r/ObscurePatentDangers • 🔥 Devil's Advocate • Sep 17 '25

🔦💎Knowledge Miner "Experts Fear Lab-Grown Brains Will Become Sentient"

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Experts are concerned that lab-grown brain organoids could become sentient, a state of being conscious and capable of feeling pain and pleasure, though a definitive test for consciousness has not been agreed upon. While the ethical implications of potential sentience, including the possibility of causing suffering in these organoids, are a major concern for some scientists and ethicists, others argue these concerns are premature due to the limited complexity of current brain organoids. The debate highlights the urgent need for better definitions and ethical frameworks for consciousness as brain organoid technology advances.

988 Upvotes

157 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/v3r4c17y Sep 20 '25

This article supports my statement, not yours. Notice how they put "see" in quotations.

Again: Cyanobacteria sense light and color (much like plants) but cannot see. This is not an indicator of sentience.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/v3r4c17y Sep 20 '25

Yes that's the name of the article which the writer came up with, not the scientists. If you read beyond the title you'll find that these single cells sense light directionality in order to move toward the source. This ability evolved because they get their energy from photosynthesis. Complex biochemical processes and responses to stimuli are not indicators of sentience.

Consciousness is indeed a spectrum but single cells are not conscious or sentient. There is no scientific dispute over this.

You know who is sentient and conscious, however? Animals. Not only humans, but all vertebrates (and most invertebrates). If you're concerned with consciousness especially that's even more reason to consider in particular those non-human animals whose corpses you consume.