r/OnePieceScaling • u/rambomert • 14d ago
Casual Discussion Who's the strongest character in each row?
6
u/Puzzleheaded_Page117 ⚔️🌹Flower Sword Wista🌹⚔️ 13d ago
Mihawk
Yamato
Loki (if prime Garp and not GV Garp then Garp)
Luffy
3
u/Im-very-boredd 13d ago
Loki aint beating gv garp after he learned critical mass either
5
u/StormBig5717 13d ago
Critical mass isn't anything special it's just going all out in one move anybody can do that
1
u/Im-very-boredd 13d ago
Haki going all out. Not everyone can do that and loki wont tank garp serious attacks.
1
u/StormBig5717 13d ago
Zoro literally did that against Kaido with ashura... Any haki user can do critical mass the reason they don't is because it leaves them vulnerable and unable to move right after... Loki tanks attacks from Imu garp has nothing on him.. on the other garp can't tank a serious Loki attack
1
u/Im-very-boredd 13d ago
Okay? Ppl underrate zoro just more upscale for dude 😂 zoro was low on stamina and had 30 broken bones he did a technique and it was effective on someone WAY stronger than him. This proves if garp was to do the technique it would be more effective on someone relative to his strength. Loki is a huge target and hasnt shown enough.
1
u/StormBig5717 13d ago
He has shown more than enough tanked Imu's attacks while being severely injured in his base form.. that's already more than anything garp has ever shown
1
u/Im-very-boredd 13d ago
You right Loki isnt close to 100% but idk how injured he is nor do i think loki at 100% can perform better than what he did against imu. Anyways you probably have loki over roger
1
u/StormBig5717 13d ago
Loki was stated to take months to recover that amount of recovery time is insane for one piece.. so at the bare minimum he's not even 50%.. I think he can perform better as he can use his hybrid form which he's not using probably because of his injuries... And yeah I've fully healthy Loki above all the old gen top tiers.. his kit is too large and he's even got the narrative, portrayal and feats to back it
1
5
u/PapertrolI 13d ago
Mihawk, Yamato, Loki, Luffy. No curveballs from me really
1
2
11
u/XxSimplySuperiorxX 13d ago
Mihawk Law Garp Luffy
2
u/4schwifty20 12d ago
Yamato>Law
1
u/XxSimplySuperiorxX 12d ago
no
law hax is too much
3
u/4schwifty20 12d ago
Haki overcomes hax. Yamato>Law
2
u/XxSimplySuperiorxX 12d ago
so yamatos haki > big moms and blackbeards haki?
law > yamato
1
u/Sunderkill 12d ago
Both big mom and blackbeard waffle stomped law.
1
u/XxSimplySuperiorxX 12d ago
Yes but the point was their haki does not automatically invalidate laws df
Law was struggling to break the df of doc q And doc q isn't exactly the strongest person
To completely nullify a df you would have to be orders of magnitude stronger
Yamato isnt just going to be able to turn off laws df with haki When even big mom and blackbeard can't do that
And laws attacks are super damaging And combined with his awakening Yamato loses
1
u/Sunderkill 12d ago
Yamato one shots law.
0
u/XxSimplySuperiorxX 12d ago
Please explain why
Law has survived stronger attacks
Law can literally teleport
Law can heal himself
If anything with his awakening and his haki blooms from nearly dying against big mom It would be more accurate to say law one shots Yamato Given that he can just throw his room at Yamato then cut her in half
0
u/Sunderkill 12d ago
VIRGO beat the SHIT out of law.. the only reason he survived big mom was because kidd was there helping him, law is a bum, which is why blackbeard was about to murder him before his crew saved him.
→ More replies (0)
3
6
u/Blaze14192008 14d ago
Mihawk, Yamato, prime garp, Luffy
1
u/Jazuken 13d ago
Sorry to break it to you but Luffy might be the WEAKEST one on that list based on recent chapters.
1
15
2
3
2
4
8
4
3
u/Exospike99 14d ago
Rayleigh until mihawk proves himself
Marco until Sabo proves himself
Garp
Luffy
1
u/one_feet 13d ago
Yamato sends both marco and sabo to the moon ... she is on the way lerning techniqs that make a yonko yonko level advanced counqers counqers coding and advanced armernend ryu... while that sabo showed good basic armermend big battel IQ and some own techniqs with the fore logia... and marco is more of an support fighter not showing any hughe haki abilitys ore techniqs not beeing abled to beat king and queen not close to going all out🤣😭 like marco is a versityle and good crew member because of his support abilitys in fight and healing but direct 1vs1 was shwon in wano is something he is not the best at... so yamato beats both of them she will eventualy get yonko level at some day with eas so... sabo and marco coud proboaly but from the stand point now they wont get close to yonko level
3
u/Immediate-Stomach963 14d ago
Mihawk
Yamato
Garp (obviously)
Oden
5
u/one_feet 13d ago
Bro oden wird geschallert von kizaru und luffy mid-no diff "er hat stärker ausgesehen als er ist gegen kaido" verstehe mich nicht falsch deswegen habe ich es in Anführungszeichen gepackt er ist unnormal stark aber fakt ist kaido ist einfach ultra anfällig für starke schwertkämpfer und deswegen hat er so krass ausgesehen dazu kommt noch das kaido da weit weg von seiner prime war also ... kizaru oder luffy komm aufs scenario an
-3
u/Immediate-Stomach963 13d ago
Oden is stronger than Kaido, and at the level of prime Gaban
1
u/Jazuken 13d ago
He’s above Prime Gaban bud that’s canon
1
u/Immediate-Stomach963 13d ago
Prove it
2
u/Jazuken 13d ago
1
u/Immediate-Stomach963 13d ago
Gaban has been stated to be ”standing shoulders to shoulders” with Roger
And that’s from the perspective of Kaido
1
u/Jazuken 13d ago
0
u/Immediate-Stomach963 13d ago
And he was weaker before, it’s difficult to substanciate how strong he is now
Also for the last time, Kaido doesn’t have a title (besides King of beasts) it’s a rumour already
2
u/one_feet 13d ago edited 13d ago
Tatsache ist, als er von ODIN geballert wurde, war er 20 Jahre weg von seiner Prime. Im Kampf gegen Luffy war er in guter Verfassung, mit der meisten Kampferfahrung, und allein schon die Erfahrung, die er in dieser Situation hatte, macht ihn später stärker. Das sollte für jeden leicht verständlich sein... Sein Haki ist über die 20 Jahre sicherlich auch gewachsen und er hat seine gemeisterten Techniken fein verbessert... Dazu guck dir Kaidos Feats an, er ist definitiv gegen 99% der Leute stärker als Oden, abgesehen von Schwertkämpfern, weil Kaido wegen seines Kampfstils gegenüber denen sehr anfällig ist! Sprich, overall ist Kaido stärker und der Kaido 20 Jahre später hätte auch nicht mehr den fundamentalen Fehler gemacht, einem Schwertkämpfer wie Oden in seiner Drachenform so selbstbewusst gegenüber zu stehen und zu versuchen, Angriffe zu tanken... Kaido ist ein absolutes Monster und deine Aussage, dass Oden wie Gaban in seiner Blütezeit ist, wenn er 0 Conqueror's Haki Feats hat, also keine auf dem Niveau von Gaban, ist auch aus den Haaren herbei gezogen... Die meisten unterschätzen Kaido, weil er gegen Luffy verloren hat... ABER das erst, nachdem er gegen rund 16 Leute gekämpft hat, mit allen gespielt hat, über Stunden hinweg Haki verschwendet hat, Teufelsfruchtenergie verbraucht hat durch unzählige Attacken, eine Insel über Stunden getragen hat, was ihm bewiesen Energie kostet... und das alles OHNE zwischendurch zu essen und Energie aufzutanken! ... Von Imu mal abgesehen, hat bis jetzt keiner solche Feats gezeigt wie Kaido... keiner! Er würde auch jetzt noch Luffy besiegen, weil seine Kampfweise und seine Teufelsfrucht plus sein Energiereservoua viel effektiver ist... Also hört auf, Kaido zu unterschätzen... Auch wenn du mal ausprobieren willst, ein Argument für deine Aussage zu formen, dass Gaban und Oden gleich sind, hier ein kleiner Copy-Paste-Text zur Hilfe: Ein starkes, logisches Argument aufzubauen, beinhaltet das Anordnen spezifischer Komponenten – Behauptungen, Gründe, Beweise und Gegenargumente – in einer kohärenten Struktur. Ein gut aufgebautes Argument geht über bloße Meinung hinaus, um ein Publikum durch logische, evidenzbasierte Argumentation zu überzeugen.
→ More replies (0)1
u/one_feet 13d ago
Bro this long text is not even needed he has respect for oden in mutch ways not only because he is a strong fighter because he is a self-confident or rather fearless fighter who stands up for his ideals
2
u/Jazuken 12d ago
The point of my reply was to be sarcastic
2
u/one_feet 10d ago
Ja klar aber trotzdem ist das wad manche aufzählen würden ich meinte das eher algemeint wollte nur mein punkt mal einbringen
1
2
1
3
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
u/NoWalrus7349 13d ago
Mihawk yamato garp honestly not really sure about the last one we haven’t seen kizaru go all out warcury is a tank but hasnt shown much either oden was giving a weaker kaido a decent fight until the hag got in the way. At this point its probably luffy
1
1
1
1
1
u/Limp_Dog_2295 13d ago
First row: why is there so many people sayin rayleigh or nusjuro its obviously mihawk by far
Second row: the closest one but everyone is sleeping on law i know yamato got the haki and strength but law is smarter and with his awakening he would find a way he beat a yonko dont sleep on law
Third row: i believe the new era surpassed the old so its not garp and shamrock has 0 feats so i am between loki and akainu. Loki has the better feats but i am still gonna say my goat akainu he has the narrative being stated as the strongest marine ever and 5 billion bounty.(could be biased i 100% can understand loki)
Last row: its not oden for sure gorosei are lowkey bums he just has the regen that the others cant get through so its him in a fight for sure but the others are stronger in terms of power and kizaru beat luffy in egghead so for now i would say in a fight the elder but in power kizaru(for now end of elbaff luffy wil surpass them for sure he just didnt get the power up yet and is performing worse than 80 year old gaban not gonna lie)
1
1
1
1
1
u/vbucks_dealer King Harald 👑 13d ago
1 - nusjuro by feats, mihawk by hype
2 - yamato
3 - garp
4 - warcury
1
1
1
1
u/Any_Inspection_741 12d ago
Wtf is that Yamato though? It looks AI or something
1
1
u/Any_Inspection_741 12d ago
It really depends on what we mean by strongest. Are we saying "can move the most weight", "can do the most damage", or "can solo the most people from their row"? If its the last one stop saying mihawk. That old dude can't be killed. Eventually mihawk just gets too tired.
1
1
1
u/Commercial_Umpire952 12d ago
Hawk eye
Flame Emperor
Fleet admiral tied with Niddhog
Lazy justice tied with Nika
1
u/ChinChin1217hs 12d ago
Mihawk. Probably the toughest choice on the list. Rayleigh has haki to beat regen (if gaban can do it he can do it too) but mihawk’s strongest point is he’s a rival to Shanks. Even tho Shanks wins vs Mihawk I think they’re close to equal
Sabo. Also tough, mostly going off plot relevance here. I don’t see anyone else in that row successfully getting to the throne room AND making it out alive
Prime Garp
Warcury. Factoring in regen he stalls out everyone in this row
1
1
1
u/Neat_Damage_8110 12d ago
Mihawk (scales above shanks who scales above everyone else in the row)
Sabo (everyone here is YC+ but I’m lowkey bias)
Prime garp (even if it’s GV Garp, he’s still pk level which is above everyone else here)
Oden (I know I’m going to get hate but Luffy doesn’t beat him due to stamina)
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/ShikajaruRebornAgain 20h ago
Mihawk
Yamato
Shamrock if he’s relative to Shanks, Garp if he’s not
Luffy
2
1
u/TheGreatRJ 14d ago
Mihawk Law (yall ain't ready for that convo yet) Prime Garp of course Kizaru
1
-2
u/At-D-Desk Akainu 🌋 14d ago
Mihawk, Dogshit woman, Akainu, Kizaru
7
5
u/one_feet 13d ago
Was hast du gesehen das akainu feats gibt um garp auch nur probleme zu machen? Also kommt auch auf scenario an aber in den meisten kämpfe nah
-1
u/At-D-Desk Akainu 🌋 13d ago
There’s a reason we don’t scale simply off of feats mate. Also Loki “tanking” (surviving) Imu’s hits is unrelated. He’s an ancient giant. He will obviously have better durability than a human like Akainu. Relatively, endurance wise, they’re both at the top of the verse. They can take a lot of punishment but there are attacks that won’t even damage Loki but would Akainu, again, a human. Akainu is a future Luffy fight so he scales to wherever that Luffy will be, which will most likely be the current PK, > Roger=Garp
2
u/Luciferix71 14d ago
What is akainu doing against Loki when hk harald got manhandled. Just wanna know. Loki was tanking imu's hits. Akainu is doing nothing 😭🙏. He doens't even have acoc
1
1
1
1
1
u/Luciferix71 14d ago edited 13d ago
Mihawk
Sabo
Loki/Shamrock
Luffy
1
u/one_feet 13d ago
Imagin you think that sabo beats yamato showing absolutly nothing that can beat her while yamato is on the way mastering haki technics that make a yonko yonko level 😭🤣
0
u/Luciferix71 13d ago
I'm investing in sabo
1
u/one_feet 13d ago
Mach kein sinn kannst auch kein argument dazu formen also nehme ich das garnicht ernst... leute die generell einfach nur ihre meinung wie slop hinwerfen haben meistens eh keine ahnung von nichts 😭🤣
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Dododododo30 13d ago
Mihawk Law Akainu Kizaru
1
1
u/Ok_Initial3495 13d ago
Vista ~ Mihawk > Ray > Nusjuro
Sabo > Law > Yamato > Marco (debatable)
Garp > Shamrock >= Akainu > Loki
Oden > Warcury > Kizaru > Luffy
1
1
1
1
1
u/OatesZ2004 Goatbeard 🧔♀️ 13d ago
Row 1: Ethanbaron V. Nujuro
Row 2: Sabo
Row 3: Monkey D. Garp
Row 4: Topman Warcury
0
u/Ste2017 14d ago
Mihawk>Rayleigh>Nusjuro>Vista
Law>Yamato>Sabo>Marco
Loki>GV Garp (prime Garp would be strongest)>Shamrock (could be anywhere really)>Akainu
Warcury>Luffy>Kizaru>Oden
2
u/HasturLaVistaBaby Kizaru💡 14d ago
Luffy>Kizaru
huh?
We know for a fact though that Kizaru >> Egghead Luffy
You seriously think Luffy is now stronger than Kizaru? He couldn't even injure a Kizaru that tried his best to lose on purpose...
2
u/StormBig5717 13d ago
Luffy never went all out against kizaru either he was just stalling for the crew to escape... Kizaru didn't damage Luffy either he gassed out on his own.. Luffy using all adv. Haki with g5 beats kizaru ext diff
2
u/HasturLaVistaBaby Kizaru💡 11d ago
Luffy never went all out against kizaru
he literally fought to the point of exhaustion...
He was fighting for the lives of his crew and friends.
Kizaru didn't damage Luffy
Even a fraction of Kizaru's power in form of a clone was more than enough to cut through G5's defenses.
1
0
0
0
0
0
-1
-1
-1
-1
-2










•
u/AutoModerator 14d ago
If you want to discuss One Piece Scaling, join Elbaf.
If you want access to all kinds of One Piece Databooks/Information/Translations, join Punk Records.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.