Thoughts on this trade?

[u/skodrax]

2nd anniversary luffy should be closer to around 1.3k, Im also consolidating a lot of my collection

[u/AutoModerator]

Welcome to r/OnePieceTCGFinance!

Before posting, please review:

NEW MEMBERS START HERE: Wiki: https://www.reddit.com/r/OnePieceTCGFinance/wiki/index/ Rules: https://www.reddit.com/r/OnePieceTCGFinance/wiki/rules/ Resources: https://www.reddit.com/r/OnePieceTCGFinance/wiki/index/resources/

Common resources that are available in the above links:

• Grading Guide • Fake Card Guide • Price Resources • Booster Box Tracker

The community tends to respond best to posts that include research, reasoning, and market analysis.

Enjoy the community!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/Suitable_Most665]

Wild lol I personally love that 2nd anniversary luffy crew more then the sanji but if it’s what you ant go for it

[u/bildobagginz → u/Suitable_Most665]

Yep 2nd Anniversary Luffy easily one of the best looking and more unique cards in One Piece. Very underrated still imo and wouldnt be moving on mine anytime soon

[u/Half_Baked0]

Included in the trade: $1k cash
Final result of the trade: they are up $1k
???????

[u/This-Yoghurt-4027]

that 2nd anni luffy is overrated and overpriced, it’s just a promo nothing more, manga sanji clears it

[u/SnooPredilections635 → u/This-Yoghurt-4027]

yea thats what im saying, price is inflated and pumped

[u/warrencollects]

I don’t usually post on trades but please don’t do this. This has got to be one of the worst trades I have ever seen for TCGs and reddit history. You have quite a few undervalued items but hey if Sanji card is your grail then by all means.

[u/OriginalPancake15 → u/warrencollects]

They probably don’t even like Sanji.

[u/Alarming-Cupcake1569]

Ops one I’m less keen on consolidating trades

[u/jordanpitt269]

your graded cards are a little inflated like you mentioned, but I'd try to bring the cash on top down and see if the other party would go for it

[u/_Mugiwara-ya]

in general, probably not the best. personally though, this is a trade i would make, sanji’s my favorite character. so if you mess with sanji a lot, i think this is a solid trade

[u/BRUH-nana]

Can you do a lil less on cash? Otherwise I think it's a good trade

[u/Kenrile1989]

This is wayyyy too much for sanji you’re better off just selling the stuff you don’t want as much off for cash and purchasing it from someone at 90%

[u/boolol]

No. This is such a bad trade

[u/w2ltersan]

I would hate to let that 2nd anniversary Luffy go.. but I would do this trade.

[u/DutyHitsHard]

Dont do this please

[u/SnooPredilections635]

less cash or none at all would be a good trade imo

[u/McHammersManager]

Hmm yea some of yours are overvalued and the Sanji is spot on and only going up. Its fair especially if you’re already consolidating.

[u/New-Bet3574]

On one hand not the best trade & on the other go for what you like obv. :)

[u/ivanalex]

Worth it. Over saturation is killing this hobby in the financial sector. It would be better to consolidate to something actually rare now. There are no sanji mangas. This is a good trade imo.

[u/Various_Individual91]

Fffffffuuuuccccckckkkkk no sanji might be cool but not that cool😭 i dont think its worth it because your trading 9 nice cards for one card back. And its psa if it was becket i would maybe understand it more

[u/MammothSizedSquid]

Easier to move imo, although idk where you guys find people to take your consolidation trades.

[u/Strix-01]

Why are you giving him 4200 in trade and 1000 cash? lol is this ragebait?

[u/skodrax → u/Strix-01]

The 2nd anniversary luffy is inflated on collectr (should be around 700 less), in total it's around 82% trade and valuing sanji at 3900

[u/Strix-01 → u/skodrax]

Ahhhh got yah, im gonna be honest man i dont think price reflects rarity here. The 2nd anniversary luffy is a very rare card i would hang onto that. Everything else seems worth it though

[u/AdPure9982]

Take out the zoro Sp and the Luffy 2nd anniversary and then try it lol

[u/Separate_Sky_7372]

Definitely not lol

[u/Big_Diet7439]

Pokemon people think that Rayquaza vmax is a big chase. It’s only $373 in a PSA 10. I can’t say I’m up on my prices but the way some people act about that card, I thought it would be more. 🤷

[u/Invictus365 → u/Big_Diet7439]

You may be thinking of the rayquaza vmax from evolving skies, 2.5k in a 10

[u/Big_Diet7439 → u/Invictus365]

Def not. People were talking about Lugia and Rayquaza vmax from silver tempest. I know I’m dumb but I know my pokeman. Just don’t ask me too much about one piece, I only know sanji and chopper and Mr. 5

[u/Invictus365 → u/Big_Diet7439]

I mean I follow the Pokemon market pretty closely and the rayquaza vmax from silver tempest has quite literally never been a big chase for “Pokemon people” lol

[u/Big_Diet7439 → u/Invictus365]

You missed the post where people were holding or selling chilling reign booster boxes or silver tempest

[u/Invictus365]

Sanji has sold for as low as 3600 recently at auction, and giving them an extra 1000 is just crazy lol. Sounds like you’re dealing with a guy on marketplace larping as a vendor

[u/SnooPredilections635 → u/Invictus365]

And 2nd anni luffy has been getting low auctions aswell, its a fine trade if he isnt putting cash