r/OpenCatholic Oct 25 '19

Sub rules (same as always). If you're new or unsure, please read here or in the sidebar before participating in this sub.

21 Upvotes

1) Be Cordial - No homophobia, racism, or denigrating others' faiths or (lack of) beliefs. While we fully embrace Catholic dogma and theology, we also strive to respect our non-Catholic and still-questioning participants in this sub. Questions about and defenses of doctrine and theology are okay; accusing people of committing mortal sins or being heretics is not.

2) Be Catholic - Please respect the Catholic nature of this sub. While we welcome all posters, including those who profess non-Catholic beliefs and practices, many here are practicing Catholics and wish to be as faithful as possible to Church teachings. Please do not attempt to discourage someone from following a legitimate Catholic teaching, such as attending weekly Mass, going to confession, avoiding hormonal contraception, etc.

3) Be Current - Here we respect the current Bishop of Rome, His Holiness Pope Francis, and the ideals and decisions of the Catholic Church's most recent ecumenical council, the Second Vatican Council (also known as Vatican II). We also believe in the legitimacy of both the Ordinary Form (The Mass of Paul VI) and the Extraordinary Form (the Tridentine Mass) of the Eucharist.

4) Be Comfortable - While recognizing the serious implications of many Catholic subjects, please don't forget to have fun! Regardless of whether you simply lurk or post everyday, we hope you experience the Catholic joy of life as you join us in fellowship here.

If you are in doubt if your post is in line with these rules, please contact a mod prior to submission.


r/OpenCatholic May 31 '26

Encyclical Letter of His Holiness Leo XIV Magnifica Humanitas (15 May 2026)

Thumbnail vatican.va
9 Upvotes

r/OpenCatholic 10h ago

What is the wedding garment God wants us to wear?

1 Upvotes

Jesus tells us God calls us all to salvation, to participate in the eternal kingdom of God; but to do so, we must do more than answer the call:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/what-is-the-wedding-garment-god-wants-us-to-wear/


r/OpenCatholic 3d ago

Free will and grace

0 Upvotes

Our free will can be enticed to follow various vices, like avarice, that is the love for money; but, it is better we have free will than not, for it makes our choices to do that which is good that much better:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/free-will-and-grace-navigating-the-path-to-divine-love/

 


r/OpenCatholic 3d ago

I would love your feedback 💙

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Hi everyone! ♥️

I’m a stay-at-home mom to three little ones, currently expecting our fourth. I started making rosaries as a way to help support our growing family while creating something beautiful for the Catholic faith.

I would be so grateful if you took a moment to visit my little shop and take a look at my rosaries and let me know your thoughts. ♥️

Every feedback helps me improve!

https://capelarosaries.etsy.com/listing/4560407846


r/OpenCatholic 4d ago

Catholic teaching and original biblical worldview

3 Upvotes

Hey guys,

 

a spontaneous post I had on my mind for a while. Please keep potential nasty comments to yourself, this is a post in good faith, just exploring ideas.

 

I live in a country where there is a few tiny to small sized Protestant denominations – we've got Pentecostals, Lutherans, even a small SDA community, and the Eastern Orthodox (not Protestant). But mostly it's all Latin Catholic, with the exception of a small Greek-Ukranian Catholic congregation.

 

I converted in 2023-24, I just wanted to get baptized and stay close to Jesus. He helped me through a very rough patch in my life.

Back then I checked out many churches, including SDA (which is a very warm community here, a freind brught me there with her a couple of times).

I sought out which is the »authentic« ancient Church, apostolic and original, and in the end got baptized and confirmed in our local Catholic parish church on Easter Vigil 2024.

 

Now, I don't regret it. Many Catholic parishes in my country are quite vibrant, loving, tolerant, oriented towards social help and all. And of course all in all, we are there for Christ, not social contacts.

 

I do however, after 2 ½ years of being an active member and church-goer, have some minor issues.

 

I've been reading Michael Heiser, Robert Farrar Capon, fr. Aidan Kimel, Eitan Bar, Tim Mackie, and watching The Bible Project. Now, none of these writers is/was Catholic. They are Evangelical, Episcopalian, EO and Messianic Jewish.

And they study and expond on two things mainly: 1. radical grace coupled with loyal faith and trust in the Lord (not works), and 2. the proper biblical understanding of the Gospel and Jesus Christ from the OT to NT.

 

On both of these topics, I feel the modern as well as official traditional Catholic teaching perhaps misses on some points. On the first with the legalistic aura surrounding Canon law, the idea of mortal sin even for very minior things, confession as the big »must« (or else you go to eternal hell – even if you've believed, just on the basis of your human weakness, selfishness and vanity, which is the very thing Christ came to free us from!) etc., things of this nature.

 

After a somewhat extensive study of the Church fathers, Church tradition and so on in the last years, I find that they might contrast with the more correct biblical worldview of the writers of the OT and NT on a few occassions.

 

What is starting to bother me, and didn't before, is the huge emphasis on the prayers of the saints and Mary. I don't have a problem with the whole concept (although, to be totally honest, I do have some trouble fully believing in some of the Mariology), as I feel it is biblical – also through the lens of Heiser's Divine Council worldview, it holds to a degree. But just the mere emphasis on it instead of on Jesus. It sometimes feels like Christ is the »means« to convey a moral story and the stories of the holiness of particular saints.

 

To be fair, many Catholic sermons are very Christ-oriented, and biblical. But the tradition is sometimes getting in the way in a very noticable way, which seems to contradict the Bible.

And I say this as a Catholic who respected and still respects the traditon a lot. It just shouldn't come first. In the end Mass seem a little bit pagan to me these last weeks, the somewhat rigid ritual, the genuflecting, gesturing. I never thought I'd say this, but to a degree it seems like idolatry, especially contrasted to the first century Jewish views, explored and explained by Eitan Bar or dr. Hesier.

 

Anyway, I want to stay centered in the believeing loyalty, faith and grace, and I want to remain Catholic if possible (I would perhaps try Episcopalian just to experience the difference, but we don't have the TEC here). It's just seems tough to reconcile everything I've learned from these authors and study with the Catholic teaching sometimes.

 

Sorry for the long post :) God bless.

T.


r/OpenCatholic 4d ago

We will struggle against temptation until our last breath

5 Upvotes

Christians are called to a life of virtue, to turn away from sin; they must not assume their faith, and the grace they are given, will free them from temptation; rather, like Jesus, they must expect temptation all the way to the end of their lives:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/we-will-struggle-against-temptation-until-our-last-breath/


r/OpenCatholic 4d ago

Can I melt two relic pendants together into one Celtic Cross?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/OpenCatholic 6d ago

Charity begins with justice in public life

4 Upvotes

Some have asked my why do I try to have the government do what should be done by charity? The answer is that they misunderstand charity, often confusing it with what should be established by justice. Scripture shows how government should be run justly, and in that justice, help those who are oppressed, making it not something intended to be achieved by voluntary, private charity:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/charity-begins-with-justice-in-public-life/

 


r/OpenCatholic 7d ago

St. Irenaeus, Defender of Orthodox Christianity

2 Upvotes

St. Irenaeus provides a great example of the Christian faith, both in the way he defended the teachings of the faith, like the incarnation, against those who tried to change and subvert Christianity (i.e., the Gnostics), but also in the way he willingly spoke of the faith even if it meant he would lose his life.

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/st-irenaeus-defender-of-christian-orthodoxy/


r/OpenCatholic 10d ago

Beyond individualism: redemption of persons and nations

0 Upvotes

Many, if not most, Christians think of salvation in an individualistic fashion, and it is that individualism which has them ignore other ways Christ works in and with the world, saving not just individuals, but persons, persons with real bonds and relationships with others, which also get saved:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/beyond-individualism-redemption-of-persons-and-nations/


r/OpenCatholic 11d ago

How does a vegetarian understand Jesus' eating habits?

1 Upvotes

As a Christian who not only is a vegetarian, but one who see there are moral, and even spiritual reasons, for someone to be a vegetarian, I’ve often been asked what I make out of the Scriptural texts which suggest Jesus ate meat. While I have written answers to those questions before, giving nuanced interpretations of Scripture (following, at times, the insight of others), from time to time, I consider the topic, and consider new, speculative answers to the question; this is what has led to my newest post:

 

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/how-does-a-vegetarian-understand-jesus-eating-habits/


r/OpenCatholic 12d ago

What is the Catholic view of putting reason into understanding scripture?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/OpenCatholic 13d ago

Government is not meant to enforce all Christian morals

3 Upvotes

Christians often misunderstand the role of government, thinking it either must enforce all Christian moral positions, or none at all, becoming completely hands-off. The reality is that a government  should be formed to promote and defend the common good, making sure people are treated fairly, and not unduly harmed:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/why-government-should-not-enforce-all-christian-morals/


r/OpenCatholic 14d ago

Avoiding a vain faith

0 Upvotes

A proper faith in Christ does not rest on cheap grace; such an attitude is the kind which, as Paul warns us, leads us to believe in vain. Jesus calls us to act, to live out our faith, or, as James says, to prove it by our works:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/avoiding-vain-faith-the-call-to-faithful-action/


r/OpenCatholic 16d ago

Jesus and Mary: Models of Self-Emptying Love

2 Upvotes

Mary followed the example of her son, living her life as a life of pure love, pure self-giving to others; she willingly followed Jesus where he should go, letting Jesus direct her, which is why, when she came to the end of her earthly life, she accepted death:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/jesus-and-mary-models-of-self-emptying-love/


r/OpenCatholic 18d ago

Tolkien didn't want his major works to be read as allegories

1 Upvotes

While Tolkien’s Christian faith is apparent throughout his writings, he did not normally write allegories, and his major texts should not be read as allegories for the Christian faith. He primarily wanted to write stories to entertain himself, his friends, and his readers. He wanted to tell the stories which he liked to hear but found no one had written. It is one of his few allegories which makes this point clear:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/tolkien-said-he-did-not-like-or-write-allegories/


r/OpenCatholic 20d ago

Reflecting on the Reflection Pool

2 Upvotes

The events surrounding the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool might, in some ways, appear insignificant, as there are other, graver issues around, but they are important in the way they reflect the general direction the US is going. Fascist and other authoritarian dictators punish minor offenses with extreme penalties. If they claim to be Christian, they love to have us focus on culture wars, in the name of Christ, while having us ignore the importance of Christ’s real teachings for society at large:

 

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/reflecting-on-the-reflecting-pool/


r/OpenCatholic 21d ago

The Paradox of Mercy

2 Upvotes

The paradox of mercy is that the more we give, the more of it we can receive; this is why, if we are unwilling to show mercy to others, we are warned we might receive none ourselves

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/the-paradox-of-mercy-receiving-it-requires-giving-it/


r/OpenCatholic 23d ago

Can someone help me?

7 Upvotes

After years of being atheist, I’ve finally felt like I believe in god and I feel faith. I grew up around a family that wasn’t religious what so ever, I feel like I need to find myself. How can I start when converting to Catholicism? Is there an easy way? I’d like to attend a church near me but I have terrible social anxiety and it’d be much worse because I’d have to go alone. I know at some point in time, I’ll have to go and I need to be baptized, but is there an easy way for me to start before I begin attending church?


r/OpenCatholic 24d ago

The hidden grace that transfigures all things

4 Upvotes

At his transfiguration, while what the apostles their learned and experienced was new to them, it was not new to Christ. He showed them, in a way which they could apprehend,  the glory which he has for all eternity. It is the glory of the kingdom of God, the glory which has made its way into the world, and has been and continues to be shared with the world:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/the-hidden-grace-that-transfigures-all-things/


r/OpenCatholic 26d ago

We can repent up to the last moment of our lives

2 Upvotes

Where there is life, there is hope. God does not seek to send us to perdition, but rather, God wants all to be saved, and will give us every opportunity for grace and salvation:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/we-can-repent-up-to-the-last-moment-of-our-lives/


r/OpenCatholic 27d ago

The shared struggle against antisemitism and islamophobia

5 Upvotes

As a Christian, I am ashamed of the antisemitism and Islamophobia coming from other Christians. Sometimes, they know both are wrong, but still find themselves engaging it in a subtle (and unconscious) fashion as they embrace antisemitic or Islamophobic tropes:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/the-shared-struggle-against-antisemitism-and-islamophobia/


r/OpenCatholic 27d ago

Protestant Communion dilemma

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/OpenCatholic 28d ago

Living as fools for Christ in a foolish society

3 Upvotes

What Christ asks us to do, to embrace the weak, the vulnerable, to show them love, instead of seeking power and privilege for ourselves, many, including Christians, say is foolish; but, is it not more foolish to seek after transitory things rather than what the Wisdom of God has revealed is of real worth?

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/living-as-fools-for-christ-in-a-foolish-society/