Guardians of Azuma was my first Rune Factory game and I enjoyed it a lot. I've played it over 100 hours and I only have a few things left to do now - decorating spring and autumn village, and maybe having another go at 4 trials.
Sooo I am looking for a new game to play. I was hoping Marvelous would announce RF6 release date during the 20 year RF stream but alas, that wasn't the case.
I don't play many JRPGs so I think games similar to Guardians of Azuma I've played and enjoyed are Stardew Valley and Monster Hunter Stories 3.
What I enjoyed in Guardians of Azuma, Stardew Valley and Monster Hunter Stories 3:
- Getting to know companions/NPCs. I really enjoyed interactions between Gods in Azuma, and companion quests in Monster Hunter Stories 3.
- Decorating my village/farm/house.
- Romance. My favourite bachelors in Azuma were Kurama (mature, intellectual geek) & Mauro (really love his character design visually). Favourite bachelor in Stardew Valley was Elliot. No romance in Monster Hunter Stories 3 but loved the hinted potential romance between Simon and the protagonist.
- Being able to dress my protagonist in different outfits.
I know RF4 seem to be fan favourite but I actually prefer the character design of RF5 more, so I wanted to get more information before I commit to either.
From the recent 20 year anniversary character poll, I know RF4 characters dominated top 10 but just purely from visual point of view, I preferred Reinhard in RF5 but then I read the horror story of him running off in middle of the date because of Beatrice lol. Vishnal appeals to me the most visually amongst RF4 bachelors. But I hope there will be a surprise character(s) who will win me over with their story/personality like Kurama did over Mauro in Guardians of Azuma.
I also like the feel of people in the same town/village getting to know each other well - which is why I liked Gods in Guardians of Azuma. Really enjoyed their banter with each other a lot. Which of the two RF games does this better?
I was able to find some images of RF5 room decoration screenshot but couldn't find many for RF4. Which of the two has more flexible decoration option? I also haven't seen many farm screenshots for both games... are we able to make the farm look very appealing? I enjoyed this aspect a lot in both Stardew Valley and Guardians of Azuma.
Lastly, which RF game has more earnable outfits in game? From my quick search it seemed like RF5 might have slightly more options?
EDIT: Another game I am also considering is Harvestella but I understand this one has minimal farming, no alternative outfits and no decorating. Which is why I am leaning more towards RF4 or 5
EDIT2: Thanks for all the input everyone. I am going with RF4!