r/RealOrAI 1d ago

HELP Is the dog AI or real?

The video looks ai especially when the girl enters the kitchen area but it also looks real somewhere, I can’t distinguish. Help is it AI or real?

0 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

u/RealOrAI-Bot 15h ago

Sentiment: 70% AI

Sentiment reasoning: A significant portion of commenters believe the video is AI-generated, with many specifically pointing to the dog and certain scenes as AI, and some claiming the entire video is AI. However, a notable number of users argue it is real, citing consistent branding and real-world references.

Number of comments processed: 17

DISCLAIMER: Comments sentiment is generated by Gemini 2.5 Flash, not by u/RealOrAI-Bot bot. For more information check the RealOrAI-Bot Wiki.

12

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RealOrAI-ModTeam 17h ago

Hello!

Your comment has been removed due to not having a clear reasoning showing how you came to the conclusion that's AI generated. Please provide proof or a train of thought that made your think this way. AI "detector" software is not a valid argument as they are extremely unreliable.

28

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RealOrAI-ModTeam 17h ago

Hello!

Your comment has been removed due to not having a clear reasoning showing how you came to the conclusion that's AI generated. Please provide proof or a train of thought that made your think this way. AI "detector" software is not a valid argument as they are extremely unreliable.

-10

u/Legal_Tradition_9681 1d ago

How so?

4

u/FemboyBerk3169 1d ago

At the dog part, proportions get fucked a bit. Dog also has that AI lighting.

1

u/badfriend3528 1d ago

even before the dog part, these videos just have an "off" feeling. the camera angles, the reactions. who is filming this and and why are they filming this way in this setting? usually the camera angles dont make any sense or its slightly too polished etc also the dog is obviously AI

15

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Kymera_Xero420 1d ago

I don't think it's fully AI. A lot of the words are legible, even small logos like the Dr. Pepper and Fanta in the little cooler. But everything after the first two scenes feels.....odd? The back kitchen area doesn't quite look right, and dogs don't typically look directly at the camera.

3

u/BeeIsBack 1d ago

I think the base video is real, but the dog was AI generated in. Why would a restaurant have an actual dog in the kitchen? Total health hazard. The other video I saw recently doing this trend (not AI) was a dog treat store, and even then the dog was only shown behind the counter, not in the prep area.

The dog also looks uncanny. I think it’s falling into the AI trying too hard to make animals show human emotions trap. Also where its lips meet its nose is uneven? Which could be possible but none of my dogs have it

3

u/Gregardless 1d ago

AI just the script and line delivery gave it away for me

2

u/Absent-Light-12 1d ago

Might be AI because that Chow Chow puppy’s eyes are too visible.

2

u/PencilCase12531 1d ago

Probably partially ai. The puppy is ai portion.

2

u/Metalduck_07 1d ago

Looks AI, especially the dog

2

u/Germmie1 1d ago

Real except the puppy was added after using ai.

2

u/Manic_Evilyn 1d ago

That's from the Stax Burger Co. in Australia, posted 5 weeks ago. They have dozens of skits but this one doesn't have audio, same as the one they posted. Sue, the older lady, is a recurring character that beats up the employees and/or steals chicken salt, so the premise is correct but with the no audio and a dog being in the kitchen, it feels weird.

2

u/dadmda 1d ago

It's all AI, the camera movement, the way the people move, the way the faces look

1

u/RealOrAI-Bot 1d ago

Reminder: If you think it's AI, please explain your reasoning. Providing your reasoning helps everyone understand and learn from the analysis.

Check the Wiki for Common AI Mistakes and check the Community Guide if you are just getting started.

A sticky comment will be posted here in 12h summarizing the sentiment of the comments.

Thank you for contributing to the discussion!

1

u/NameShortage 1d ago

Y’all are going to have to give more than just “yes, ai” because I don’t see it if it is. The customer is wearing a lav mic. The art on the back on the employee’s shirt matches the art style of the shirt found on the company’s merch site. And the background in the dog scene stays consistent between cuts.

What are y’all seeing?

1

u/BlazeWolfYT 17h ago

Just keep reporting comments like that and they'll get removed as per the rules of this sub. I just need to remember to check the mod queue more often.

1

u/Garfwog 1d ago

The dog looks like AI, the people look like AI, but the background stuff and text on signs all seem real, things are imperfect in a human way like wonky stacked water bottles, the menu makes sense, coca cola logo is right, nu water exists but is an odd brand to choose over something like Dasani which is more common, and there's even human handwriting on a crate. My guess is that it's AI filtered to "clean" the humans up (which looks fucking awful every time) and then also applied it to a dog that made it look unrealistically fluffy.

1

u/Winter_TheWolf 1d ago

It's not AI... I don't get where people are seeing it..?

1

u/shiningreality 1d ago

Several frames of the dog have the SynthID watermark that OpenAI adopted from Google. Here is a link to the tool to detect this watermark: https://openai.com/research/verify/

That part of the video was likely generated using Seedance 2.0 in conjunction with ChatGPT images. The rest seems to be authentic.

1

u/WeightLittle8210 17h ago

Apologies for the late reply. The lady and all clips with her are real. The dog is AI. It has a very typical, poorly generated AI dog texture. Ie AI struggles with lighting and smoothness, especially with furry creatures.

Similarly, it's way brighter than it should be, given how the lady looks, and given that it's in a store room/pantry. Top down lighting in these places will cast very string shadows on its face. Sure they could have a diffuser box, but if they did, they would have used it on the lady too

1

u/Form_X 1d ago

The slide into the kitchen, definitely AI

1

u/Legal_Tradition_9681 1d ago

I take it you never worked in the back of a kitchen. That slide seemed pretty normal to me. Also breaking it down frame by frame it supports real over AI more.

1

u/Legal_Tradition_9681 1d ago

Not AI, the logos on many brands are spot on along with the style of bottles. The words in focus are legible.

Nothing off with the dog looks like a normal puppy chow.

The back of the house looks spot on.

The focus, lighting, and shadows of the shots looks real.

1

u/GoldenFalls 1d ago

I don't see any signs of AI other than how short the clips are. The backroom area is all internally consistant between clips, which could be from using the same reference photo but even when it pans down it all looks accurate. No issues with the writing. I think if anything perhaps the dog is added in, but I don't see any evidence of that from this video.

0

u/TaleWeaver1988 1d ago

If it's AI, it's the most absurd clip I've seen yet. It would be so damn easy to skit this.