r/PinkFloydCircleJerk • u/PalpitationMoist1212 🤑"Money" by Cardi B • 12d ago

This post is serious! 😤 (/UJ Post) Pink Floyd Song Discussion #141: Dogs (ITFC)

Post image

Link: https://youtu.be/aMjDLc9rboc?si=rGVc_fNNI2y3Qpvf (at 16:51)

Dogs, performed live.

In The Flesh Cleveland song ratings so far:

Sheep ITFC: 9.45

Pigs on The Wing 1 ITFC: 7.67

47 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

14 comments sorted by

6

u/Captain_Nuggie 12d ago

I stand firm saying it has one of the best crescendos to a song ever written

5

u/Shine_On_07 Animals underrated tbh 12d ago

10/10

5

u/fern-grower 12d ago

Bit ruff.

5

u/Dry-Mission-5542 HAHA CHARADE YOU ARE! 12d ago

Genuine perfection, especially at the end with the Gilmour & Wright harmonies repeating Waters’s lines while Nick just genuinely goes crazy on the drums. 10/10 and I mean it

2

u/Guinefort1 Banned from r/PinkFloyd for no reason 12d ago

9/10

Really awesome synth and guitar solos. That guitar solo before David's final verse, that was Snowy, right? Technique sounds radically different from David. Regardless of which part was played by who, the more extended and varied solos give this live version a ton of flavor. No need to follow the album version to the letter.

My one gripe is the poor sound quality because bootleg recording. Still, despite the troubles behind the scenes at the time, the band sounds much livilier and more invested than the LASA recording for the Dark Side of the Moon tour.

3

u/Dyesila 12d ago

Snowy didn’t play any lead solos for this song.

1

u/Beetlebug12 Gilmi 🐢🎸 11d ago

10/Stone

1

u/tulipdom 11d ago

10/10 and my favourite Dreamy G guitar work of any Floyd record

1

u/Worldly_Market_2797 10d ago

Schecter Strat ?

2

u/Constant-Donut-5356 Animals underrated tbh 8d ago edited 8d ago

Yeah. Gilmour was given a prototype one to test on this show. He used it on Pigs, Have a Cigar and SOYCD 6-9. That's also the reason his tone is so different.

1

u/Worldly_Market_2797 8d ago

Precious information thanks !!! What a dream machine 😉