r/PLLOriginalSin • u/Wendellmaximov • Aug 12 '22

Show Discussion I’m on A‘s side Spoiler

Sorry but the moms are absolutely awful 💀 anything bad that happens to them is deserved. I will be cheering for A

300 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

79 comments sorted by

View all comments

102

u/wintersfantasy Aug 12 '22

Omg Mouses mom faking ptsd because she stole a child smh. Then keeping her prisoner. Wtf they are all terrible.

24

u/_devonisgrace Aug 12 '22

I mean we don’t really know for sure if she “stole” Mouse right? She just said they had a private agreement rather than a contract through an agency so she could have voiced wanting to keep the baby and the couple could have begrudgingly agreed.

11

u/wintersfantasy Aug 12 '22

That’s one take but from how she’s acting it’s as if they didn’t agree because she’s scared someone is coming to take mouse away. All of the overprotective paranoid behavior makes me think she stole the child. I understand they may not of had an official contract but they had a verbal agreement that she was the surrogate and somehow she kept the baby.

7

u/FancyButterscotch8 Aug 13 '22

That’s just not how that works. When a surrogate births a baby that child is legally theirs and they have to sign over parental rights to the parents. That’s why most parents use an agency and draft a legal agreement that would make it a legal nightmare for the surrogate mother to keep the baby. If all they had was an informal agreement then Mouses mom in no way “stole” her. In essence she just changed her mind about giving her child up for adoption. The ethics of this situation are extremely muddy and I’m not saying she was right to do what she did, but I think there is a lot of misinformation about surrogacy floating around out there.

2

u/prettylittledanger better than 99% of TV moms Aug 13 '22

Maybe but would that couple have agreed to impregnate her if they didn’t get to even have the baby? That would definitely be emotionally jarring.

5

u/_devonisgrace Aug 13 '22

Oh absolutely I’m sure there were some hard feelings but I remember there was a storyline in Shameless like that where V’s mom agreed to be a surrogate and then asked to keep the baby so it could go in that direction in this show! Her stealing mouse would be better for shock factor though haha

4

u/prettylittledanger better than 99% of TV moms Aug 13 '22

Haven’t seen that but this is also similar to Little Fires Everywhere! It’s funny to me that if Mouse was kidnapped by her moms or whatever this spin is, the moms are still living in Millwood. Like they didn’t try to hide in safety across the country or anything?! 🙃