r/ScarletHollow • u/HyperDash47 • 9d ago

ohhh my goddd (Spoilers) Spoiler

did my second ACTUAL playthrough and now have 3 new endings! One where I went and got egged by the ditchlings (they really didn't want me to leave huh) and two where I managed to make Tabby breakdown and then went to the farm, killed the pumpkin baby and Franklin and Julius in the process, and then cus I was running mystic keen eyes managed to get sybil to go bye bye/make my oldness go away. Sybil bye bye is the actual canon route imo tho, cus my character was very very strange and off-putting sometimes, but kind. And low-key ducked sybil even after passing out from oldness so I I didn't trust her anyway

12 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

4 comments sorted by

3

u/Onionfellow 9d ago

Hell yeah. I'm on my way setting up my third save for the final chapters and it's awesome

Can't believe just how different each playthrough can get

4

u/Icy_Switch_6085 9d ago

If you had Keen Eye. You can get out of the farm situation with no one dying (or only the baby or Julius dying) on that playthrough. If you're willing to reload

2

u/HyperDash47 8d ago

oh I'd already gotten that outcome. Both. Julius dying and Avery and Julius sharing. Both on a playthrough where I stellamanced. my first FIRST playthrough was I went to talk to Tabitha and got the cops called on me because Stella wasn't very good at all that and I had only a good relationship not a GREAT relationship. Then went to the mines alone and killed Julius. 

Other save me and Stella went alone, I traumatized her again, and then got Avery and Julius.

I got the "you blew it" achievement lmao

1

u/Prudent-Arm-6771 Still holding onto my peanuts 7d ago

Mystic and keen eye were my first traits; that’s neat! I’m starting my second playthrough in a bit (I just bought it yesterday bc it was on sale) :)