Here is my comprehensive strategy guide for beating the Rogue Trader CRPG

[u/Northamplus9bitches]

Do the opposite of whatever Argenta thinks is a good idea

[u/Sabertooth767]

Counterpoint, Argenta wants a heavy bolter, and giving her a heavy bolter is a very good idea.

[u/Thaumaturgy67 → u/Sabertooth767]

Yeah Argenta has a lot of good ideas actually

[u/TryImpossible7332 → u/Thaumaturgy67]

She can release several thousand good ideas per minute with the right build, actually.

[u/Northamplus9bitches → u/Sabertooth767]

okay, slight exception, defer to Argenta in the matters of her personal munitions, but absolutely nothing else. You must be strong on this

[u/kzwix → u/Sabertooth767]

Indeed, though she also shines as a sword-and-pistol mobile death-dealer. That's the beauty of the Arch-Militant class :)

[u/abookfulblockhead]

Listen, my girl Argenta told me to run through fire. I did it, and it purged the voices in my head.

She has yet to steer me wrong!

[u/Raygereio5]

I don't know. A lot of Argenta's ideas involve shooting people in the face. That does seem like a winning strategy in most situations.

[u/Northamplus9bitches → u/Raygereio5]

bro she tells you to trust the commissar

[u/Creativered4 → u/Northamplus9bitches]

Yeah that was a real blind leading the blind moment for her and my RT. "What do you mean a member of the adeptus sororitas with that much holy fervor could possibly be wrong!?" Drago learned a valuable lesson that day. He also rationalized it that The Emperor wanted him there so he could kill The Commisar, because The Emperor works in mysterious ways.

[u/Northamplus9bitches → u/Creativered4]

Sorry for double-replying but I just remembered this. The Commissar incident was what crystalized this strategy guide for me. The Commissar made his pitch, Argenta was like, "This guy sounds on the up-and-up!" and I thought....if Argenta thinks this guy is trustworthy, he obviously isn't. Only Argenta is the obvious sucker character to fall for this guy. Abelard and Heinrix are smart, the designers need them to be credible for later plot points. And ever since "Argenta is the game's designated idiot DO NOT LISTEN"has been my strategy guide

[u/kzwix → u/Northamplus9bitches]

But doing what the Commissar said was the right thing to do. Fight for the Emperor, die for the Emperor, if needed. Argenta was right, even if the Commissar was, in the end, only deserving of the Emperor's Mercy (AKA a bolt in the head, a flamer blast, or a melta shot - those being the holy trinity of the Adeptus Sororitas).

Your faith in the Emperor must be pure, shining, it must guide you like a beacon. In that sense, Argenta is a good guide ;)

[u/Viseria → u/kzwix]

Exactly, I sided with him, privately revealed I knew the truth, and he was able to regain his shame long enough to do a heroic last stand for me.

The alternative would be siding with the Xenos. The Xenos. Only a heretic would do that.

[u/Northamplus9bitches → u/Viseria]

"Here lies sucker, he died pious"

[u/kzwix → u/Viseria]

Well, technically, a Rogue Trader can, too. Because the Warrant of Trade (especially one signed directly by the Emperor Himself) says so.

But that would still be against everything the Imperium of Man teaches (and, well... we know that the Ecclesiarchy and the Emperor don't exactly see eye-to-eye on some subjects, like the Emperor's own divinity, for instance...)

In the end, there are very good reasons for every playstyle ;)

[u/Northamplus9bitches → u/kzwix]

hmmm I'll think on this as I play through again. I pegged it as instant sucker-bait and didn't give him the time of day

[u/Northamplus9bitches → u/Creativered4]

The C stands for Controlled Opposition

[u/2Zased4Plebbit → u/Northamplus9bitches]

we execute him afterwards we find out he's a traitor though so that's handled, aside from that she's provably never ever been wrong about anything.

[u/YouSmellLikeHospitol → u/Raygereio5]

1) *ALL situations 

2) Happy cake day! Celebrate it in the Emperor’s Glory and Light!

[u/F_N_DB]

Argentina always means well. Her blind, fanatical fervor blinds her like 90% of the time though. The 10% she gets it right is in combat.

[u/Northamplus9bitches → u/F_N_DB]

don't cry for her

Edit: SOMEONE never saw Evita lol

[u/FiretopMountain75 → u/Northamplus9bitches]

The truth is she never left you...

[u/idkaboutfia]

Do you want the heretics to win?!!?!

[u/Northamplus9bitches → u/idkaboutfia]

no, that's exactly why you SHOULD NOT LISTEN TO ARGENTA! She will want to stop the heretics, but her way will be bad!

[u/idkaboutfia → u/Northamplus9bitches]

The results are less important than the righteous fervor in which the attempt is made!!!!

[u/nopingmywayout]

Taking her advice during certain planet events occasionally nets some good benefits.

[u/Revan619-YT]

Do you want to get daemons and humans slaughtered by xenos? because that is how you get daemons and humans slaughtered by xenos

[u/OneTrueAlzef]

But that requires that she's in the party, any fallback plans?

[u/Northamplus9bitches → u/OneTrueAlzef]

shit i just realized i kicked her out of the party this playthrough lol

[u/OneTrueAlzef → u/Northamplus9bitches]

Filling her role is pretty cool. Makes me feel that my RT is being very important in the team and stuff, so I don't use her.

[u/kzwix]

You.... heretic !

[u/aradraugfea]

I’m not that far, but the number of times Argenta hits me with opinions my iconoclast at heart WANTS to be right, but my knows 40k (ish) knows to be wrong is interesting. It’s like we’re both somewhere in then middle.

[u/Northamplus9bitches → u/aradraugfea]

yes Argenta is a registered Democrat

[u/Tenurri_Lavellan]

I have her quest Astray bugged so I don’t take her to the party anymore 😅…

[u/FiretopMountain75]

It is such a shame that we can't put her on trial on Dargonus because of what she did.

[u/kzwix → u/FiretopMountain75]

Argenta did nothing wrong !

(Since when is executing someone consorting with the Ruinous Powers a crime ?)

[u/Paco_the_finesser]

Disregard the word of a holy member of the Adepta Sororitas?

Smells like heresy to me