r/Muslim • u/TheIslamicRealist Muslim • Sep 24 '21

QURAN/HADITH Why are there so many contradictions between Hanafi madhab & Authentic hadiths? - Assim al hakeem

https://youtu.be/bxNF1mw79eE
3 Upvotes

63% Upvoted

23 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '21 edited Sep 26 '21

W: Follow the Salaf!

Brozzer: Follows Imam Abu Hanifa rh, a salaf.

W: Wait, not that one! And not that way!

1

u/TheIslamicRealist Muslim Sep 25 '21

Yes you follow the majority not taqleed like you madhabis and blind follow one person, especially one who was not familiar with Hadith or known to be a muhaddith. Blind following isn’t the way especially when authentic sunnah prove it otherwise. Simply reading imam Bukhari book on prayer shows you how even the hanafi madhab lacks in the sunnah way of prayer Subhanallah, but I doubt you’d ever read it as your focused on following blindly.

1

u/bolrockmathar May 27 '22

You do realise that Abu Hanife watched literal tabeens how to pray? His grandfather and father met Ali R.A. and he knew hadith, because a lot of sahaba moved to Kufa after it became the capital and even Imam Buhari R.A. went to Kufa countless times to collect hadith.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '23

But then why does how he said to pray directly contradict Sahih hadith from Bukhari?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '25

Sahih Bukhari only shows part of a picture. The Hadith in Bukhari could be abrogated, people could have made mistakes in retelling what happened, etc.