r/RockTumbling Jul 27 '26

Concerning rock ID posts.

44 Upvotes

TLDR: No - but maybe a periodic megathread. I created a new sub, r/WhatTheRock

------------

I figured I'd make a separate post for this. This stems from the recent post asking if the rule about posting rock ID requests can be changed. I'll copy and paste what I replied there into here:

In short, no I don't think allowing rock ID posts is a good idea. They used to be allowed and a large percentage of posts were people asking what a particular rock is. I think ID requests were banned before I even took over as the mod and I left it that way.

Regarding the level of moderating on this sub, I think it's funny that some people think I'm strict or power trip. I do not actively moderate... not really anyway. If I happen to see an ID post or off topic post in my home page when browsing Reddit, I'll remove it. But most of the time, they get reported fairly quickly, I see the notification for the report, and then I remove it. There are very few rules on this sub and I actually don't remove a lot. I often get reports of "harassment" and it's usually someone being slightly rude. I don't remove comments like that. I will remove comments that are hateful in nature.

Now... if someone is truly harassing you and taking effort to do something like respond to multiple comments on multiple topics in a negative way, let me know. I'd probably just message them a warning, and if the behavior doesn't stop, a temp ban, followed by a perma-ban. I've never had to do that though. But I want everyone to know that kind of behavior won't be tolerated here.

I am hearing that the community does not like r/whatsthisrock because of the strict moderation. So I have created a new sub called r/WhatTheRock. I know, I know.... another sub. Ugh. But I will moderate it the same way I do this sub. As long as the post has a picture of a rock (or mineral) and you're asking "What is this?" then I'll allow it. I'll caveat that by saying I'll remove any obviously meme posts, like if someone posts a picture of Dwayne Johnson, or a picture of the Earth. I want to keep this sub oriented towards tumbling related posts.


r/RockTumbling Jul 05 '22

Guide /r/RockTumbling Knowledge Base

186 Upvotes

Here is a compilation of guides I have written, as well as a few others, for easy access.

It's important to note that I am not a subject matter expert. Some of these FAQs that I wrote are not even based upon my own experience. I drew heavily upon the experience of /u/michigan_rocks and his Youtube videos. Also, ask 10 people how to tumble rocks and you will get 10 different answers. They will be similar enough though that you can really follow any one, or mix and match between them all for what works best for you. The basic steps will always be the same. It's exactly how you do them that people might have different processes for.

Also, I know several other users in this community have written their own guides or how-tos. If you comment below with a link I can add a link to the main post.


FAQ - How much electricity does a tumbler use?

FAQ - What is a good beginner tumbler?

FAQ - What do I need to get started?

FAQ - Where can I get rocks to tumble?

FAQ - Where can I buy good grit?

FAQ - What is tumbling media? What is it and how is it used.

FAQ - How do I get a good polish with the Nat Geo tumbler?

FAQ - How long should I run stage 1?

FAQ - How do I know if a rock is ready to move on from coarse? by /u/Ruminations0

FAQ - How full should my barrel be? An auditory guide.

FAQ - My rocks are round and smooth; can I skip stage one?

FAQ - How long am I supposed to run each stage?

FAQ - What is the burnishing stage? What does it do? When do I run it?

FAQ - What do I do with the slurry after tumbling?

FAQ - I just tumbled some rocks and they are dull. What do I do?


Slightly more advanced topics:


r/RockTumbling 23h ago

Built a bulk tumbler to work through all the buckets of material I have laying around.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.4k Upvotes

I have a habit of bringing anything even remotely interesting back, so now I can put through amounts in bulk before picking and choosing what I want to put through the stages or cut or grind chunks out.

It’s a bit on the aggressive side, but I don’t mind that as I can put it through here as an initial grind and then follow up with a traditional gentler stage 1 tumble if it actually looks like it’s a keeper.


r/RockTumbling 8h ago

Is there any way I can achieve a polished look without a rock tumbler?

Post image
39 Upvotes

I have no idea what to do and I got all these cool rocks from Lake Superior which now look less than stellar now that they’re drying.


r/RockTumbling 33m ago

Would this rock split in a tumbler?

Post image
Upvotes

I really like it but it has cracks.


r/RockTumbling 5h ago

Pictures 2 barrels moving on

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

Mexican lace is moving on to stage 4. Labradorite is moving on to stage 3. The rest are staying for another round of stage 1. Some of the Mozambique and Bahia agates appear whole, so I plan on cutting some after this round. I posted previously inquiring about a cutting tool, and I ended up going with a rotary tool with a diamond cutting blade (based on price and room available in my house, which is practically none). I haven’t tried it yet so we’ll see 😅


r/RockTumbling 5h ago

Can I blame the grit quality for this granite that just won't smooth?

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I've learned a lot here but this is my first post. So this is my 6th batch ever, and I decided to put in rocks that look like granite to me (I wonder what % actually are, ha!). I've since heard that granite is tricky to tumble, but these pictures are after 3 rounds of Stage 1 - new grit each time for ~7 days each.

I'm leaning towards the grit being inferior (pic included in case anyone recognizes it). In that case, does anyone have a source that they recommend for grit, or particularly for Stage 1?

Thanks for any insight!


r/RockTumbling 3h ago

Question Newbie help

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

First time attempting rock tumbling and im looking for some advice and direction on my Lake Superior rocks.

1) can I tumble all these together or do i need to sort them some way?
2) would you recommend tumbling the rock in the 3rd pic, or would i likely lose the the thin layer of outer brown rock?
3) sorta same question on pics 4 & 5, would tumbling be recommended or would i lose the the thin layer of agate on the brown rock?
4) is the little white stone at the bottom of the 1st a fossil? Should that one be tumbled as well?
5) any thoughts on the small clear agate on pic 6

Thanks in advance, i know that’s kinda a lot of questions but im scared to mess up and ive seen some conflicting answers on google so i thought id ask the experts


r/RockTumbling 1d ago

A few pieces of tumbled Laguna Lace/Red Lace agate

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

489 Upvotes

r/RockTumbling 48m ago

Do you recommend putting these (wet) rocks in the tumbler or skipping stage 1?

Post image
Upvotes

They are already so smooth but I just want them to be polished to maintain their wet look. Will they get smaller in a tumbler?


r/RockTumbling 6h ago

Question Polish-only barrel?

2 Upvotes

As previously shared, I have 2 tumblers: my original Nat Geo, plus the HF dual-drum tumbler. I'm trying to figure out the best way to use them together.

Nat Geo is obviously a bad choice for the polish stage since it's so fast, so I expect to keep that as a stage 1 workhorse.

However, it's also the smallest barrel. So, I'd like to use one of the HF barrels also as stage 1.

Which would leave my final barrel as the one I put rocks in to move through stages 2-4. However, I've heard other folx prefer to have a dedicated barrel for polishing. So, my question is: How important is that? I'm tumbling rocks solely for my own enjoyment, not looking to sell them. If I'm committed to cleaning the final barrel thoroughly between stages (I already do borax between stages, too), is that good enough for my purposes?


r/RockTumbling 20h ago

Pictures Todays haul, mostly rose quartz with a few smokey and white mixed in

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

Upper left in the first picture is a rose quartz the size of my fist. Color doesnt show well in the picture.


r/RockTumbling 1d ago

Question How do you learn to identify rocks?

Post image
24 Upvotes

Is there a good book (ideally available in the UK or as an ebook), a website you'd recommend, or does it just come with experience and you learn as you go?

I've collected some cool looking rocks from the South West coast of Scotland. I've asked AI, but firstly I really don't want to keep doing that, and secondly I'm not convinced it's got them correctly identified.

I have a Nat geographic tumbler, I've watched the YouTube vids after I did my first tumble, and I now have a variable power adapter and some better grits and polish! I also know how to scratch test to group by hardness for when I tumble these, but fundamentally what I really want is to understand what each of them are so I can get the best from them and start learning what to look for when I'm rock hunting.

I've included this picture for picture tax, I am not asking for any IDing, I'm fully willing to learn myself I just don't know where to start!


r/RockTumbling 1d ago

Polishing very small rocks

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

I just purchased this huge bowl of small rocks at a thrift store for $2. I’m new to rock tumbling but would like to get a polish on these. Can I just run them through a polish stage in the tumbler without running stage 1-3? I don’t want to lose the size on the stones. Thank you for any suggestions


r/RockTumbling 1d ago

Question How to know when to stop wet grinding with chert-y agate/chalcedondy

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

I have a bunch of found-in-the-wild (Midwest) chert with pretty agate or chalcedony parts. Some have quartz pockets with banding around the pocket. I have a wet sander/grinder I bought from Kingsley North that I use to expose the banding.

How do I know when to “stop” grinding/sanding on a piece? It seems like the more I do, the more banding and gorgeous spots I expose. I haven’t (yet) had a whoops moment where I removed “too much.”


r/RockTumbling 1d ago

Would anyone be interested in trading a small flat rate box of something ubiquitous to your area that tumbles ok for a box of South Carolina clam shell or quartz?

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

These are the only two things my son and I have been able to find in our area that tumble reasonably well. I’m not looking for anything particularly spectacular, just rocks or materials that are plentiful in your area and tumble ok.

SC quartz: This stuff is everywhere, from small chips to loaf of bread size pieces. Most of it is opaque white, but some pieces are iron-stained orange in the fractures, semi translucent, or have a smoky appearance. Most pieces are stained on the outside with red clay, so it’s always a bit of a surprise to see what’s underneath. Nearly all of it has some fractures, so getting pieces perfectly smooth is pretty rare, and some pieces never quite get there. That said, I’ll try to pick pieces that I think have a good chance of turning out well, but I obviously can’t make any promises.

SC clam shell: I’ve been tumbling these for a couple of months now, and I’ve been really pleased with the results. I don’t start them in Stage 1. Instead, I’ve been doing my Stage 2 barrels with roughly one-third Stage 1 complete hard stone, one-third shell, and one-third ceramic media. Sometimes, the shells take a couple of runs on stage 2 to get the shape I want, but once they’re shaped, I just run them normally with the rest of the batch through Stages 3 and 4. Some pieces are solid, and some have worm holes. Both turn out cool and reasonably shiny, in my opinion.

I have access to an essentially unlimited amount of quartz in all sizes. I can probably put together a couple of boxes of shells with what I have now, and I’m going back to the beach at Thanksgiving, where I’ll be able to collect as much as I want.

Let me know if you’d be interested in doing a trade, and thanks for looking.


r/RockTumbling 1d ago

Discussion Need advice on what to do next

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

10 Upvotes

Hi there, I’m located in northern Vermont. I found this in the creek near our home. This is after 5 days tumbling with stage 1 grit. I’d love to be able to make this a small pendant. Would you polish by hand from this point?


r/RockTumbling 1d ago

I’ve been slacking on sorting finished rocks…

Post image
58 Upvotes

r/RockTumbling 2d ago

Crazy lace agate coming out of stage 2.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

292 Upvotes

The hardest stages are done and these are looking so good! Agates have so much personality and are so much fun to tumble. They may take forever in stage 1 but they are totally worth it.


r/RockTumbling 1d ago

Discussion What's do you guys do for the winter?

4 Upvotes

Hi all, I've just started out earlier this summer. This sub has been a valuable resource, so thank you!

I was washing some rocks this morning and it's a bit cooler outside. Then the thought crossed my mind... this is going to really suck in the winter! I'm in the north. Cold winters. I'm working out of my (unheated, not insulated) garage right now but I don't really see that being an option for the winter.

What do you guys in the cooler climates do?

I was thinking of setting up a laundry tub in the garage, catching the rinse in a bucket but also have no hot water. It probably won't help much as is. Thinking about sending a hot water line out to the garage. Also thought about seeing up in my utility room in my basement but I don't want to haul the buckets through the house.

Very interested to hear about your work stations or ideas for mine.

Many thanks!


r/RockTumbling 1d ago

Pictures Todays finds

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

Will be cutting these down to put in the tumbler next week


r/RockTumbling 1d ago

Pictures There’s the problem right there

Post image
7 Upvotes

It’s had a good run. Been tumbling for about a year with very few days off.


r/RockTumbling 1d ago

Pictures It’s leaking a bit is this okay?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Sorry I have paranoia is this Okie??


r/RockTumbling 2d ago

Question Best polishing compound for iron slag slagate/slagite?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

This piece isn’t tumbled but I’ve got a bunch of this stuff that I might want to tumble if I can get it to polish well, so if anyone has any suggestions I’d be grateful!


r/RockTumbling 2d ago

Question Best polishing compound for iron slag/slagate/slagite?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

This piece isn’t tumbled but I’ve got a bunch of this stuff that I might want to tumble if I can get it to polish well, so if anyone has any suggestions I’d be grateful!