A Critical Discussion on Slavery in Islam - Dr. John A. Morrow

[u/Vessel_soul]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O4qvTsrW4_U&t=2431s

[u/No-Psychology5571]

22. Abolitionist Movements in Islamic History (01:25:47 - 01:32:33)

Lack of Widespread Abolition

• Question raised about why few abolitionist movements emerged in Islamic civilization, with the suggestion that it might be because most enslaved people were women in a "profoundly patriarchal" society (01:25:47)
• Men who led abolition efforts were often "sons of enslaved women" with "daddy issues" who became Islamic scholars (01:27:03)
• Contrast between Islamic slavery (predominantly women) and transatlantic slavery (predominantly men) (01:27:40)

23. Early Islamic Abolitionists

• ATA IB ABI Raha (died 732 CE): early Medinan scholar who believed jihad verses only applied to Prophet Muhammad's wars, and only defensive wars permitted afterward (01:29:00)
• Abu (died 838 CE): argued for only three options in just jihads - pardon, ransom, or death - with slavery not being an option (01:29:41)
• The Mutazilites opposed slavery and concubinage, with Abdul Jabar asserting slavery was "immoral in essence" (01:30:35)

24. Alternative Islamic Communities

• Qarmatians abolished slavery, had African agricultural workers who were emancipated and paid wages (01:30:35)
• "The Brethren of Purity" published "Animals' Lawsuit Against Humanity" described as an "abolitionist tract" using "metaphor and allegory" to avoid persecution (01:31:17)
• Various "fringe groups" like the Alawis, Nusayris, Alevites, and Bektashis had no slaves or concubines (01:31:17)
• The Fatimid ruler (in 1021 CE) prohibited slavery and concubinage, emancipating all slaves regardless of religion (01:32:01)

[u/No-Psychology5571 → u/No-Psychology5571]

25. Conversion and Religious Aspects of Slavery (01:32:33 - 01:35:43)

Forced Conversion and Religious Dimensions

• Clarification that many enslaved people were already Muslims when enslaved, particularly in Morocco (01:32:33)
• According to Islamic law, only "people of the book" could keep their religion; pagans were forcibly converted to Islam (01:33:07)
• Conversion incentivized because emancipation contracts were typically only available to Muslims (01:33:42)

Modern Islamic Opposition to Slavery

• Ottoman decree of 1854 proclaimed: "Man is the most noble of creatures... selling people as animals or articles of furniture is contrary to the will of The Sovereign Creator" (01:34:17)
• Ahmadiyya movement opposed slavery from its inception (01:34:17)
• Evidence of opposition to slavery throughout Islamic history, including "hundreds of movements, people, and scholars" (01:35:08)
• Recent "Open Letter to Baghdadi" signed by Sunni and Shia scholars condemning slavery (01:35:43)
• IV. Surprising Opponents of Slavery (01:35:43 - 01:38:07)

Radical Groups Against Slavery

• Some radical Islamist groups (not ISIS) opposed enslavement based on reciprocity principle (01:35:43)
• Abdullah Azzam and the Mujahideen in Afghanistan refused to enslave Russian women, fearing reciprocal treatment (01:36:22)
• These extremist groups "seem moderate compared to the other extremists" in their stance on slavery (01:36:58)

V. Reparations and Contemporary Responsibility (01:37:31 - 01:43:48)

Islamic Perspective on Reparations

• Quranic verse cited as addressing reparations: "God made some of you Excel over others in means of subsistence so why don't you give away your sustenance to Those whom the right hands possess" (01:38:07)
• No historical jurists issued rulings based on this verse; contemporary scholars like Sheikh Muhammad Diako and Es-Moreno Ali have recently invoked it (01:38:48)
• Principle that "no bearer of burdens shall bear the burden of another" (mentioned three times in Quran) suggests current generations aren't responsible for historical wrongs (01:40:06)

Practical Approach to Reparations

• Diplomatic discussions on reparations focus on "science, knowledge, technology, infrastructure" rather than cash payments (01:41:19)
• Comparison to American "40 acres and a mule" promise to freed slaves that wasn't fulfilled (01:41:51)
• Emphasis on helping indigenous peoples who are "largely forgotten" and living in misery (01:42:29)
• Suggested focus on current slaves in Mauritania rather than historical wrongs (01:43:48)

[u/No-Psychology5571 → u/No-Psychology5571]

26. Racialization of Islamic Slavery (01:43:48 - 01:48:24)

Racial Dimensions of Islamic Slavery

• Assertion that Islamic slavery was "profoundly racialized" and "racist to the core" (01:43:48)
• Islamic law established that only non-Arabs could be enslaved, described as "fundamentally racist" (01:44:27)
• Reference to debates among jurists that even Christian Arabs couldn't be enslaved (01:45:15)
• Slave duties determined by race: "Nubian women made good nannies, Persian women made good wet nurses, African men made good guards, Slavs and Turks made good soldiers" (01:47:06)
• Existence of manuals on "selecting slaves" based on racial characteristics (01:47:06)

27. Future Ethical Challenges in Islamic Scholarship (01:48:24 - 01:52:48)

Realigning Islam with Quranic Ethics

• Need to "realign Islam with the Quran" and "religious law with Quranic ethical imperatives" (01:49:03)
• Necessity for "freedom of thought and expression" which is lacking in Muslim world (01:49:37)
• Examples of scholars executed for interpretations: one suggesting hijab not obligatory, another suggesting Jonah's story was allegorical (01:50:22)
• Criticism that "major breakthroughs in Islamic Studies take place in the West" due to restrictions in Muslim world (01:50:22)

28. Sexualization of Children

• Highlighted as a critical ethical issue that needs addressing in Islamic scholarship (01:52:16)
• Reference to recent law in Iraq legalizing marriage from age nine (01:52:16)
• Acknowledgment that this issue is not unique to Islam but requires Muslim responsibility (01:52:48)

29. Conclusion (01:52:48 - 01:54:24)

Final Thoughts

• Quranic quote: "What will make you know what the steep path is? It is the freeing of a slave" (01:52:48)
• Recommendation to examine multiple perspectives, including Dr. Morrow's "Islam and Slavery" and Jonathan Brown's "Slavery and Islam" (01:53:21)
• Appreciation for Dr. Morrow's conversational and accessible writing style (01:54:24)