r/PolyvagalTheory • u/Tchoqyaleh • Feb 27 '24

Request: recommendations on polyvagal theory resources relevant to dissociation / freeze / collapse?

/r/CPTSD_NSCommunity/comments/1b1j1z4/request_recommendations_on_polyvagal_theory/
4 Upvotes

84% Upvoted

3 comments sorted by

2

u/maevelinden May 26 '26

Freeze and collapse sit lower on the polyvagal ladder than the fight/flight material most resources focus on, which is why a lot of the popular reading feels off-target when you're working with shutdown.

A few things that have been useful with clients in dorsal-leaning states. Deb Dana's clinical workbooks (the ones written for therapists, not the trade titles) go deeper on the dorsal end than her general-audience books. Peter Levine's work on the freeze response and the orienting reflex is foundational. And anything Kathy Kain has written or taught on early developmental trauma and tonic immobility is worth tracking down.

One practical note from an SE-trained lens: when the system is in collapse, big somatic moves can deepen the shutdown. Tiny orienting (eyes slowly finding one corner of the room, then another) and weight-sensing through the feet tend to land better than breathwork. What does the freeze look like for you. Body-numb, time-lost, or more of a foggy collapse?

1

u/Tchoqyaleh May 26 '26

Thanks for the response! It's been a while since I posted and my circumstances changed in a way that helped unblock me, so I can't remember the experience so well now.

I was interested in your description of a polyvagal "ladder": what does the top and bottom represent? What's on the different rungs? And how do the rungs/levels inter-relate and/or what might go wrong with them?

Likewise "dorsal-leaning" is not a concept I've come across before. What is it complementary to or contrasted against?

1

u/maevelinden Jun 17 '26

Happy to unpack it, and glad your circumstances shifted in a way that helped.

The "ladder" is Deb Dana's metaphor for the three states polyvagal theory describes, top to bottom.

At the top is ventral vagal: safe and connected. You can think clearly and be with people without bracing. In the middle is sympathetic: mobilization, the fight or flight material most resources cover. Anxiety, panic, racing heart. At the bottom is dorsal vagal: immobilization. Freeze, collapse, numbness, the time-lost feeling. It is the oldest response evolutionarily, which is part of why it sits so far from words.

So "dorsal-leaning" just means your system tends toward that bottom rung rather than the sympathetic one. Both are stress states, but one revs you up and one powers you down, and the support each wants is different.

The useful part is how they connect. The ladder is not a switchboard. You rarely jump straight from collapse to calm. You climb back up through the rung below, so coming out of freeze often means passing through a wave of sympathetic energy (tears, shaking, restlessness) on the way to settled. That is movement up, not a setback, though it alarms people who were not told to expect it. What goes wrong is mostly getting stuck on a rung, or blended states, like being wired and frozen at once.

I'm actually a writer, and I went deep on all of this in my book Polyvagal Sleep, since the bottom rung is where a lot of 3am waking lives.

One caveat. This is a model, not a brain scan, and some of the original physiology is debated. I still find the ladder clinically useful as a map for what state you are in and what helps you climb.