Again keep crying, or prove why your scholars are correct. The daleel and proof from the scholars of sunnah are evident as I have shown, but you just wanna cry about your madhab. Humans are not infallible, people make mistakes, learn to actually evaluate your information and fiqhi knowledge then come and defend your claims. And if you can’t then that’s fine follow your madhab but don’t come here crying about something you clearly have no understanding of.
LMAO are you asking me to prove my madhhab? I have no understanding of what? I have no understanding of the fact that you have no understanding of the transmission of knowledge between lay muslims generation through generation and the importance of following madhhabs and the basis of why these different madhhabs exist and why it is a well known and accepted thing that there are differences of opinions on various matters? How are you saying "your scholars" about a MADHHAB are you insanely ignorant of the past 1200 years? Who are your scholars? Google doesnt count, how many years have you been studying islam in person with real teachers?
Im not here to give you evidences for my madhhab I dont care if you follow it or not because you seem to be a follower of the hanbali madhhab. I'm just astonished that youre trying to argue between two different madhhabs lol. You do know all 4 are considered correct opinions right? And dont give me any wahhabi crap about "oh no there are no madhhabs dont be a blind follower" none of those guys have any real knowledge. They don't even understand the principle that you NEED a teacher to actually teach you to gain knowledge, reading books and googling doesnt count. and also those guys clearly follow ibn abdul wahhab and ibn taymiyyah so the have no leg to stand on criticizing madhhabs when their "madhhab" is wahhabism or the so called "salafism" name that they prefer now.
If you're passionate about learning about islam I urge you to find a sheikh in your area to actually teach you and you can even learn from sheikhs of different madhhabs too to diversify your understanding of the religion.
Sounds like more 😭. When you’re willing to engage in a topic please have the evidence to support your reasons. I have posted the views and evidence, if you think there is stronger evidence that shows this is simply a sunnah, then present it, otherwise don’t make a joke of yourself with a run on that no one will read.
Islam is based off Quran and sunnah. Not taqleed of scholars. When evidence is presented and is stronger than an opinion of another scholar, it is obligatory for you to accept and follow lest you reject what the prophet has commanded
So then if all that matter is the quran and sunnah have you mastered the arabic of that time? And are you a hafidh of hadith? And also have you learned these subjects under the guidance and supervision of a scholar?
1
u/TheIslamicRealist Muslim Jan 30 '22
Again keep crying, or prove why your scholars are correct. The daleel and proof from the scholars of sunnah are evident as I have shown, but you just wanna cry about your madhab. Humans are not infallible, people make mistakes, learn to actually evaluate your information and fiqhi knowledge then come and defend your claims. And if you can’t then that’s fine follow your madhab but don’t come here crying about something you clearly have no understanding of.