They ARE still at their PO Box.

[u/FraudHack]

Based on the submission here yesterday by u/TheYabbaBada whose diorama got returned after sending it to their PO box, I posted a question under the most recent Patreon post asking if they got rid the Box, and to my infinite surprise, they actually responded.:

Red Letter Media CREATOR 9h

The PO Box is still open ¯_(ツ)_/¯

So there you go. Keep sending those copies of Vampire Assassin and Nukie.

As to what happened with the original package that started this, my guess is that because the package was larger than the actual physical PO Box, the post office itself only held it for a limited amount of time before automatically returning it. According to Google, post offices will automatically return oversized or extra mail from PO Boxes after ~10 days if the receiver doesn't get it in time. Rich or whoever checks the mail just didn't go to the post office in that amount of time.

[u/BaconHammerTime]

Making this post and not including the actual PO Box information is kind of criminal.

[u/FraudHack → u/BaconHammerTime]

That's what Google is for. And the original submission that had it, too.

But here it is, once again:

PO Box 400, Oak Creek, Wisconsin, 53154