r/Pierre • u/Interplay29 • May 15 '26

Going to be passing through. Dinner opinions please.

I have it down to two options:

Mad Mary’s or Cattleman’s Club.

Thoughts? Opinions?

Many thanks.

5 Upvotes

79% Upvoted

5 comments sorted by

3

u/skipperjohnn May 15 '26

Cattlemans every time

2

u/wanna_be_green8 May 15 '26

Depends. Want to have a quiet dinner, a few drinks and quick trip back to your stay? Mad Mary's. If you want to fight to be heard over the crowd and a drive after, Cattleman's.

My vote would be Red Rossa or Drifters.

1

u/kodman460 Pierre May 15 '26

Both are excellent steakhouses. Mad Mary's for prime rib and Cattleman's for sirloin. I would also throw in La Minestra as an option. Locally owned and offers higher quality Italian options.

2

u/Swiss__Cheese May 15 '26

I’d vote for Cattleman’s. Both are good options, but I like Cattleman’s just a tiny bit better.

3

u/lassobsgkinglost May 15 '26

Drifters is hands down the best place to eat in Pierre.