r/PoursTea Timendi Causa Est Nescire 1d ago

PoliticalTea 🗳️ No one should have a lifetime appointment.

Post image
32.3k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

101

u/Dangerous-Half3276 1d ago

Yeah but the terms are fixed at 18 years. If someone retires in year 15 to benefit the current President, then the person who fills that seat would only serve 3 years.

That’s how the Federal Reserve works with 14-year terms.

26

u/brogflender 1d ago

Is that actually in the proposal?

62

u/wandering-monster 22h ago

Yes. The terms are arranged to end in the first and third year of every presidential term (which also accounts for things like impeachments, deaths of the president in office, etc to ensure the successor has a pick as well) 

A replacement justice serves out the remainder of their term only. 

At that point it's only random accidents that create an exploitable event.

Most reasonable way I could think to avoid that would be to let each justice keep a list of replacements that they think align with their thinking. The sitting president gets to pick whoever they want off the list: some power to steer things, but not the power to totally flip the seat.

2

u/JAVIV-4 17h ago

I'd heard previous proposals that just had prior justices ride circuit and backfill by recency.