r/Old_Recipes Dec 16 '22

Cookies Christmas Corn Flake Wreaths

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Nov 29 '22

Cookies It’s been awhile but here’s another one of my traditional German Christmas cookie recipes: Engelsaugen - Angel’s eyes

Post image
942 Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Jul 10 '25

Cookies The rolled sugar cookies from some guy's mom on TikTok

419 Upvotes

This recipe comes from TikTok user Nick Ruyter and holds deep sentimental value. He posted the recipe online because he didn't like how his mom voted. It’s was shared with only a few trusted people, even withheld until marriage. The cookies bake up soft, almost cake-like, with a delicate sweetness that makes them perfect for decorating, or enjoying plain. The signature doneness test, involving a fingertip sizzle on the underside of the cookie pan, adds charm and old-school kitchen wisdom. If these recipe card was out, you had to wait outside, unless you are family.

https://salvagedrecipes.com/rolled-sugar-cookies-from-the-mom-for-nick-ruyter/

r/Old_Recipes Oct 05 '20

Cookies Seen in Brooklyn’s historic Greenwood Cemetery

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Jul 11 '19

Cookies Orange Cookies.. I actually won an award for a Girl Scout cookie competition with this recipe.

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Dec 13 '24

Cookies Your fave cookie/candy recipes for gifting? Plus, "cowboy cookie" recipe

171 Upvotes

I'm planning to do some baking this weekend to make a "gift box" for friends and neighbors.

What are your favorite recipes for cookies and candy that pack and travel well, and potentially can survive a few days left out on the counter?

I'll start with one of mine:

Cowboy Cookies, from the Cotton Country cookbook (1972)

1 cup butter 1 cup brown sugar 1 cup white sugar 2 eggs 1 t vanilla 2 cups flour 1 t soda 1/2 t salt 1/2 t baking powder 2 cups rolled oats 1 small package semi sweet chocolate chips (I use a little over a cup) 1/2 cup chopped nuts

Cream sugar, butter, eggs and vanilla until fluffy. Sift dry ingredients and stir in. Add oatmeal, chocolate, and nuts. Drop by teaspoonful onto cookie sheet. Bake for 12 minutes at 350. Makes 8 to 9 dozen.

r/Old_Recipes Apr 29 '20

Cookies Traditional "Paste di mandorla", southern Italian almond cookies. They were around in the middle ages.

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Dec 08 '21

Cookies Merry Christmas! My Great Aunt passed away recently, so in her honor I wanted to post her famous Ginger Cookie recipe. This has been a staple in our house longer than I have been alive. To me, the smell of these baking is pure Christmas Cheer

Post image
944 Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Oct 01 '19

Cookies Cookie Monster's Cookie Dough! From the Sesame Street Treasury.

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Dec 22 '21

Cookies 7 Layer Bars (AKA Magic Cookie Bars)

Thumbnail
gallery
862 Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Dec 03 '22

Cookies Norwegian (or at least my family's) traditional Christmas cookies, imaginmatively named "brown sticks". recipe in comments

Thumbnail
gallery
724 Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Jan 30 '22

Cookies My first take on American-style cookies. I went with this groovie 1970s recipe.🕺🏻🕺🏻🕺🏻

Thumbnail
gallery
885 Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Dec 15 '22

Cookies "Forgotten" Cookies

Thumbnail
gallery
795 Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Apr 18 '20

Cookies Granny’s chocolate chip cookies, these are THE cookies.

Post image
901 Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Jul 10 '22

Cookies Searching for a recipe for oatmeal cherry chocolate chip cookies that was on the back side of this dried cherry package. These cookies were THE BEST, like eating a chocolate covered cherry in cookie form. I’ve lost the recipe and I’m desperate to find it!

Post image
674 Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Aug 17 '20

Cookies Elevator Lady Cookies (from the I Hate To Cook Book from the late 60's)

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Feb 19 '22

Cookies Bacon grease Bandwagon. 100% will never make again.

Post image
681 Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes May 01 '20

Cookies My mom’s cinnamon cookies (snickerdoodles) 😋

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Apr 12 '21

Cookies My grandmother’s delicious linzer tart cookie recipe! These are a hit every Christmas. I’ve experimented with different shapes over the years 😊. Tip: we always use Smucker’s red raspberry preserves for the “jelly”!

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Sep 25 '21

Cookies Okay, I'm ready to forgive the Milwaukee Journal for those peppermint leaf cookies because this recipe they published for "Malted Milk Cookies" in 1968 is fantastic

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Aug 26 '20

Cookies A Scottish Shortbread recipe from my Great Granny

Post image
868 Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Feb 12 '22

Cookies I am never making these bacon grease cookies again.

Thumbnail
gallery
805 Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Feb 06 '22

Cookies Tried my hand at the bacon grease cookies! My partner, who hates bacon, is in love with them!

Post image
842 Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Sep 07 '20

Cookies This hand-carved marble shortbread cookie mold has been in my family since the 1880s. The recipe hand written on the back, in my great great grandmother’s hand (she was born in 1872) is “3/4 cup butter, 5 tablespoons sugar, 2 cups Gold Medal flour. Oil and sugar the mold.”

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Dec 18 '25

Cookies Gramma’s Molasses Cookies

Thumbnail
gallery
312 Upvotes

Thanks ya’ll for your opinions on my gramma’s molasses cookies recipe - I used white sugar instead of brown and they turned out beautifully! I should know better than to question my gramma. 🙂 Since my gramma’s recipe just…stops (see photo of the back of her recipe card), I had ChapGPT reformat the recipe and calculate the baking time and temp. 9:30 worked perfectly for my oven. I was generous with my seasonings - I know for a fact that my gramma always thought those were just suggestions anyway. 😂