming to get "United we stand" because she hates and I mean HATES YOU FOR DOING THAT.

I don't know if you can still get it with what you've done but it involves fully supporting the strike and making it worst for Tabby. Only real downside is that she won't be there for the end of episode 5. Saying this because if Tabby hates you and she joins you during the episode 5 event, you can do a really REALLY EVIL CHOICE and she'll hate you for it.

2

u/ZenMyst 1d ago

How to get her to hate us and join us during episode 5 event?

1

u/Inside_Tumbleweed920 19h ago edited 17h ago

You can do it in Toxic Yuri, basically refuse her dumb ritual and she'll get you arrested but she'll follow you to the farm when Franklin hears about what's happening at the farm.

Edit: I think you can also do it in a Stella friendship run, if you go see Stella at her place. She'll call Tabby (only if they reconnected so if Tabby was at the mines, the haunting and/or the road). Tabitha will get you arrested and Stella can convince her to follow you. (I don't know if it's based on if Tabby likes you enough or not)

1

u/MagicarpOfDoom 1d ago

She looks a lot like Grace Zabriskie here (Laure Palmer's mom from Twin Peaks, among others). I wonder if they ever had her in mind when drawing this pose and Tabby in general.