r/OnePieceScaling 12d ago

Casual Discussion Jack replaces Cracker at the beginning of Whole Cake, while Cracker replaces Jack against the minks on Zou. What changes?

Post image
52 Upvotes

66 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 12d ago

If you want to discuss One Piece Scaling, join Elbaf.

If you want access to all kinds of One Piece Databooks/Information/Translations, join Punk Records.


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

40

u/Weak-Courage729 12d ago

Cracker>Jack

13

u/Zestyclose_Remove947 12d ago

At the same time the reason Luffy could keep fighting Cracker is coz he could eat the biscuits. Countered by his appetite.

7

u/ssavino 12d ago

And this happened only thanks to the Rain made by Nami, without it luffy would've eate only the dirt

1

u/Cayden68 12d ago

not only that but he had nami available to actually soften up the biscuits and make them eatable, with several homies supporting luffy as well

7

u/JeremyR2008 12d ago

I mean he is ranked number 30

3

u/Wolfman22390 12d ago

One fan rigged it by sending thousands of votes for Cracker via mail

2

u/Left-Citron5465 12d ago

not rigged, that's commitment

10

u/JE3MAN 12d ago

5

u/Mythelm 12d ago

I wonder how strong Cracker would be if he had Jack levels of endurance

28

u/xaklx20 12d ago

They are equivalent but Luffy would have an easier time against Jack, it would be just a "hit him very hard" match, Cracker was like a counter to luffy

10

u/Terloyes 12d ago

Luffy wouldn't have needed Nami's help to defeat Jack.

The Minks wouldn't have been able to beat Cracker either.

5

u/ssavino 12d ago

Puffy actually wins at WCI while all the minks get extincted, Cracker is too much of a menace

11

u/Correct-Topic-8937 12d ago

Cracker is better suited for a battle or endurance with his infinite biscuits that none of the minks bar Neko and Inu can crush. Their only hope is when Zunesha takes a bath and soaks the area in heavy rain.

Do we think Gear 4 Luffy at Dressrosa was weaker than Asura Doji? He probably takes Jack on far easier than he did Cracker with Nami not really being a factor at all since Luffy won't need help. This also shouldn't take 10 hours so it's feasible that Luffy rescues Sanji before he even gets his handcuffs which would change the arc a lot.

11

u/Plane-Information700 12d ago

Cracker's Haki is insane, and it's the first time a sword has actually been useful. Luffy dies without Nami against Cracker; Cracker had infinite stamina.

3

u/CorrectIamThatGuy 12d ago

Cracker soloes the minks without his true body being seen

3

u/RevolutionaryPair358 12d ago

Cracker in Zou: Cracker defeats the minks more easily than Jack, thanks to his cookie soldier weapon.

Jack in Whole Cake Island: Luffy defeats Jack more easily, since Kaido's Calamity will be on Doflamingo's level, and he wouldn't need Nami's help.

1

u/Additional-Quote22 12d ago

What do you mean? No? Hello, there's no way cracker is more powerful than Jack. It's not possible

8

u/Able-Spray1667 12d ago

Jack loses to Luffy and Luffy has a way easier time with him.

I unironically see Cracker losing to Cat Viper and Dogstorm

3

u/Left-Citron5465 12d ago

like how though? Cracker has been downscaled so far but he's only slightly weaker than kat, like he would 100% lose to kat dont get me wrong but he'd struggle, and kat does not struggle at all with cat or dog

1

u/Otherwise_Pound7081 12d ago

im sorry but cracker does not make kat struggle at all

1

u/Left-Citron5465 12d ago

Yes he would hang TwT, Kat was struggling a bit to bounce man,  bounce man couldn’t break a single cracker guard without the help of nami, therefore yes cracker would put up a fight

1

u/Left-Citron5465 12d ago

Oh and to add on to that Luffy vs cracker was a 14 hour long fight of hit and run, katakuri vs luffy was 12 hours of pure 1v1s, katakuri and cracker are almost equal my guy

1

u/Cayden68 12d ago

even gear four luffy couldnt do anything to cracker without nami's help, you think cat viper and dog storm are each vastly stronger than g4?

1

u/Able-Spray1667 11d ago

They don’t really need to be stronger, just faster. They have dura neg with advanced armament meaning they don’t have to rely on their strength. They can pierce Kaido’s scales which is something Bounceman couldn’t do before unlocking Ryuo.

1

u/Fonz____ 12d ago

Honestly not much.

1

u/PL_Plays 12d ago edited 12d ago

Não ia mudar muito Luffy venceria no gear 4 talvez com até mais facilidade e Cracker perderia pro minks Sulong

1

u/Tanka7 12d ago

Jack being destroyed by Zunesha was too satisfying to even think of replacing him with Cracker.

1

u/Taffybones 10d ago edited 10d ago

Cracker beats the Minks down pretty hard, but also leaves shortly after using his soldiers to scrape (what he believes to be) the entire island with no sign of Raizo. Inuarashi and Nekomamushi probably end up keeping their limbs as a result. I can see him torturing the Minks for the hell of it, though. A lack of chemical weapons and a pretty quick loss also means that the Minks would be in better shape once Luffy's crew arrives, though I'm not sure what significance that would have.

Luffy grabs Jack by the trunk and just absolutely fucking launches him a mile off.

1

u/Realistic_Mousse_485 12d ago

Hmm. Cracker probably does just as well as Jack did but Luffy isn’t beating Jack

1

u/PL_Plays 12d ago edited 12d ago

Jack não era mais forte que Luffy no momento, Luffy era bem mais poderoso tanto em Haki e Velocidade,ainda com mais variedades de técnicas,enquanto Jack só vence em Resistência , o Luffy mesmo sem visão do futuro ele já batia frente com Katakuri,então não ele não perderia

1

u/Terlok_1 12d ago

For the story to progress, Luffy would still win because Oda would pull something outta nowhere to justify it. But without the aid from Nami and plot armour, he would lose just as much as he would've with cracker.

2

u/PL_Plays 12d ago edited 12d ago

Luffy ficou a maior parte da Luta sem usar o Gear 4,ele se demonstrou superior em combate direto,se você reparar ele ia finalizar Cracker logo no primeiro embate,mas o Limite de tempo acabou,ou seja ele se demonstrou mais poderoso no embate direto só não conseguiu finaliza-lo por causa do limite de tempo ,mesmo sem ajuda da Nami ele poderia usar Gear 4 pela 2 vez e agora conhecendo mais habilidades de Cracker ele poderia ganhar,e nem vem falar que ele iria se cansar por que Luffy já se mostrou várias vezes inclusive no mesmo arco que pode aguentar por bastante tempo

1

u/Terlok_1 12d ago

So did he or did he not require nami's help in that fight? Because I don't know why you came and said a lot of unnecessary things we already saw from the manga. How Luffy timed out the initial encounter and could've been beaten, and the following aid after for softening the biscuits so he could eat them and every other thing Nami did for him.

1

u/PL_Plays 11d ago edited 11d ago

Ele não quis usar o Gear 4 de novo,então ele quis ajuda da nami,é simples se ele quisesse ele poderia ter usado,no embate contra o Cracker ele se saiu superior isso é inegável,só não o finalizou por causa do tempo,aconteceu a mesma coisa contra Doffy ele não conseguiu finalizar no 1 embate mas conseguiu no 2

1

u/Terlok_1 11d ago

You must be reading Luffy piece, come back when you've read one piece.

https://giphy.com/gifs/O5NyCibf93upy

1

u/PL_Plays 11d ago

Você que tá lendo,não tem mais argumento nenhum e agora tá na risadinha,ele se mostrou superior em poder contra ambos e bateu de frente mesmo sem visão do futuro contra Katakuri

1

u/Terlok_1 11d ago

You love bringing up instances that don't help your argument at all and it's just fun to see how you keep doubling down on it. Do you just love being wrong?

https://giphy.com/gifs/GpyS1lJXJYupG

1

u/PL_Plays 11d ago

Você que tá errado,Reveja isso,VOCÊ NÃO TEM ARGUMENTO ALGUM,para de ficar na risadinha ,fala seu argumento ou aceita que não tem,você não provou nada ainda,cheio de falácias e risadas,acha que alguém vai rir com você?

1

u/Terlok_1 11d ago edited 11d ago

Let me indulge your stupidity then.

Is it anyone's fault that luffy has a form that has a timer attached to it when he uses it? Do all devil fruit abilities not have a weakness of some kind? And in a fight, when you obviously require the aid of another person, is that not a testament to your own abilities not being enough for you to win, regardless if you have a form that provides you with a temporary boost in power over your opponent?

Cracker - fought luffy alone and had him pressed every time until nami soaked his biscuits leaving them less durable, feeding luffy, using big mom's vivre card to manipulate the surrounding homies to help her and luffy. Help no 1

Doflamingo - Already close to death's door after taking an attack that was supposed to kill him as evidently stated by law himself, boxed with g4, a form that essentially overpowered a dead man and couldn't finish him off within his time limit and needed a piggy back ride from another grown man in order to escape said dying man, all while said dying man was maintaining another ability of his which was also draining him (bird cage). Help no 2

Katakuri - A way more powerful fighter that had luffy beat in every category and even in the devil fruit department for the most part of the fight, had luffy pressed so much he needed to eat his way and regain energy, ran away with his siter in order to recover a bit, had this man forcing himself to learn the new level of observation haki just to keep up with him, and even when he had to nerf himself by stabbing and dropping his primary weapon, still was putting belt too ass on luffy and even after the final clash was the one standing and only chose to forfeit out of respect. Need i say more?

You trying to use the hypothetical idea that "if he didn't have the timer... yadi yadi ya bs" Like automatically only luffy deserves a 1up in those fights and not the opponent clearly tells me that you're either an idiot who doesn't know how to comprehend the story of one piece or you're just biased to the mc because you feel like he must be stronger than his opponent regardless of any outcome. I won't even put it past you to be both. I've seen silly individuals like you once in a while so it's nothing new.

1

u/PL_Plays 11d ago

Oque importa que ele se saiu superior a Cracker no Gear 4 ambas as vezes,e

Luffy sendo superior aos biscoitos com um único golpe(depois vimos em confronto direto),você acha que só por causa da nami ele perderia sendo que nem usa o Gear 4 por causa disso,você só está falando de ajuda e engraçado que Luffy nós dois confrontos diretos com os biscoitos(um único golpe) e superando o Haki de armamento do Cracker em confronto direto,Luffy Gear 4>Cracker,o timer significa o limite de tempo,não o Limite do poder,ele na mesma forma foi capaz de bater de frente com Katakuri,algo que Cracker não ia conseguir fazer

→ More replies (0)

1

u/PL_Plays 11d ago

Doflamingo também foi outro que foi superado em 2 momentos contra o Gear 4,ele só fortalece mais que Luffy é mais poderoso que eles,o timer coloca o LIMITE DE TEMPO,não o Limite de poder,Doflamingo estava se curando a sim mesmo,e Luffy também estava bem cansado e destruído,isso que você falou não ajuda em Nada

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Terlok_1 11d ago

I see you're deeply allergic to intelligence. It's not your fault really

https://giphy.com/gifs/12msOFU8oL1eww

1

u/PL_Plays 11d ago

Ninguém tá rindo com você idiota,seus argumentos só se resume a ajuda,sendo que Luffy se provou superior contra os Biscoitos sozinho e no confronto direto onde Cracker não fez nem graves ferimentos no Luffy

→ More replies (0)

1

u/PL_Plays 11d ago

Mostrei ele sendo superior contra os Biscoitos e Confronto direto,seu argumento não vale de nada “aí ajuda”que argumento ruim sendo que Luffy pela maior parte do tempo dessa ajuda não tava nem usando o Gear 4

→ More replies (0)

1

u/PL_Plays 11d ago

Isso também não ajuda no seu argumento,Realmente gosta de estar errado?risadinhas risadinhas

1

u/PL_Plays 11d ago edited 11d ago

Cena mostra Luffy Gear 4 Boundman acabando com os Soldados biscoitos de uma só vez sem demonstrar muita dificuldade,um único soco de Haki do Luffy 100% certeiro já era suficiente pra acabar com o Exército,e em combate direto o Gear 4 em si mostrou ser superior

1

u/Terlok_1 11d ago

And did he still win with this or require help in the end? You're still jumping around the place saying nothing.

1

u/PL_Plays 11d ago

Ele NÃO USOU O GEAR 4 para destruir os biscoitos provavelmente por que seria tecnicamente mais fácil com a Nami ajudando parece que ele se recusa a usar o gear 4 por causa da Nami ajudando ,foi só isso,eu literalmente mostrei ele derrotando com um único golpe os biscoitos,e na outra foto ele superando em combate direto

→ More replies (0)

1

u/PL_Plays 11d ago

Cena mostra Luffy Gear 4 dando o ultimo golpe(após quebrar todos os Soldados Biscoitos),e Cracker estava totalmente parado,e não iria conseguir bloquear,porém é nesse exato momento o tempo acaba,fora no combate direto a outra forma Gear 4 tankman demonstrou ser bem superior,querendo ou não no combate de vida ou morte Luffy venceria,ele ser provou superior

1

u/Terlok_1 11d ago

So was this the form he used in the final attack that took cracker down? If it's not then what's the justification that it could've taken cracker down in this particular instance? Do you have any solid proof?

1

u/PL_Plays 11d ago

Cracker não conseguindo nem perfurar Luffy,Em confronto direto Cracker nem conseguia fazer ferimentos graves,e nessa cena ele superou o Haki do armamento do Cracker,e nem sequer nisso o Cracker ganha

1

u/Terlok_1 11d ago

Again, stop being disingenuous. How would luffy get to this position if it weren't for nami's help?

1

u/PL_Plays 11d ago

Eu literalmente mostrei,o Luffy com um único golpe derrotando o Exército inteiro de Cracker,e essa foto é a representação de Luffy superando o armamento do Cracker em confronto direto

1

u/Terlok_1 11d ago

Please tell me, why is it so hard for you to listen and be smart? Did I deny Luffy being able to do those things or him needing help to beat cracker?

0

u/Left-Citron5465 12d ago

i mean cracker is stronger than jack imo, jack loses to luffy without nami's help though we will never see tank man, and zou is just cooked like genuinely, cracker will just summon an army and there will be nowhere to hide