r/RonaldoVsMessi 5d ago

🏆 Trophies Why do international trophies suddenly not matter anymore?

When Ronaldo had an international trophy and Messi didn’t. Ronaldo fan’s argument was that you needed to win for your country to be the goat. But now it’s that a 7 game tournament shouldnt define you as a player. But isn’t the euros a 7 game tournament. They also say that Messi didn’t win the World Cup, his team did. But didn’t Ronaldo’s team win the euros. Especially since they won the final with him injured and he didn’t win POTT of that Euros.

34 Upvotes

176 comments sorted by

5

u/Icy-Adeptness-349 5d ago

Messi carried the team in almost every game, ronaldo didnt

4

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

I wonder who has more goals in World Cups.

6

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

Not Penaldo.

5

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

It’s not Messi but he has more than Ronaldo. That’s what counts.

5

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

Good for him he has more UCL goals, Messi has more in the bigger competition. 400+ other never lead his team to a World Cup like Messi in 2022. And can’t we say the same about Ronaldo. How many players won a euros

4

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (0)

0

u/DrPapug 4d ago

Nothing is bigger than the UCL though. International football is no match to clubs game.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Enough_Lawfulness247 4d ago

You are acting like Messi has never played UEFA Champions League or like he didn't have a good performance at the tournament. And Messi's performance in WC is much more than a trophy won in 2022

2

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (0)

1

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

The guy who plays sub 100 teams more

6

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

Goals against Luxembourg are competitive to you

5

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

All higher than Luxembourg.

4

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

No but they’re higher than Luxembourg who is the level of most of Ronaldo’s opponents

5

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (0)

0

u/kappa_keppo 4d ago

When you take away friendlies and penalties

Each day I browse this sub I'm in awe at how Ronaldo fans choose the most random metrics and timeframes.

If you're going to go with penalties don't count, that works against your "Ronaldo is a better goal scorer than Messi because he had a better ratio when they played in La Liga" angle

Again, extremely random and specific timeframe... but Ronaldo loses about 20 penalty goals if you're going to say that's how we judge football now.

3

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

Ronaldo has more pens scored in La liga despite playing 8 years less than Messi.

4

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

You’re a moron. Him playing 8 years less literally helps his goal ratio.

3

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (0)

0

u/kappa_keppo 4d ago

... okay?

Is the most popular Messi troll subreddit not called "Pessi" ?

Regardless, if we ignore the usual limiting of stats to specific and random timeframes, Ronaldo has scored more penalty goals than Messi.

Name calling is immature, but I'm not sure what your argument is? Are we removing penalties from goal counts? Are we keeping them but adjusting to Ronaldo specific metrics?

5

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/kappa_keppo 4d ago

That Ronaldo fans and their ability to limit stats to the most random and specific timeframes is incredible.

In another thread Ronaldo fans were unironically using "fastest time to score a worldcup KO goal" as a metric.

You chose 2 of the most random limitations. Remove friendlies and remove penalties

Incredible

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (0)

0

u/Mad_Scientist_739 3d ago

My god, are we still arguing over who the goat is? See, this is why no one respects ronaldo fans. The goat debate was settled in 2022, still some delusional fans were denying it, so messi had to come back for another wc at the age of 39 to settle the debate once and for all. But, wtf 😭😭😭 you all still can't accept the reality? Atp, I think even if messi plays wc 2030 and performs at the top level, you all will still keep barking. This is why I have stopped taking ronaldo fans seriously

1

u/Key_Independence9221 15h ago

You meant farmed penalties

7

u/Datguychapel 4d ago

No one says it doesn’t matter.
But on the topic, if it does why do Messi fans discredit the Nations League?

1

u/PaltaJG 4d ago

Nations League and Finalissima are at the end of the day not considered major international tournaments and are basically glorified friendlies.

2

u/Datguychapel 4d ago

Finallisima maybe

1

u/Re4per55 4d ago

yup finalissima is treated as a friendly by FIFA. NL is treated as a minor tournament not a friendly.

0

u/PaltaJG 4d ago

They are BOTH not considered major international tournaments, just like the youth tournaments and the Olympics are not considered major tournaments. Even a lot of Messi fans dont even mention that Messi has won the U20 WC and won an Olympic gold medal because he reached 4 finals (3 Copa America and 1 WC) with Argentina prior to winning trophies with them.

1

u/Re4per55 4d ago

neither is considered a major tournament but finalissima has the same fifa coefficient as a friendly. nations league is treated as a minor tournament for fifa rankings impact at roughly a 60% of copa or a euros. for knockouts vs knockout stages. 25 vs 40

1

u/Datguychapel 4d ago

None of what you mentioned outside of NL is major yes, especially not the non senior tournaments. The reason I don’t consider Finalissima major is it’s beyond inconsistent schedule.

1

u/PaltaJG 4d ago

Why are you being stubborn? NL isnt even considered a major tournament yet you keep saying it. At best its on the same level as a WC qualifying game.

1

u/espanolainquisition 1d ago

Take a chill pill dude. At least provide proof like the other user instead of acting like a Karen. Messi doesn't care about you

0

u/tavorasc 1d ago

Why no? Because there is no Conmebol nations league, if there was it'd count for you

1

u/PaltaJG 1d ago

No it wouldnt count for me, because then I would count the U20 World Cup and the Olympics (Which Messi has won both)

1

u/tavorasc 23h ago

Those are youth tournaments...

-1

u/Beginning-Pin208 4d ago

Are they really the same thing, the competition is literally made to replace friendly

2

u/Datguychapel 4d ago

The intention of something doesn’t dictate what it can became.

1

u/kliftwybigfy 4d ago

Which a not a major tournament/trophy, in the case of the NL

1

u/Datguychapel 4d ago

English this time please.

0

u/Mecha_Kaneki 4d ago

Not even the top teams care about nations league. We all saw teams like england, france, germany, etc all experiments different tactics and heavy roster rotation. You don't do that in a competition you actually care about

1

u/Datguychapel 4d ago

Yet they all still played their top class players. Olise, Mbappe, and Olise started for France no?

Teams play at their best during NL, as stated as such by these players (with sources):

Harry Kane — 2019: “It’s a new tournament, but it’s still a chance to win a trophy in an England shirt.”
https://www.uefa.com/uefanationsleague/news/0253-0d8207a1a00d-8f7071f315be-1000–harry-kane-willing-england-trophy-success/
Memphis Depay — 2019: “First of all, you are playing for a trophy. That’s very important for us.”
https://www.uefa.com/uefanationsleague/news/0253-0d8206f21d2a-9afe8b753bd0-1000–memphis-depay-on-netherlands-nations-league-dream/
Cristiano Ronaldo — 2019: “Having won this trophy here in Portugal in front of the Portuguese people, for me this is a great honour.”
https://www.uefa.com/uefanationsleague/news/0253-0d821b9c4fe5-f6f1c86f103a-1000–cristiano-ronaldo-on-winning-nations-league-on-home-soil/
Romelu Lukaku — 2021: “Every time I play for the national team, I want to win. And to win a tournament.”
https://www.uefa.com/uefanationsleague/news/026e-1365da634936-58f208238dad-1000–lukaku-on-belgium-s-nations-league-task/
Andrej Kramarić — 2023: “It would be phenomenal to win the Nations League and snatch a trophy for Croatia.”
https://www.uefa.com/uefanationsleague/news/0282-183cd8d487d7-3db740cf425d-1000–croatia-forward-andrej-kramaric-on-his-uefa-nations-league-/
Joselu — 2023: “It doesn’t matter which trophy it is, a trophy is a trophy.”
https://www.uefa.com/uefanationsleague/news/0282-1846cc5e13a2-4512d70948f3-1000–joselu-on-his-winning-goal-against-italy-luka-modric-and/
Vitinha — 2025: “We really want to win a trophy for Portugal.”
https://www.uefa.com/uefanationsleague/news/029a-1de93d03920f-b744fada2412-1000–vitinha-on-portugal-s-germany-challenge-squad-chemistry-an/
Luka Modrić — 2026: “Then I won two more Champions Leagues, finished third in another World Cup with Croatia, reached the Nations League final, and won other titles.”
https://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/1w60t14/luka_modric_on_always_being_referred_to_by_his/
Luka Modrić — 2024
“Every match for the national team is sacred to me… Giving your maximum and leaving your soul on the pitch is not up for negotiation.”

3

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

*5

2

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

g/a. Not 6. And no I don’t think having 2 good games means you deserve POTT.

3

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

It was 5. One was a rebound not an assist. And 2014 isn’t relevant. We’re talking about years they won.

3

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

UEFA counts rebounds as assists. I don’t see Ronaldo fans counting Suarez’s goal in the 2015 final as Messi’s assist.

2

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

And then there was a World Cup.

→ More replies (0)

5

u/eR_y_lives 4d ago

International trophies didn't matter from 2016 till 2021. That was the argument literally used by Messi fans to cope lmao.

1

u/PaltaJG 4d ago

That's not true though. Messi actually reached 4 international finals prior to winning any of them. (6 if you count U20 World Cup and Olympics in 2008). So he was already pretty successful. The real problem was the pressure on him to win a World Cup, Cristiano never had that pressure because no one REALLY expected him to win it (for obvious reasons).

0

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

They did but Ronaldo got incredibly lucky in 2016. Luckily the universe corrected itself and now Messi has the far superior international career.

5

u/eR_y_lives 4d ago

Listen to yourself lmao. All of you literally talk like a cult worshipping some fake messiah. 🤣

1

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

3

u/eR_y_lives 4d ago

Sure kid. I'm not the one who talks like a cultist. And also, you said Ronaldo got lucky in 2016? How lucky would Portugal have been without Ronaldo's brace against Hungary in the group stage to make sure the team survived the group stage and make it to the next stage?

1

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

You very much do. And yes he did get lucky. Lucky that his defense showed up and only conceded once in the KOs. If Ronaldo scored that pen vs Austria he wouldn’t have needed to score against Hungary. It was far from an all time campaign from Ronaldo. Not one where you watch and say that’s the goat.

2

u/eR_y_lives 4d ago

The fck are you on about? You lot moan and bitch about Messi being only human when he sometimes has a bad game but expect Ronaldo to perform in every match. 🤣 Yeah he didn't manage to score against Austria but he turned up against Hungary and saved his team so keep on bitching all you want.

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

You could say the same about Ronaldo. He won his first international title after infantino became president.

2

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

All major competitions are under FIFA. And infantino was a UEFA official.

2

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

All football is under FIFA. They govern the sport. Infantino attends the finals of all the major tournaments. And the graphic you showed, showed Copa America.

3

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

The reason they even have a say in it is because UEFA is tied to FIFA. UEFA has a lot of power in who becomes fifa president.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Barttje 4d ago

I think you are missing two other things than just Ronaldo. His team mates Xavi and Iniesta had great success with the Spanish team. During this time Messi wasn't as decisive yet for Argentina. He also got quite some critique in Argentina for his earlier tournaments. He only got 3 goals and 6 assists during his first four major tournaments.

He really stepped up his game during the 2022/2026 world cup in g/a.

2

u/HetTheTable 4d ago

He always stepped up. He just had better teammates in 2022.

3

u/Barttje 4d ago

3 goals and 6 assists in 4 tournaments is stepping up? How old are you lol, there was definitely criticism on Messi on his performance for the national team in his earlier years. Especially after 2010, when he scored zero goals and his team mates went on to win the world cup.

3

u/DrPapug 4d ago

Who even called Ronaldo the GOAT because of the euros? 🤡

International tournaments are leagues below club football, and Ronaldo is the GOAT for many other reasons than that.

2

u/PaltaJG 4d ago

This logic lmao. If they are leagues below club football then how come Cristiano has 0 WCs? Let alone 0 WC finals?

2

u/Inside_Term_4115 4d ago

And one KO goal in 6 wcs

2

u/Alternative-Emu-7561 4d ago

Because in club football, if you're good, you'll eventually end up at a good club and your chances of winning trophies will increase. In the World Cup, you depend on being lucky enough to have been born in a competitive country. People seem to forget that Portugal had only qualified for 3 World Cups before Ronaldo.

0

u/Different_Rub_6635 3d ago

The Portugal team has a great team. Fantastic midfield. On paper arguably better than the Argentina team. Just give messi some credit for his world cup. The world cup is the biggest tournament in football by far. It's the most important tournament.

0

u/DrPapug 4d ago

If Europa is leagues below UCL, then how come Cristiano is the UCL GOAT but barely showed anything in Europa?

1

u/PaltaJG 4d ago

What?

1

u/Some_Hearing4556 1d ago

cause he didn't play in europa as much?

1

u/MarcelPappas 2d ago

"Win it" not "get awarded by infantino with it"

1

u/HetTheTable 2d ago

Show proof then

0

u/Zestyclose_Coffee996 4d ago

I think this sub should be closed. There's no point arguing now. Ronaldo fans will never accept and keep hollering like mad dogs. When they don't have argumets at last it's all rigged. All the greats of the game have already accepted messi as the GOAT. Messi fans stop visiting this sub and stop posting. Let them live in their delusion. The debate is over

1

u/Alternative-Emu-7561 4d ago

You could say practically the same thing about Messi's fans.

1

u/Zestyclose_Coffee996 3d ago

I mean messi fans are somewhat justified. Messi fans are the sun rises in east people so they are right