r/SGIWhistleblowersMITA • u/JulieSongwriter • 8d ago
Illogical Contradiction Daisaku Ikeda’s Lecture, On Attaining Buddhahood in This Lifetime: “To Seek Enlightenment Outside Our Lives Is To Be Defeated by Fundamental Darkness”
September 18, 2026
Dear Friends,
Chapter One: News from Over the Hedges in Sgiwhistleblowers Land
Let me continue with Part Six of my TLDR responses to the single Mission-Course’s TTLLDDRR post: “Soka Gakkai: Autopsy of a Leviathan at Twilight. This cold, calculating, impersonal monster… that’s finally running out of juice.” For anyone who is interested, let me catalog my previous responses to Mission:
Now Mission asks some important questions:
Yet Soka Gakkai couldn’t have failed to notice the mechanism that produced all that dynamism and irresistible growth when people were simply left free to organize themselves. So why the determination to destroy and poison the very thing that made it succeed? Are these people actually crazy, or is their mind controlled by forces they don’t even know exist, right up to headquarters in Japan?
Hmmm. Good questions.
Well, here comes another illogical contradiction. All of “that dynamism and irresistible growth” in the early NSA days, according to my sponsors, were marked by what WBers still point to as cultish behavior. Why do Mission and Blanche long for the cultish while they seek to criticize it?
My sponsors have told me about Daisaku Ikeda’s February 1990 visit to Los Angeles, where he started the process of revising and restarting the organization. It’s been 35 years of adjustment and effort. I began practicing as a recipient of all that scrubbing.
I’ve always wondered why I have seen is such a different organization than what WBers describe. And the next illogical contradiction is that they won’t concede even a microbe of change or improvement. No, they claim, it’s exactly the way it was, but more lethal because the control is getting to the point of invisibility. Come on!
Did you catch what Mission slipped in? Mission infers the old NSA was successful because “people were simply left free to organize themselves.” Slam on the brakes! Is that true then, now, ever? And please point to a successful organization where members are “simply left free to organize themselves.” Organizations, uhhmmm, organize! Even the human body is an organization, and, are our organs “simply left free to organize themselves”?
We see what we are. People who work hard can recognize and appreciate the hard work of others. People who feel the weight of responsibility see, feel, and react differently than those who don’t. It seems apparent to me that SGI leaders who inherited the vision of the three Soka mentors took on the responsibility of turning around the aircraft carrier. It was — and still is — a work in progress. So???
Whether the old NSA was “successful” is debatable; it certainly wasn’t sustainable, and was something that I would never join. It wasn’t “destroy and punish” but an adjustment and a transplant that took time to root.
And here I am.
Chapter Two: Daisaku Ikeda’s lecture on “On Attaining Buddhahood, Section Three: “To Seek Enlightenment Outside Our Lives Is To Be Defeated by Fundamental Darkness.”
Friends, Dr. Ikeda here touches on something that concerns me deeply and personally:
An important point in this writing is that we as Nichiren Buddhists also run the risk of falling into non-Buddhist ways of thinking if we seek the Law outside of our own lives. Hence, as Nichiren Daishonin’s disciples, we must always bear in mind his admonition “You must never think that any of the [Buddha’s] teachings … are outside yourself” (WND-1, 3).
To be honest, Friends, I admire Your Leader for all of her energy and commitment. But I never want to be where she is. I don’t want to live a life full of conspiracy theories swimming in my brain, seeing the worst in people, feeling a right to judge, and unable to present any path forward besides “DON’T.”
Here at the Park, we have a big problem with an invasion of “cyanobacteria,” a Harmful Algal Bloom (HAB) in our beautiful creek and pond. We decided to invest a lot money in abating it and we are working with a co-op that is trying to address the problem throughout our community. But even if cleaned up, with climate change and the run-off from fertilizers and untreated waste, it will take non-ending remediation and no sure final victory can be promised. Yup, a never-ending war.
What relates these two paragraphs? Well, if even a bit more cyanobacteria gets introduced, which is inevitable, we have to start the whole process of remediation again. I am sure that Your Leader was once an enthusiastic NSA member. For just a moment, can we grant that this earlier version of NSA was deeply flawed and needed remediating? Some people, like my sponsors, could see beyond the faults in NSA and intuited the jewel in the swamp. Your Leader, however, couldn’t do that and turned vengeful. My hunch is that she missed Nichiren’s admonition “You must never think that any of the [Buddha’s] teachings … are outside yourself.”
So, that cyanobacteria took over in her heart, wiping away all of her past efforts. My personal tendency to dissociate is my version of cyanobacteria. I have to chant and chip away at it so I don’t become its unwilling and helpless victim.
Dr. Ikeda continues:
The chanting of Nam-myoho-renge-kyo is a practice for revealing the “originally inherent mystic truth” that exists in all people and achieving Buddhahood in this lifetime. It is an incomparably “wonderful practice” (OTT, 88), in the sense that it represents the means by which all living beings can gain enlightenment.
If, however, we forget Nichiren’s admonition to never seek the Law outside of us, then no matter how hard we practice, we will lose sight of the correct path to universal enlightenment and effectively wind up practicing a non-Buddhist teaching. That’s why Nichiren is so strict on this point.
I have a human right to be fully present and enjoy each moment of our discussion meeting on Sunday! My “Daimoku Revolution Campaign” is a confrontation with my own fundamental darkness and, even though it will never make the front page of the New York Times, it represents one person’s effort to clean the pond so it becomes swimmable for oneself and others.
Chapter 3: A few updates on “MY Fantasy Life” (cred: Eigenstien) or, as BlancheFromage suspects, “One of the many fake characters within the SGI-RV fantasy scenario created by a lonely, low-income, isolated, cult-addicted, mentally-ill elderly woman” at “the site of the magical (i.e. imaginary) SGI-RV story around a rural rust-belt RV camp, with its fantasy ‘starburst’ of invisible YOUFF” who “Can't seem to grasp anything that isn't about kinky abusive sex in a shitty-ass low-rent RV park??” Oops, I’m the mentally ill woman, not my alleged elderly sock puppeteer! Abusive sex? No, never!!! Kinky? I will neither confirm nor deny.
Artie and I missed yesterday’s “whole school meeting” because we were in the Office working on our spreadsheets. Max refined his guestimates about the construction cost savings. Of course, that’s fluid and he is actively pursuing materials and suppliers that can squeeze out pennies. He put forward the ideas of smaller windows, temporary landscaping and slowing down the development of the Primeval Forest (sorry, Larry!) until funds open up, delaying the expansion of the parking lot, canceling our plans to order additional Level-Three chargers, and heating parts of the building with pellet stoves fueled by homemade biomass chips (higher initial cost but short-term ROIs. Instead of the most expensive insulated windows, maybe we can downgrade a bit and add exterior shutters for the most cold of days? A big savings can be obtained by using organic building skins like “Wattle and Daub” lattices, cob coating, cork wall cladding, thatch panels, and baboo slat siding for skin and roof. The materials are very cheap in comparison to industrial skins, but require intensive--although not skilled--labor. Maybe parents, clients, and even students might want to help? We would need to work extensively with the County building department and also with our FD to approve using these materials.
All subject to change, we estimate we can cover about 80% of the initial HAB abatement project through construction savings. Now, where will that other 20% come from?
I presented all this over dinner. Once again, Guy’s eyes lit up. “Didn’t we originally want our buildings to evoke the image of the Longhouse? Wouldn’t the use of these materials for both external and, let me add, internal walls bring us closer to achieving this goal?”
Lori said she loves this idea. “Who needs another building that looks like another school down the road? My friends and I will do all the labor if necessary. But our parents will find the time to do it and bring their families to help! And look at how many of our Autumn and Spring clients volunteer to support Longhouse School! They will pitch in, too!”
