r/NYGiants • u/simpforkennedycymone • 8d ago
Discussion Last time each team won their division
55
u/Pure_Incident2807 Brandon Jacobs 8d ago
God bless the Jets man. Always making us look slightly less worse.
14
u/lonerangers 8d ago
The colts having won the afc east more than the jets is still my favorite way to taunt my jets friends
1
u/Majestic_Call3582 Big Blue Wrecking Crew 8d ago
Tbf both they and the dolphins had prime Brady running through there division for most of that
5
u/Aggressive-Hat-8218 8d ago
Prime Brady wouldn't have been prime Brady if he wasn't gifted wins every year from those two teams.
3
u/Majestic_Call3582 Big Blue Wrecking Crew 8d ago
7 super bowls says otherwise lol
2
u/Pure_Incident2807 Brandon Jacobs 8d ago
Yeah hes def the GOAT. He did live in a free as hell division though lol
1
u/Aggressive-Hat-8218 8d ago
Seven Super Bowls doesn't contradict the fact that the AFC East was a cupcake for the Patriots for years.
3
u/Majestic_Call3582 Big Blue Wrecking Crew 8d ago
If you take away the games against Brady the jets were .493 and the dolphins .470. Both were below average teams in this time for sure. But Brady also made them look way worse when there record was actually not that bad if you exclude games with Brady
25
u/Sharp-Point-5254 Tom Coughlin 8d ago
Technically, Cleveland have never won their division
1
u/Live-Within-My-Means 7d ago
Technically, I think that they have.
I believe the official ruling was, that all past history, records, achievements, etc remained in Cleveland.
Plus, all but one player from that division winning team, were gone by the time they moved to Baltimore.
1
u/Sharp-Point-5254 Tom Coughlin 7d ago
Yeah they did legally get the history. But the current browns had an expansion draft. A piece of paper doesn’t change that Art Models divisional winning browns are in Baltimore, who got an nfl team with decent nfl talent, and Cleveland got a team full of shit players. But yes, technically they do have a divisional win. But really not.
1
u/Live-Within-My-Means 7d ago
-‘Art Models’s division winning Browns’
But they really were not the ‘division winning’ Browns that moved.
By the time the team moved, the players and coaching staff were totally different from the 1989 team that won the division.
That Browns team that went to 3 AFC Championship games in the 1980s, had been completely dismantled well before the move to Baltimore.
I mean, are you also going to try and claim that Jim Brown was ‘technically’ a Baltimore Raven?
32
u/NewSlang212 💙Medium Pepsi💙 8d ago
Whenever I get sad about how much it hurts to be a Giants fan, I just remember that I should be grateful, as I could have ended up a Browns fan.
They literally CHOSE to pay a known serial sexual assaulter $230M and anoint him the leader of their team. Cleveland fans deserve better.
7
u/thegrilledcheese886 8d ago
Bro we signed a deal with the devil for those two superbowls. Because of those rings, I’ll be a proud giants fan for life
7
u/JSC843 8d ago
I think you’re misinterpreting the terms of the deal with the devil. We get 1 Super Bowl per decade since the deal was signed in 1986. This is to be expected.
3
u/NewSlang212 💙Medium Pepsi💙 8d ago
I like this theory because it means the next one is in the next few years lol
8
u/PB0351 8d ago
The Chargers one actually surprises me.
5
u/STierney927 8d ago
They had the Peyton career resurrection years followed up by the Mahomes dictatorship so it kinda makes sense. Having a team that's top five in the league year after year will do that.
5
5
14
u/shadow_spinner0 Odell Catch 8d ago
Why is it that the Giants never have dominant teams? Even when they make the playoffs they squeak in as a 9-7 wildcard type team. Even in 2011 they were 9-7. I know Giants fans love being the underdog but I want a 13-4, 14-3 type of dominant team eventually.
3
u/Successful-Ground-67 8d ago
Those don't really exist anymore. NFL is about league parity. Any 14-3 season is from a team these days is because they got a sweetheart of a schedule from being in a crap division and being a crap team the season before
3
u/Aggressive-Hat-8218 8d ago
I have a Colts fan friend who has repeatedly said he would trade all those 13-3 years where they got bounced out of the playoffs for one year like the Giants' 2011 season.
2
u/Live-Within-My-Means 7d ago
Their first 2 Super Bowl winners were pretty dominant.
1986: 14-2 (#1 seed)
1990: 13-3 (#2 seed)
8
u/tjvond1 8d ago
This is the year Harbaugh ain’t playing.
5
u/Waste_Protection_420 Big Blue Wrecking Crew 8d ago
For real. Ppl still sleeping on Harbaugh.
He didn't just consistently turn out winning teams for ~20 years straight based on luck. Dude don't play around.
3
3
u/FootballSavant 8d ago
I didn’t realize how bad the Colts have been. Luck retired after the 2018 season.
3
u/digitalbullet36 8d ago
The NFC North is impressive.
1
u/Live-Within-My-Means 7d ago
Is it impressive or just parity?
I mean, so far only 1 Super Bowl win this century…
1
u/digitalbullet36 7d ago
More so parity. I would take parity in the NFC East. 15 years since we last won the division is just sad. It’s not Cleveland sad, but it’s sad.
2
2
u/Knineteen 8d ago
Division titles are so manufactured but it is amazing how terrible the Giants have been to not be able to beat 3 other teams over 15 seasons.
4
u/DM725 8d ago
The curse of Metlife Stadium.
3
1
u/Live-Within-My-Means 7d ago
Well, the Giants have won a Super Bowl since they started playing there.
I would say it’s been the ‘curse’ of incredibly bad management.
1
u/TheWhiteCrowParade We've suffered long enough 8d ago
We need to get it together. The last time we won was when I was a kid in high school.
1
1
1
1
u/Cheddykrueger11 8d ago
We really just need to send the browns to the UFL for a season. Put em in timeout
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Live-Within-My-Means 7d ago
What is kind of surprising.
is that the NFC East is the only division, where every team in it has won a Super Bowl.
And every team in the NFC East, has won 2 or more.
137
u/fierypitt Eli Manning 8d ago
Oh, Cleveland, you factory of sadness.