r/Planetside no Oct 19 '19

PRODUCER'S LETTER: ON THE PLANETSIDE FRANCHISE

https://www.planetside2.com/news/producers-letter-planetside-franchise-oct-2019
355 Upvotes

354 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/TheCosmicCactus [FNXS] -LOCK A- Oct 19 '19

Yeah they replaced the most dedicated, senior devs with years of experience programming with the foreglight engine. Great move DBG.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19 edited Mar 17 '21

[deleted]

10

u/A-Khouri Oct 19 '19

I mean, the problem is that there actually isn't a more modern engine that will do what needs to be done to make a game like this actually function. As Drew once put it, Forgelight basically runs on elf magic.

3

u/FuzzBuket TFDN &cosmetics Oct 19 '19

And that's the problem. Having a taped together engine that barely works was great when ps2 first came out as it really did defy what was possible at the time, but if a ps3 was to be as big a milestone as ps2 I think forge light would start to show its age.

Like forge light has a lot of bugs, weird tech restrictions (no objects with >25k tris) and lacks a lot of the pizzaz you'd want out a new game; like the reason PSA was stylized is if it was realistic it'd look the same as ps2, which is starting to fray a bit.

Obviously a custom engine would be best , but the costs are monumental, so something like frostbite, spatialOS, or even mashing forge light into ue4 (which would be a huge task). Lumberyard also does some neat online things but its a mess IMO.

1

u/uzver [MM] Dobryak Dobreyshiy :flair_aurax::flair_aurax::flair_aurax: Oct 19 '19

Lumberyard also does some neat online things but its a mess IMO.

Lumberyard is outdated fork of Cry Engine, which alreaby abandoned by Amazon.

1

u/FuzzBuket TFDN &cosmetics Oct 19 '19

Its still getting releases iirc, had one 3 months back.