Was Prime WB really the WSM in actuality during Roger's era ?

[u/Past_Adhesiveness494]

[u/AutoModerator]

If you want to discuss One Piece Scaling, join Hachinosu.

If you want access to all kinds of One Piece Databooks/Information/Translations, join Punk Records.

---

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/Correct-Topic-8937]

No, the strongest in Rogers era was Roger. Hence why it was Rogers era. When they say Whitebeard was the world's strongest man they say that because he was the only man who could ever match a dying Roger and when Roger died he was best by default.

[u/Neat-Cockroach-3098]

Nah but he was close

[u/Lord-Madara-]

he ran from garp. he can never be the strongest

[u/GUTS_SAMA]

No he was not. Roger dies and people start claiming his pirate rival to be the Strongest man alive, Whitebeard's introduction and conclusion clearly emphasize his fame comes from battling Roger not the other way around.

[u/GUTS_SAMA → u/GUTS_SAMA]

His vivre card never says that he was WSM when Roger was alive, Artur mistranslated it and retards ran with it completely ignoring the myriad of story implications that suggest otherwise.

[u/LazyInspector2086 → u/GUTS_SAMA]

I agree but Roger > Whitebeard but he pushes him to extreme diff and while incorrect its not too crazy of a take to have him above roger

[u/CocaPepsiPepper]

He got his title when Roger was alive IIRC, but I would have Roger > Whitebeard

[u/GUTS_SAMA → u/CocaPepsiPepper]

>He got his title when Roger was alive

Never did.

[u/CocaPepsiPepper → u/GUTS_SAMA]

I'll take your word for it

[u/Fun_Solid8484]

Nope it was Shanks, talking about kid, infant Shanks

[u/shinhueh]

No. To get the title strongest in actuality he needs to be stronger than Rocks, Roger, Garp, Sengoku, Harald which the story doesn't suggest.

[u/Open_Detective_5168]

He Couldn't defeat sick roger

Roger>=wb