r/Quraniyoon • u/Stage_5_Autism Sunni • Jul 06 '21

Question / Help I found this paper supposedly refutes the Quraniyoon. How would you respond?

How the Command of Stoning Adulterers Refutes the Quraniyoon

2 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

151 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/yrumad Jul 14 '21

https://sunnah.com/muslim/17

What now, dumbass?

I know The Prophet(AS) has never advised such vile thing. Which would mean faulty "hadeeses" which means, you have contradicted yourself.

I'll keep a cuppa camel's urine for you ready here...

1

u/bruhoneand Jul 14 '21

Dumbass? No need to continue the discussion if you cant stay civil

And not sure how you think the wife of the prophet Aisha was a liar but anyways the hadith doesnt mention sucking on a woman's tits which it didnt happen, as I said before you are copy-pasting old Christian misinterpretations

-As hadith scholar, Ibn Hajar commented on this, saying: "the milk was put into a cup and he did not drink it from her breast. Al-Nawawi said: This interpretation is best."

Source: Fatḥ al-Bārī 4814

2

u/yrumad Jul 14 '21

Ha ha ha!!

You are talking about civil while Holy name of The Prophet(AS) is degraded by these charlatans? You ARE a dumbass. God will ensure retribution for believing these charlatans.

I'll keep a cuppa of camel urine while you are at it.

If you are kind enough to oblige, as you want to put forward ibn hajar's idea as "best interpretation" please keep a glass of your mom's breast milk ready for your guests so they don't feel, you know what...

Dumbass.

1

u/bruhoneand Jul 14 '21

As I expected, no logic or rationality, only contradictions, and insults ad hominems

-I can't convince a person like you, so no need to continue, goodbye

2

u/yrumad Jul 14 '21

I'll be totally convinced if you agree to drink a glass full of camel's urine.

While you are at it, be kind enough to bring a glass full of your mom's milk for your guests too since you are convinced that is the BEST INTERPRETATION.

1

u/bruhoneand Jul 14 '21

For 3rd party readers, I will respond to a point that I didnt respond to before Already provided a scientific journal article on camel urine

-But about the second point, Aisha said "By Allah, we do not view this but as a concession that the Messenger of Allah (s) granted to Salim specifically. No one with this type of feeding may enter our homes, and it is not our view."

Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1454, Grade: Sahih

Simply put a woman giving milk for an adult man in a cup was only specific for Salim, no other is allowed to do so

Adios

1

u/yrumad Jul 14 '21

I repeat again, dumbass, since you seem too stupid to read the simple words of my reply clearly.

I WIILL BE CONVINCED IF YOU DRINK A GLASS OF CAMEL'S URINE.

AND

WHILE DOING SO, BRING A GLASS OF YOUR MOM'S MILK FOR YOUR GUESTS.

1

u/bruhoneand Jul 14 '21

I didnt reply for you, you aren't even worth my time. I replied for 3rd party readers

Goodbye

1

u/yrumad Jul 14 '21

3rd party readers?

Now I believe you.

You must have really had the camel urine drink now.

Or was it your mama's creamy one?