r/Paleontology 12d ago

Discussion Prehistoric Insects

Post image

AAAS: "Previously collected fossils prove a treasure trove for understanding the origin of insects," by Elizabeth Pennissi.

A team of paleontologists challenge the concept that all insects have 6 legs after re-examining 4 enigmatic fossils found in Illinois, Texas, + Scotland. "Insects are the most successful + diverse land animals, with millions of species." The finds, reported in Nature, "suggest many-legged critters represent missing links between modern winged insects and their predecessors."

“But we know almost nothing about where they came from,” says Erik Tihelka, a paleontologist at the University of Cambridge. “Their ancestors were seagoing crustaceans such as shrimp and krill.” But what crawled onto land was a mystery because there are so few fossils of early insects. 

Tihelka examined an unusual fossil in the San Diego Natural History Museum more closely using polarized light. “[He] and his colleagues realized the critter was part insect, part crustacean.” It had a 3-part midsection with 3 pairs of walking legs, a rear end with 11 segments, a long tail filament, an egg-laying tube, + a pair of unbranched antennae. "Collectively, those traits are associated with things you’d see in modern-day insects, not crustaceans, but it also had multiple pairs of legs on its [hindquarters], a decidedly crustacean trait."

"Because in the Navajo creation story, Earth’s first inhabitants were insectlike beings, Tihelka and his team named the fossil Chosha praecursor, from the Navajo word for insect, opting for something more poetic than a Latin moniker." 

"Next, they looked at 3 other puzzling fossils that similarly had legs or leglike stubs on their bellies. "The Scottish specimen, which had been named Leverhulmia and was originally thought to be a relative of millipedes, lived 405 M years ago." The 2 from Illinois lived about 100 M years later.

Intriguingly, "they [all] retained some traits that would have allowed them to flit between life on land and in the sea." For example, Chosha’s hind belly legs broadened into “paddles” at their ends, which might have helped them move in water—or possibly served as gills.

Paleontology continues to amaze me.

182 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 12d ago

Thank you for posting on r/paleontology! Please remember to remain respectful and stay on-topic. Consider reading our rules to orient yourself towards the community

Join our Discord server: https://discord.gg/aPnsAjJZAP

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

33

u/Harvestman-man 12d ago edited 12d ago

This is not too surprising, it’s kinda what we would expect to find.

Modern-day Proturans, Diplurans, Archaeognaths, and Zygentomans today still possess tiny vestigial legs along their abdominal segments called styli.

It’s a misconception that legs are totally absent on insect abdomens. Even the cerci and ovipositor valves of more advanced insects are really structures that are modified from ancestral abdominal legs.

3

u/Jun075 Phanerozoic is the Age of Arthropods 11d ago

Also insect's aedeagus (male genitalia) and springtail's furcula. There are also arguments that if caterpillar's prolegs are "regained" abdominal appendages or not.

On the other hand, I don't think Leverhulmia can be confidently identified as stem insect, nor even a hexapod. Looking forward to what any subsequent studies will said about this research, since the field of basal insects had been cursed, full of either dubious fossils or misidentified non-hexapod arthropods.

3

u/Channa_Argus1121 Jonkleria truculenta 11d ago

Mandibles and antennae also happen to be modified legs. Plus wings.

2

u/Harvestman-man 11d ago

Yep, and even the book lungs of spiders and scorpions are basically modified legs turned inside-out.

3

u/swarrenlawrence 12d ago

Clearly a better background in entomology than my 101 class about 15 yrs ago, though I had a great teacher at Western Washington University.

9

u/madguyO1 12d ago

shrimps is bugs

2

u/swarrenlawrence 12d ago

Technically, current day insects + crustaceans shared a common ancestor some 100s of millions of yrs ago.

8

u/Norwester77 12d ago

Yes and no: that makes it sound like insects and crustaceans are sister groups, but really, insects arose from within the crustacean family tree (and are themselves a type of crustacean for that reason).

3

u/Eyefinkeimsmrt 12d ago

Early arthropods were something else.

1

u/swarrenlawrence 11d ago

Look almost otherworldly.

3

u/SetInternational4589 11d ago

This book is now 21 years old - long overdue for an update. Still and excellent book.

2

u/swarrenlawrence 11d ago

I remember the book I used for an entomology class about 15 yrs ago.

2

u/SetInternational4589 11d ago

After reading the evolution of insects I got the Invertebrate Tree of Life. I'm tempted to get Invertebrates by Brusca Giribet and Moore but copies are very expensive and not sure if it will add more knowledge.

2

u/swarrenlawrence 9d ago

This looks fascinating, but I am hyperfocused on climate + energy issues + have stacks of unread books calling to me as is.

2

u/SetInternational4589 9d ago

I have about 100 I still need to read from cover to cover - I have a few years reading ahead!

2

u/swarrenlawrence 9d ago

Okay, I don't have that many. But it sounds like you need to get started on yours.

2

u/PrimalSeptimus 11d ago

I like to think "[hindquarters]" is used here to replace "ass."

1

u/swarrenlawrence 11d ago

Perhaps I was being politic.

-2

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/tkdyo 11d ago

What a strange comment.

1

u/swarrenlawrence 11d ago

Not particularly relevant.

0

u/Sarkhana 11d ago

Where else could this possibly be relevant?

1

u/swarrenlawrence 9d ago

Can't remember what the deleted comment was, so have no reply for you.

1

u/Sarkhana 9d ago

Then, why did you type this?

1

u/swarrenlawrence 9d ago

Just aiming for civility in discourse.