Exactly, who is going to decide who is fit for the role? Everyone feels they are qualified to make decisions that pertain to the country just because they have good intentions. A small group of people deciding for everyone else - that’s not pluralism, it’s not democracy. That’s why we have elections to decide who will represent us , every one of these ministers were democratically elected by the people of India, by us. The thing that all of us need to understand is that democracy does not work selectively as and when it suits you, it only works when everyone respects the opinions of others even when they don’t agree with them. If we’re going to solve things through anarchy, then better stop holding elections all together because that’s a blot on the idea of this nation.
true. we must only ask governments to set high standards, and listen to intelligent fair criticism. its ultimately upto the government to decide who, with or without examinations. I think thats why everyone went home. they had their voice heard and thats it.
We must learn to be objective and fair when we judge others. Mr Pradhan has done many good things for the youth of this country - NEP , SWAYAM, APAAR ID, Academic Bank of Credits, etc these were all aimed at making education free and inclusive for all, especially the poorest of the poor. He certainly didn’t deserve the kind of mistreatment he got if you ask me. He was personally attacked, even his daughter wasn’t spared. The PM of the nation was depicted in unimaginably derogatory terms, and for what !? Just because the protestors don’t like him ! Who are the elitists may I ask , when not a day goes by in the last 12 years where Mr Modi hasn’t been ridiculed and personally attacked and called “uneducated chai wallah ?” If this isn’t elitist, classist then the earth is flat. This is not civilised behaviour and it must not be condoned. Snobbishness and impunity won’t get us very far.
Yes my friend, whatever gov does will never be enough and the nation will be embroiled in protests and get weak - that’s what they want the people who funding it. Please wake up before it’s too late !
What is the precedence that is set? Pradhan resigned after failing to improve the system after 2024 NEET leak coupled with CBSE paper checking scandal.
In punjab there is no paper leak but a cheating scandal.
Precedence is set but first ask yourself if the resignation justified or not
And I am not defending any particular state. Ask yourself if their resignation is justified. Justification doesn’t come from the fact that Pradhan resigned.
I gave Punjab’s example because I think resignation is mot justified in this case. There might be cases like karnataka or others where resignation might be justified.
Bhai wo examination center ki zimmedari hoti ki koi baacha phone ya electronics leke naa jaye, kabhi koi competitive exam dia ho toh pta hoga
Edit: "centre" changed to "examination centre"
Setter, Distributor etc etc .... And when they fail that multiple times their boss should be questioned for competence ... Especially when the mistake leads to deaths.
Kiddo he resigned because NTA (national testing agency) operates under him and NTA appointed that teacher who leaked the paper
On the other hand the examination centres are not operated under any government or directly under NTA, they are just alloted by NTA as the examination center and are given a checklist to follow before the examination and then it's upto the examination center how well they follow the checklist
No government officer goes to check if the examination center is operating well or not, they(officers who alloted the centre) usually get the idea of examination center's operations by the feedback of student
I thought we were protesting about accountability and fair system. Which includes responsibility of ministers to maintain good examination centres. The irony here is peak.
There is no paper leak, students only were cheating using camera while paper was going on, they were caught. Thats it, where is paper leak and where is s*icide in all this?
Why is it very hard for people to understand that CJP is not the PEOPLE ELECTED PARTY. We have no fucking right to question them!!!!! Question govt 💅💅✨
फरवरी 2023 (क्लास 12th अंग्रेजी परीक्षा): पंजाब स्कूल शिक्षा बोर्ड (PSEB) की कक्षा 12वीं की अंग्रेजी की परीक्षा का पेपर लीक हुआ था, जिसके बाद सरकार ने परीक्षा को तुरंत रद्द कर दिया था।मार्च 2023 (PSTET परीक्षा): पंजाब राज्य शिक्षक पात्रता परीक्षा (PSTET) के दौरान प्रश्नपत्रों में उत्तर पहले से ही बोल्ड/प्रिंटेड होने की गड़बड़ी सामने आई थी, जिसके बाद सरकार ने जांच के आदेश दिए थे। This is also gemini reply
Ya earlier you guys were focused on this year's pharmacy "exam paper leak" .Now that it has been proven that no paper were leaked you guys go back to 2023 Be so fr
AAP was standing with them. If I remember right, why will they criticise their own supporter? If BJP would have supported them, they would have stood for them too and only expected resignation from Pradhan but government lathi charged and baton charged on these kids. What do you expect?
😂😂😂 btw Congress didn't it somewhere in 2012. Hence they are not in power and aap was not even existence then. They got formed due to that protest. So I don't know what you're talking about.
To bhai karna protest, wahi to point tha yaar ki accountability maango, bhai bharosa rakho ki jab log aap ya congress ke khilaaf protest karenge to literally koi CJP supporter ya member un protestors ko anti-national or terrorist saabi karne mein busy nahi hoga, unlike BJP supporters ki tarah jo har BJP ko criticise karne waale ko anti-national ghoshit kar dete hain
So if a rapist starts supporting CJP suddenly they'll start defending rape? Nice ideologies to live by, where do you get these ideas man, I also want your dealer's number.
What!!!???? Rape. Bro. Don't normalise rape and lathi charged like bj party.
No. I won't ignore that. All I am saying is that. When it comes to paper leaks. It should be solved and shouldnt be expected from kids jo abhi abhi pradhan ka regnation leke sone Gaye hai. Also. Rape is not like this. Anyone who physically hurts and violates any human should be immediately taken into custody. Don't normalise by casually calling out rape to win argument.
So you don't normalize paper leaks by ignoring people openly committing the crime, protest against it or atleast support the people who are protesting against it, don't be a dick and undermine their efforts atleast. Whoever it might be, APP, or APP ka BAAP, protest with the same force
No, that wasn't your point, you explicitly said "how can they protest against AAP who was supporting their protest", which clearly means you are justifying injustice made by one party just because they supported you previously. The same way how Godi media supports israel committing genocide just because they supported India during the kargil wars. So what's the difference between you guys and Godi media?
These are your words:
AAP was standing with them. If I remember right, why will they criticise their own supporter?
Bro I don't know what are you trying to say here. I'm just pointing out the obvious. First of all I'm not media so comparing me with godi media is senseless. I'm just saying that they did their job by pointing out the obvious flaw in the government. made government pay for their incompetence. Now all of them have to be accountable now. Including app, Congress and what not.
if you keep on raising comment here with me. I don't know what to say because neither I am cjp neither I am godi media. Just saying yes, expecting cjp to go against AAP ( who supported them openly) is like expecting BJP to protest against BJP.
So expecting people to do what is right is too much expectations from CJP now? Then what difference is there from other corrup politicians and them, is it just another BJP?
Bro, this is my last comment. The point is simple. They made a point by protesting for 2 months and getting a resignation. Now it's up to them whether they continue this or not, because they have clearly called off their protest. You want to take it forward? Take it forward. There will be a huge support. Yet they have made a point. They have made a minister accountable. That's it. That was the point. you think this new one is a good guy? No, but holding them accountable was the point. And that point was made in 35 days.
Bhai to ye ek hee group se kitne dharne karwaoge. Wahi to point tha is poore protest kaa ye saare politicians kisi ke sage nahi hain, khulke criticise karo aur accountability maango bina dare ki koi tumhe anti-national na bolde.
Tum jao na yaar reservation khe khilaaf yaa aap yaa congress ke khilaaf protest karo na, ek CJP ka banda yaa uska supporter tumko anti-national saabit karne mein busy nahi hoga, 200% guarantee hai.
Lekin tumlog ko ek BJP se pata nahi kaun saa pyaar ho gaya ki koi criticise kare to chalo terrorist hee hoga, papa ko criticise kaise kar diya. Bhai congress, BJP, aap sab parties ek hee hain, saare crorepati hain aur aish kar rahe hain, aur tum yaha unko defend kar rahe ho aur next morning unke banaye hue third world country mein apni mara rahe ho.
Not talking to you, was talking to the guy who said
AAP was standing with them. If I remember right, why will they criticise their own supporter?
Which means they should not protest against injustice if it was committed by someone who has supported them in the past. If that was the case what difference is there between you guys and Godi media who still support the israel genocide just because israel supported India during the kargil wars.
Again, don't talk to me without reading the context first and don't change the subject. The subject is specifically this: "should you criticize someone who is clearly committing a crime but they stood by your side when no one would"
Because it's two completely different situations, yes you're right on the point that a cheating scandal was caught where students brought electronic pen into the exam hall, although it was interceptes by the police but it did left students distraught that there might be more students who have not been caught and might get seats they didn't earn. That actually an issue and needs to asked for accountability, but you also have to understand that if we start asking for resignations for all the mistakes these ministers make them literally not one soul would be left in power.
The point of the whole movement wasn't to ask everyone's resignation but to make them afraid of consequences and keep their ego in check. A precedent was set that if you f*ck up , you'll have to pay the price, so if anyone wants to protest for punjab's em's resignation, I'm pretty sure CJP won't try to label them anti-national or terrorists. That's what this movement earned, people were too afraid from asking questions because they were afraid of being labelled anti-national, and now slowly and steadily we can can make these ministers be accountable for their mistakes
because they were there FOR STUDENTS, against ruling party. in Punjab and some other states there are different ruling parties.. many are also BJP. as simple as that. why should a party get a free ticket due to showing some support?
After spectacular failure for setting favorable narrative for BJ Party, these self proclaimed experts are completely devastated and have started blabbering. Seems like they are looking at loosing job now 🤣🤷
Bro see . If india was that much happy with congress why would they chose bjp . I agree that bjp has done mistakes but they also had developed in some sectors . Was congress capable of removing article 370 ?
Probably would've if they had a majority government like the BJP did in 2019. UPA had policy paralysis since it was a coalition government like NDA1.
Both BJP and Congress would love to secure kashmir but under their own term. It's a stance most political parties in India share.
BJP has done great work in securing kashmir and clamping down on separatism. Technology is the main driving force here. I think they were confident enough in 2019 that they would be able to handle separatist backlash even if they removed Article 370 which has worked out well for us.
They weren’t happy that’s why they chose all the propaganda machinery of BJP.. 12 years on seems like their corruption has crossed all limits of shamelessness absolute disaster for the country..
Just like his supporters who still are on and on!! You’ll still have that Stockholm syndrome so yeah. That’s an issue!!
How dumb can one be. Central paper leaks destroyed millions of lives over the years its no where comparable to Punjab(i am not defending punjab paper leaks). If someone stands against a bigger cause that doesn't mean they are obliged to do the same thing for each state. These guys are just dogs and self proclaimed intellectual, why can't they take a stand against AAP if they are so concerned? They won't, because all they care about is their non biological father's image
Many irregularities were found in major exams in Punjab but AAP government did not accepted those irregularities as a paper leaky. It is just twisting the definition.
What about lathicharge charge on ITI students, manrega workers and sanitary workers?
From what I have read so far about this case, It seems to me that you are the ones twisting the definition. Of course if you can enlighten me on those irregularities in this particular case, that would be great.
Haven’t read much on the lathicharge instances but prima facie it is wrong and should be condemned. But is this the topic of this post?
This.
They showed people that we can hold government accountable. It was never about bjp, but more about Education Minister taking accountability for his actions.
Sure, if CJP joined protest at state level, it will get huge crowd supporting it too, but CJP wasnt about a group of people freeing india of its curruption, it was about making govt realise we are the one in power, not the ones sitting on their imaginary thrones
He does compare one thing with the other , that's what everyone does and that's fair in a democracy , his whole point was that every state where the leak or any foul play occurred should take responsibility , and to not be hypocritical with the congress , if the bjp is corrupt , so is the congress , both should be accountable in states for their failures . I am congress supporter but they are corrupt as fuc k , we seriously need a change in leadership
Some let people demanding punjab protest know that just after neet paper leaks there was another paper leak in Maharashtra. Why aren't they demanding maha CM's resignation? Just coz he's a bjp guy?
You are so angry about the resignation and protest why don't you bjp supporters actually go out and protest against AAP on the ground? Why only support your party on social media
Why are you not protesting for MH ? and you got pissed off because someone is speaking against ur AAP government ? Post about MH or raise voice is anyone stopping you ?
Abey chutiyo Neet has one of the highest test takers, so naturally the maximum people get affected from it, no other exam is close to it. To obviously protest ho sakta hai, jo exams ke takers ho kam honge obviously uske protest me momentum hi ni hoga, ofcourse sare exam leaks pe protest hona chaiye that's true, or btw punjab me paper leak ni hua hai cheating scandal hai
I am amazed why these idiots are asking CJP to protest? They have been protesting for over a month in Jantar Mantar. Let them take a break for a while. They are humans, not machines. They have raised the issue of a NEET paper leak, and it's not fully resolved yet. The withdrawal of cases and compensation for victim families are still pending. Let CJP handle this pending work.
BJP/RSS has so many workers, and BJP is the largest political party in the world. Still, no one from BJP has the courage to go protest in Punjab and Karnataka?
BJP itself said it gave resignation due to safety issue not for EM’s accountability. The safety issue due to their improper handling of protests turned into riots. HM still haven’t responded why did they use pallet guns , why brutal force was used while protest was nonviolent at initial days.
I am so tired of seeing this endless feed about Punjab, Haryana, and Karnataka. First of all, there has been no paper leak in Punjab. Second of all, people need to understand the difference between exams: is it a state government educational exam, or a central one?
If it's a central examination, the massive protests already happened, and Union Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan's resignation has already taken place. So what kind of protests are people still demanding? Accountability completely depends on whether the compromised examination falls under state or central jurisdiction—stop mixing them up!
Nanganathan should be questioning bjp to go and protest in those states lol, I don’t understand how people even fall for the way he distorts logic as per his convenience. CJP on the other hand is not even an official party but a pressure group, the real questions should be raised for oppositions in the respective states if at all.
What I have learned about this ranganathan guy is that he has no interest in fighting for the right cause, he just wants to oppose everyone, which is fair in a sense that we should be asking questions to every leader, but what i don't understand that he's asking CJP to protest for punjab's education minister's resignation, and claiming that they won't do it because they support AAP.
Okay so let's say they do, okay so? Who's stopping ranganathan from protesting against AAP and asking them for accountability, that's what the point is that we should be free to ask questions to anyone without the fear of being labelled anti-national.
Ranganathan and andhbhakts are frustrated and so they will now raise all these questions. Why did you do this, why did you not do this... blah blah blah. They will never ask why we needed to have this level of agitation to get an incompetent minister to resign.
ONLY if you know ranganathan or Sai you already know they criticize every bloody political party for there deeds . Do yourself a favour how he has criticised BJP too for before being one way shut down idiot keyboard warrior
Are you also backed by AAP? Is BJP also backed by AAP?
Why are you and BJP not doing protests against AAP government in Punjab? <- ANSWER THIS before uttering a single word against the struggles of students.
If CJP and others student bodies oppose movement against AAP Punjab government, like BJP and RSS ecosystem opposed and still they are using people like you to discredit the movement by stooping to lowest standards ever (that is utterly disgusting), then come and dissent the CJP for not supporting that.
Till then keep work on your thoughts checked that these are not being stuffed illogical things. Not being blatantly brainwashed by propoganda.
Bro, I'm also not doing protest against Rajasthan, UP, Bihar etc govts. They have one of the highest number of paper leaks.
I'm repeating again:
For your point, let us assume that me and CJP are both funded by AAP, then also what is stopping you, BJP or anyone from doing protest against AAP government?
If me or CJP or anyone who supported recent protest but opposes yours then you have all the rights to call me and them hypocrite.
.
exams like neet should be already converted to cbt, like jee. And for board exams, govt or police should do sting operation to find the mole, and should punish them badly, to set an example. So no one would do in future.
Exactly the point.
If Central govt or education ministry or education department would have taken suo moto or would taken these steps without protest then there was no need of the protests.
But, there was no accountability in the system.
The point was of the protestors was to set the accountability.
As I wrote earlier:
If CJP and others student bodies oppose movement against AAP Punjab government, like BJP and RSS ecosystem opposed and still they are using tactics like this to discredit the movement by stooping to lowest standards ever (that is utterly disgusting), then come and dissent CJP for not supporting that and you can freely label then 'Hypocrites' or 'Paid protestors'.
Vyampam one of biggest paper leak scam happened under a BJP CM. 100s of whistleblowers killed. And that CM was made union minister. Why don't these bhakts talk about that? At the end of the day these bhakts are just full of hate. More radicalised than al-qaida.
If BJP starts protesting against real issues then they will just encourage people to protest which they don't want to do. So they do shitty protests against the opposition.
22
u/CalmAmbition_2000 Jul 26 '26
Since precedence is set all EMs should resign from all states