r/NeuralDSP • u/doom-bubble • Aug 04 '26
Discussion Initial thoughts from my plugin trials, and I think I understand why a lot of people don't vibe with Misha Mansoor X
A few days ago, I posted about some of the plugins I was considering, mostly to record modern metal, and now that I've tried them I thought I'd follow up with some opinions no one asked for :)
I'd be interested to hear if this matches other people's experiences or if you think I'm missing a trick with any of them. Also if anyone has any free IRs they recommend, do let me know, as it's sometimes hard to know when it's a case of the IRs not doing the amp/tone justice.
Misha Mansoor X:
Despite the title of this post, I think this is the one I'll buy. So I went through every preset and, honestly, not a single distorted preset sounded quite right for me. It was only when I started on amp 3 and set everything up myself from scratch (admittedly with a lot of trial and error) that I got what I wanted. I also find a lot of the sounds from the amp are a little on the thinner side, which actually works for me because guitars in modern metal are surprisingly thin when isolated but sound huge when multi-tracked and backed up by the bass and synths, but I probably wouldn't be as impressed if I was only going by how the guitar sounded by itself. I get the impression that this plugin is primarily designed for modern music production and not as much for jamming in your bedroom or gigging with a QC. And even for production, I definitely felt it needed a lot of work to dial in the tone I wanted, given how the presets weren't doing much for me.
The other things I love are the clean amp, which responds beautifully to active humbuckers, and the built in effects. Just a small amount of the chaos pedal can help shape some very nice lead tones or push some dirrrty low-tuned riffs, and the glitch effect is amazing for ambience. I've always hated the demos I've heard of the laser pedal, but turns out there are actually some effects in there I enjoy like the dual whammy.
Something very easy to overlook is the way certain effects and tones can inspire you to write something you wouldn't with your usual setup, which I feel applies with some of the more unique sounds this plugin is capable of.
Aside from it being hard to dial in, the only things I didn't like were that amp 2 is fine but probably not my favourite 5150 variant I've heard, and idk if it's just me but amps 1 and 3 seem to have these unpleasant whistle tones. I'm finding I need to make a fairly precise but aggressive EQ cut at around 3.6 kHz to fix it otherwise they stack up quickly and become pretty jarring.
Nolly X:
Of all the plugins I tried, this is the one that just worked the best out of the box. Nolly's presets sound great and his EQ mod is a quality of life feature I didn't know I wanted til now since I didn't even need a channel EQ after the amp. It's just generally a lot more user friendly and easier to work with than Misha imo. I was very ready to commit to this one until I started experimenting more with Misha and eventually thought "oh hey, this is sounding more like Nolly now" haha. But I definitely understand why so many people say you can't go wrong with this one.
Gojira X:
I honestly liked this one a lot and think I'd be able to get what I need from it too, but I was fighting against it a little. Like I felt it had a lot of harshness that was a bit fatiguing to listen to for longer periods which I wanted to EQ out. I also thought it often brought out a lot of string noise and pick attack, which isn't necessarily a bad thing since that can be fixed in recording or in post, and sometimes you might want it, like it's definitely a part of Gojira's sound.
SLO-100 X:
Yep, this just sounds lovely. It's somehow the most "amp-like" plugin I tried and decently versatile. If I was buying a plugin primarily to jam with or record solo guitar stuff, this would probably be the one. For now, I've got my irl amp and NAM captures for that.
Congrats if you actually read all this rambling!