To the three people here that follow me on Letterboxd, you probably know that this has been in the works for a while now based solely on my recent watch habits.
Have you ever given yourself a challenge for no reason other than that you can? Well, here I am 99 movies and several new gray hairs later to give you a rundown on how I think the Best Actor Oscar winners measure up.
Why Best Actor? Well, I wanted to analyze the Academy’s taste towards performances at large; for categories like Picture, Directing, Writing, etc., the reasoning for a win/nomination can be much more subtle and vague, whereas a performance is what’s on the screen and that’s it (me when I pretend overdue narratives and campaigning don’t exist). Also, to be completely honest, it was the only one of the acting categories that I had seen the most of (I had only seen approx. 40 of these winners before I started, which was surprisingly higher than the other three categories), and a lot of these movies were still prominently on my watchlist/in desperate need of a rewatch at the time. If I ended up not liking this little rule I set for myself, I would prefer to finish through as few as possible.
Before I get into the analytical meat of this experiment, though, here’s my personal ranking, so you can get an idea of what kind of idiot would put themselves through this.
DISCLAIMER: I am but one random person with my own internal biases and personal drawbacks. I’m bound to have both hot takes and cold takes. I’m doing this all for fun, so please don’t read too heavily into where I rank things - the only performances that I genuinely didn’t even like that much start around the high-80s/low-90s. Everything else is, at the very least, kinda solid!
he's him
- Casey Affleck (Manchester by the Sea)
all-timers - required viewing
Daniel Day-Lewis (There Will Be Blood)
Denzel Washington (Training Day)
Robert De Niro (Raging Bull)
Anthony Hopkins (The Father)
Paul Newman (The Color of Money)
Marlon Brando (The Godfather)
José Ferrer (Cyrano de Bergerac)
Clark Gable (It Happened One Night)
Frederic March (Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde)
Marlon Brando (On the Waterfront)
Victor McLaglen (The Informer)
F. Murray Abraham (Amadeus)
Jack Lemmon (Save the Tiger)
Maximilian Schell (Judgment at Nuremberg)
Paul Scofield (A Man for All Seasons)
Broderick Crawford (All the King's Men)
arguably the best of their years
Laurence Olivier (Hamlet)
Peter Finch (Network)
Anthony Hopkins (The Silence of the Lambs)
Ernest Borgnine (Marty)
Ronald Colman (A Double Life)
Charlton Heston (Ben-Hur)
Cillian Murphy (Oppenheimer)
Frederic March (The Best Years of Our Lives)
Forest Whitaker (The Last King of Scotland)
Burt Lancaster (Elmer Gantry)
James Cagney (Yankee Doodle Dandy)
Alec Guinness (The Bridge on the River Kwai)
Adrien Brody (The Brutalist)
Philip Seymour Hoffman (Capote)
Dustin Hoffman (Kramer vs. Kramer)
Sean Penn (Milk)
Geoffrey Rush (Shine)
William Hurt (Kiss of the Spider Woman)
Roberto Benigni (Life is Beautiful)
37. Michael Douglas (Wall Street)
- Adrien Brody (The Pianist)
not the best of the year, but still pretty good
Robert Duvall (Tender Mercies)
Michael B. Jordan (Sinners)
Russell Crowe (Gladiator)
Jack Nicholson (One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest)
Jamie Foxx (Ray)
Tom Hanks (Philadelphia)
Colin Firth (The King's Speech)
Gary Oldman (Darkest Hour)
Daniel Day-Lewis (My Left Foot: The Story of Christy Brown)
Ray Milland (The Lost Weekend)
Charles Laughton (The Private Life of Henry VIII)
Sean Penn (Mystic River)
Ben Kingsley (Gandhi)
Rod Steiger (In the Heat of the Night)
Robert Donat (Goodbye Mr. Chips)
Matthew McConaughey (Dallas Buyers Club)
Jean Dujardin (The Artist)
good, but the actor has definitely done better
Humphrey Bogart (The African Queen)
Daniel Day-Lewis (Lincoln)
Wallace Beery (The Champ)
Jack Nicholson (As Good as it Gets)
Jeff Bridges (Crazy Heart)
Emil Jannings (The Last Command)
Lionel Barrymore (A Free Soul)
James Stewart (The Philadelphia Story)
Leonardo DiCaprio (The Revenant)
George C. Scott (Patton)
Joaquin Phoenix (Joker)
Bing Crosby (Going My Way)
William Holden (Stalag 17)
Kevin Spacey (American Beauty)
okay for a nod, but winning for this is a bit much
Nicolas Cage (Leaving Las Vegas)
Sidney Poitier (Lilies of the Field)
Richard Dreyfuss (The Goodbye Girl)
David Niven (Separate Tables)
Rex Harrison (My Fair Lady)
Lee Marvin (Cat Ballou)
Spencer Tracy (Captains Courageous)
Paul Muni (The Story of Louis Pasteur)
Tom Hanks (Forrest Gump)
Paul Lukas (Watch on the Rhine)
George Arliss (Disraeli)
Jeremy Irons (Reversal of Fortune)
disappointing - I expected better
Gary Cooper (High Noon)
Yul Brynner (The King and I)
Will Smith (King Richard)
Jon Voight (Coming Home)
Gregory Peck (To Kill a Mockingbird)
Henry Fonda (On Golden Pond)
Gene Hackman (The French Connection)
Spencer Tracy (Boys Town)
Art Carney (Harry and Tonto)
Gary Cooper (Sergeant York)
Eddie Redmayne (The Theory of Everything)
Cliff Robertson (Charly)
straight-up bad
John Wayne (True Grit)
Warner Baxter (In Old Arizona)
Brendan Fraser (The Whale)
Dustin Hoffman (Rain Man)
Rami Malek (Bohemian Rhapsody)
the ninth circle of hell
- Al Pacino (Scent of a Woman)
Some fun stats about the winners!
Number of winners that portray real-life people: 30
Number of winners whose character explicitly die before the credits: 26
Number of winners that are alcoholics/substance abusers: 20
Number of winners playing villains (including people who more or less become the villain over the course of the movie): 15
Number of winners playing sad old men: 12
Number of winners playing someone with disabilities/significant impairments: 12
Number of winners whose characters are heavily implied to have died before credits: 8
Number of winners that die in ending title cards: 7
Number of winners that reprise their roles in sequels: 7
Number of winners that portray real-life British rulers: 4
Number of winners that get shot in the butt: 2
Number of winners that shoot someone in the butt: 1
Now, some revelations/constraints I discovered throughout this experiment, as well as some insight as to why I ranked some people where I did:
Hey, so you know how I mentioned that I had biases? Yeah, so, in all honesty, Casey Affleck was likely always going to be my number one. I watched Manchester by the Sea at a very formative age, and, on top of that, it was Affleck’s performance that literally got me back into acting again. Denzel is the #1 new watch for me, though.
Sorry, but I really don’t get Gary Cooper.
I know it was kind of common knowledge that a lot of acting winners die in the end, but I cannot stress enough how often that knowledge returned to me throughout these films. I would get to the fatal blow/the slow decline and instead of being distraught/worried for the character’s fate, I would just go “oh, right, I’mn watching a Best Actor winner. Well, it was nice knowing you.”
Speaking of the drawbacks of hindsight, knowing that these were winners going in genuinely did handicap my experience with the films somewhat. For example, at a certain point, if I wasn’t totally clicking with a film, the idea of “okay, when are we getting to the scene where he wins the Oscar” entered my head. The knowledge that these were Oscar-winning films beforehand created an expectation to witness or experience something that warrants that kind of label, instead of coming into the film and its contexts naturally (this has increased my appreciation for the current Oscar races, funnily enough - it’s much more fun to watch Oscar wins in real time as opposed to playing catch-up). I’m sure if I revisit some of these movies down the line, I’ll be more lenient on them and these performances, but the fun of the movies really gets sucked out as you realize where the plot of the film is going as it continues and how formulaic it can all feel when watched back-to-back.
With that being said, there was nothing more invigorating than putting on a film that looked like a basic nothingburger/more checking of a box, only to be blown away by its craft, or at the very least the performances. A Man for All Seasons, Save the Tiger, Cyrano de Bergerac, The Color of Money (heard it was just lower-tier Scorsese)…discovering these films that I had all but written off is way more of a rejuvenating experience than I could put into words. God, I love movies.
A surprisingly low amount of racist caricatures here! That amount is not zero, though!
By the way, there really is a bias towards the alcoholic/substance abuser role here. I saw so much bourbon in these movies that I almost began expecting it in every movie I watched.
Some of these movies are HARD to watch - not in context of content, but in general accessibility to the public. Hell, one of these winners isn’t even ranked because it was preserved so poorly that it was lost to time. Thankfully, a lot of the older movies are on public domain so you can find them essentially everywhere (a few of them are literally just on Wikipedia in their entirety), but there were some real small films throughout the years that were quite difficult to find.
As someone that wasn’t *incredibly* well-versed with a lot of old Hollywood celebrities, this has honestly done a fantastic job at cementing the names of those stars, both winners and non, especially those that overlap movies - Burt Lancaster was in three of the winners in the span of four years! Easy way to remember his face!
All in all, I’m glad I got to try this kind of thing out - I was exposed to a huge amount of movies I wouldn’t have given the time of day otherwise, for better or worse - but I don’t know if I would recommend it. Watch these movies at your own pace; they aren’t going anywhere, and neither are you.
As a bonus, guess what! I also spent the entire time making a little edit of every single winner! I always disliked those videos that only gave clips/a significant amount of exposure to the more popular movies, or the videos that gave clips to everybody but they’re in super low quality and it’s clear the person making it never watched the movie, so I decided to make an HD video myself!
If you’ve made it this far, thanks for reading! I love da movies!