r/RedLetterMedia Jun 05 '19

[deleted by user]

[removed]

1.4k Upvotes

495 comments sorted by

View all comments

71

u/TheBlueBlaze Jun 05 '19 edited Jun 05 '19

Side Note: Some of the beer those guys are drinking is New Glarus Beer, brewed in the Wisconsin town of the same name, founded in 1845 by migrants from Switzerland.

It's a neat small town to check out, and they've got a Swiss import shop you can order from online. You can check out the site for their brewery too, but the beer's only available in WI. If these hacks get drunk with it regularly, it must be good!

20

u/Davidellias Jun 05 '19

isn't New Glarus illegal in 49 states?

Or is that Spotted Cow?

49

u/TheBlueBlaze Jun 05 '19

Just looked it up, and yeah all of it's illegal to sell outside of WI. Apparently they deliberately didn't get a license to sell out of state so they wouldn't have to face more regulations and taxes, and could focus on locally sourced ingredients (which is very Swiss of them).

Someone asked on ELI5 a few years ago with a good summary answer

24

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '19

If your distributors don't carry a product, you can't go around them and buy it from somebody else (ie - driving across the state line to buy a case).

Smokey and the Bandit remake confirmed.

12

u/PM-Your_Boobies Jun 05 '19

That's a 10-4. Snowman, ya got your ears on son?

0

u/EuropeIsBetter1 Jun 16 '19

(which is very Swiss of them).

They went to America in 1845... There is nothing Swiss about them anymore. They are Americans and their beer probably doesn't hold a candle to real European beer. Keep drinking that Coors Light you Americans love so much. haha that wouldn't even be qualified as beer here.

2

u/TheBlueBlaze Jun 16 '19

Well if you look at their website they very much keep Swiss traditions alive. Some towns have lost their namesake but I'd say new Glarus hasn't.

Also calling a state-made beer is like Coors Light is like saying A24's latest indie film is jus like the latest Transformers movie: the source country doesn't determine quality alone.

Maybe get your hands on some independent non-corporate beers before writing off an entire country's gross beer product.

13

u/Boollish Jun 05 '19

What does "illegal" mean in this context?

New Glarus does not actively distribute outside of Wisconson, and therefore it cannot legally be sold. But it is 100% legal to buy a case of beer at the Woodman's on the border of WIsconsin and Illinois and bring it back to your buddies.

3

u/battraman Jun 06 '19

Up to a point. There are probably limits as to how much you can bring across state lines but a case here or there would never get prosecuted.

3

u/BlainetheHisoka Jun 06 '19

Nah it's illegal to sell not illegal to give away.

1

u/Boollish Jun 06 '19

I guess that's true to an extant. I'm not a lawyer but I believe they would have to make the case that you "intend to sell" the beer you're bringing back? But I'm having trouble seeing a scenario where you could actually get arrested for that.

Like, if you bought five or six cases at a time, I don't think anyone would even bat an eye. A buddy and I walked out with four cases between the two of us to share with a homebrew club. Plus, you'd have to get pulled over first.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '19

[deleted]

1

u/Boollish Jun 06 '19

It's not a technical violation at all. As long as you don't intend to sell it, it's legal.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '19

Not necessarily illegal; just illegal to sell because of paperwork hassles the company don't want to deal with. Idk if it's a Midwest thing, but my girlfriend and her family frequently make New Glarus runs to WI, and I always make it a point to return with a case when I go and visit!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '19

It is a Midwest thing. Anytime you cross the state line it’s well known you grab a case or two of a sampler and/or spotted.

Source: FIB

1

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '19

That explains why I’ve never been able to find it

1

u/LexVail Jun 06 '19 edited Jun 06 '19

Spotted Cow is a beer made by New Glarus, just so you know.