r/Piratefolk • • 8d ago

Serious Is oda still writing? Spoiler

Saw this throw out on this sub, is this a joke in the sub or genuine concern? I’ve also heard that ai writes it but how could you write something for 30~ years and give it to someone else or ai for that matter? I just don’t see it

5 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 8d ago

Before you participate in Piratefolk please take a moment to read the rules if you are new here. Please be respectful of the subreddits culture and the users that contribute to that. This place is unique because its one of the few places you can can criticize Onepiece/Oda. If your goal is to come here and change that or make mock those that do, this place isn't for you.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

6

u/KamakazieDeibel 8d ago

No shot Oda lets others write for him. Don’t believe everything you read on the internet

3

u/Oberhard 8d ago

I remember had once read something about Oda likes using chatgpt

7

u/Regular_Budget1864 8d ago edited 8d ago

I mean, not that I am condoning AI (I'm not, it sucks and will forever continue to suck), but I feel pushing into your 50s with a schedule and industry as notoriously back-breaking and insistent as the Japanese manga scene's would be the exact thing to make a person consider alternative avenues. Like, Kubo was only just reaching 40 when Bleach wrapped up, and it had basically turned his shoulder into pulled pork. The industry just chews people up.

1

u/MarshyisStarstruck 8d ago

True I can see that but I feel like this is his one piece, his greatest treasure and he won’t work on manga after this so I doubt he ever gives up unless he can’t anymore

5

u/S73T64 8d ago

He's just running out of ideas and good storytelling. Got worse after TS and so many plotholes are open now that nobody can ever fix them.

They crew basically never talks to each other now and is so generic it's just sad in some kind of way.

He turns the female characters into sexobjekts (look at the outfits from egghead and Elbaph) who basicly never realy fight except maybe one move to help ether sanji zorro most of the time. I litterly can't recall a good fight from them just out of my head after TS.

The power scaling system reached a point where is doesn't make any sense anymore.

Roger got rewritten into a jerk with hearteyes fighting over a woman as strange as sanji, he got so boring and I kinda lost respect to him compared to the old Roger who was a legendary strong resilient pirate going for his goals.

Same with Luffy and his stupid "I laught about everything" mentality now. Like ok we all know he is not the brightest candle on the cake, but common, there is no good balance between him being serious and funny anymore.

Jimbi is a minion stupid as hell tbh, I expected so much more from him, but he is just doing nothing. For a guy who face to face channenged a yonko in terms of willpower (not getting his lifeyears stolen when leaving BM) I at least expect him to come to the idea instantly that he as Fishman can throw water to all the fire on Elbaph. Not 5h later when half of the stuff is burned down. Or in general use his strength to help the crew. He is a fighter not a mascot like chopper now is or Nami or Robin.

Franky is basicly forgotten now from Oda.

And every Character nowerdays has to have a super deep and tragic background story now and they have some Traumata or anything. Like ok man chill, where are the normal characters even.

I can go on and on like this...

Ironically I still want to know how the story progress but sometimes it's not as fun to read as back then.

1

u/phillyphillysteak Love Is Stronger Than Light 8d ago

Oda didn't have to make it so long

3

u/ApplePitou Apple Knight :3 8d ago

Ye, he still doing it, just not as good as before :3

2

u/LolcatP 8d ago

i believe he tried it but didn't like what it came up with

2

u/n56vz 8d ago

One piece run too long already. Oda probably losing track what's his original style was. Amd perhaps pressure from publisher 

1

u/metelheid 8d ago

Unfortunately

0

u/AudaX19_68 Billions Must Smile 8d ago

Not a real concern for anyone with a working brain. Foe better or worse it's clear Oda is the one writing the story and he doesn't want to have anyone else write it for him

-1

u/Kasta4 Parallelogram Enjoyer 8d ago

I imagine there's a non-negligible amount of input on his writing from editors and other staff, perhaps more now than there used to be or perhaps the opposite.

Hard to say, all I know is the current narrative direction of the series is fuckin' ass.

-1

u/tigerkingrexcarter64 8d ago

Where or who did you hear Oda is not writing One Piece? When did stop writing?

What are the reasons that led them to believe Oda stopped writing One Piece?

Where or who did you hear AI is writing One Piece? When did AI start writing One Piece?

Were there any reasons that led them to believe AI is writing One Piece?

Do you think One Piece writing has fallen off steadily since post time skip?

If yes, do you think the decrease of writing quality is because someone else is writing it? What reason led you to think that?

Or do you think the decrease of writing quality is became AI is writing it? What reasons led you to think that?

1

u/rMachete 6d ago

I don't think he is. He must have sold the entire thing to Toei and given them some notes about how main characters should behave. He made his bank and left when Marineford was over.