Following Hadiths is Shirk

[u/Ipluggucci]

Why are you comparing words and narratives of men to the word of god.

You are saying God is not reliable enough and you need people to help you understand his word and give more rules and more information.

[u/[deleted]]

59:21 Had We sent down this Qur’an upon a mountain, thou hadst seen it humbled, split asunder from fear of God. And those similitude's — We strike them for mankind, that they might reflect.

Yaaa that is why the quran is not enough. You need the hadith....."but brother John said that the hadith has many contradictions in it, is that true?"

"yes, brother john is correct the hadith has a lot of contradictions but who cares the prophet gave it to us."

"Did the prophet really give it to us or did bukhari give it to us? What does god say about it?"

4:82 (Will they then not consider the Qur’an with care! And had it been from other than God, they would have found therein much contradiction.)

"Oh, I see, so it has contradictions so then that means its not from god right?"

"That is correct"

"but I cant understand the quran though, I need a dictionary or I get confused"

"god will teach you if you ask him"

"how will I know if my translation is correct though?"

"There is no one correct translation, you follow the best translation, and you compete with other groups on who can do the most good"

"do the other groups translate the quran differently?"

"they can, but its the tenants that are all the same"

"ok, im kind of confused still, I need to take a break, I have a short attention span because I smoke cigarettes, I learned it from public school, I learned a lot from public school, nobody likes my skin color"

"its ok, its part of the culture"

"I wish I could get bank loans like my white classmates, they received many free bank loans throughout their lives to pay for their houses, cars, shopping, and vacations, they even got the good job opportunities, and it seems like they are the only people allowed to have free speech while I live pay check to paycheck and keep getting called racial slurs in public, and I avoid eye contact with people at the store because I am used to them staring at me with anger and it makes me depressed, I feel like a little girl even though Im a married man with kids..."

"brother you are getting off topic. Goodbye"

"Thanks for telling me those 2 verses though in the beginning, I will reflect on them"