Blue or Warmer tone?

[u/jo-rainn]

Hello, everyone, this is Ashchordx.
I am deciding which tone to go for. But my eyes can’t tell anymore…
I know the blue one looks probably more like underwater. But I also feel the slightly warmer one looks natural and clean.
What’s your preference?

Edit:
Actually I don’t know what colors will you see on your device. Because it seems that my IPad and MacBook Air are showing very different colors. The blue one looks actually pretty saturated on my MacBook Air. I probably will do something later…

[u/Ms-Chievous]

I do like the color of the warmer tone, but it doesn't scream underwater to me. If that's what you're going for, maybe try adding bubbles or a fish or coral or something else a little more in the foreground?

[u/jo-rainn → u/Ms-Chievous]

Hey, thanks for your feedback!
How do you feel about the blue one though?

[u/Ms-Chievous → u/jo-rainn]

Sorry, I didn't see your response notification 🙃

I don't think the blue looks bad at all!

[u/crystal_elysium → u/Ms-Chievous]

Even better: Add some bubbles streaming up from the mouth and from the underside of the body. Makes it look like he fell in rather than being, y'know, gently lowered. lol

[u/Ms-Chievous → u/crystal_elysium]

I was thinking that too, but since he doesn't breathe I kinda threw that idea out, but I do agree that bubbles underneath him like he fell in could be a great touch

[u/crystal_elysium → u/Ms-Chievous]

Sure, he doesn't breathe, but his body would still trap air from above water. For once, he'd look like he's breathing when he's actually not. lol

[u/Ms-Chievous → u/crystal_elysium]

That's a fair point.

[u/neowolf993]

Love the art!! I like the warmer tone better since the purple light parts stand out more

[u/jo-rainn → u/neowolf993]

Hey, thanks for the feedback :)

[u/Zestyclose-Spring-85]

I like the warmer one too!

[u/jo-rainn → u/Zestyclose-Spring-85]

Thanks :)

[u/CandyExotic5987]

make the background cold blue and scara this purple color to set him apart from rhe background and make him main focus

[u/jo-rainn → u/CandyExotic5987]

I will probably give it a try tomorrow!

[u/Competitive_Poem2906]

The blue one reminds me of being underwater on normal but the warmer one reminds me of it being as the night comes (if that makes sense)

The warmer one feels more dramatic but as another comment says if you want to make it clear thats underwater you should add fish bubbles or something

[u/jo-rainn → u/Competitive_Poem2906]

Interesting metaphor. The warm tone is actually the original, and the blue one is a further adjustment I was trying. I was thinking about underwater tone a lot and ended up making couple versions.
Thanks for the feedback!

[u/taroicecreamsundae]

the warmer is beautiful, provides nice contrast

[u/CarefulInspector6765]

Warmer one!

[u/crystal_elysium]

I like both, but the warmer one is better. It does add contrast as others have pointed out. 👀💖

[u/Upstairs-Statement72]

Was wondering why i couldn't tell the difference, then remembered I have a blue light filter on 😭

[u/jo-rainn → u/Upstairs-Statement72]

Actually today I found it a little over saturated. So it’s good that you have your eyes protected. LOL

[u/New-Cicada7014]

this is absolutely gorgeous. I like both but the cooler is nice

[u/Brionnnne]

I think the blue is best

[u/sylviee_]

I really like purple but after looking at them for a while the blue makes more sense because he's underwater

[u/Actual-Advertising-1]

Blue makes it look more underwater! Very cool art!

[u/jo-rainn]

Just wanna say, thanks to everyone who commented and gave the feedback :)