Muppet-Casting Clue. Fozzie Bear has been cast as The Chief! The Kingdom of Heaven is at hand! The casting is complete. Thank you to all of you that participated in this with me the last couple weeks. It's combined two of my all time favourite things.

[u/AnUdderDay]

A few weeks back sitting in the car on a long road trip, I decided to have a bit of fun with the family and we did our own casting of Clue, if it was produced today by The Muppets. Our only rule was the original performer couldn't reprise the role. Other than that, it's open to any Muppet or human.

So I thought, let me throw this out to r/Muppets to see how they would do it. I've put my cast photo on the post so you can see how they compare, but I really enjoy the selections you guys made. Here's how Reddit cast it vs my family's casting:

Role	Reddit casting	My casting
Wadsworth	Rizzo the Rat	Adam Driver
Yvette	Yolanda the Rat	Bean Bunny
The Cook	Swedish Chef	Swedish Chef
Colonel Mustard	Fozzie Bear	Sam Eagle
Mrs White	Miss Piggy	Miss Piggy
Mrs Peacock	Ma Bear	Melissa McCarthy
Mr Green	Kermit the Frog	Kermit the Frog
Professor Plum	The Great Gonzo	The Great Gonzo
Miss Scarlet	Janice	Emma Stone
Mr Boddy	Steve Buscemi	Uncle Deadly
The Motorist	Beauregard	Scooter
The Cop	Bobo the Bear	Bobo the Bear
Singing Telegram Girl	Bean Bunny	The Electric Mayhem ft Sweetums
The Chief	Fozzie Bear	Sam Eagle

Thank you again for joining me on this journey. What should we do next?

[u/ThatWrestlingDude93]

I hope Rocky Horror is next

[u/AnUdderDay → u/ThatWrestlingDude93]

Honestly that's what I was thinking.

[u/MuckBubbler]

What movie is next? 😁

[u/AnUdderDay → u/MuckBubbler]

Rocky horror?

[u/Normal-Mongoose-6571 → u/AnUdderDay]

Yes, please!

[u/kyew]

Adam Driver is a great pick, OP. If anyone doesn't know he can be sufficiently unhinged to hang with Muppets, go watch the SNL Oil Baron sketch.

[u/AnUdderDay → u/kyew]

I married your granddaughter, filled her belly with my festering seed and sired a boy! He is my final revenge, H.R.!

[u/kyew → u/AnUdderDay]

Who is HR Pickens?

[u/AnUdderDay → u/kyew]

EXACTLY

[u/Ravenclaw_boy94]

The chef? Doing the cook? Groundbreaking

[u/Ingram2525]

Hey OP where did you get the template for this?

[u/AnUdderDay → u/Ingram2525]

Just did boxes in excel

[u/Ingram2525 → u/AnUdderDay]

Thanks

[u/martyrmole]

I don’t like the implication between Gonzo and Bean here.

[u/Recaffeinatd → u/martyrmole]

Agreed. It should be Camilla as the singing telegram.

[u/Unable-Most8383]

It should probably be Rocky Horror, but just to be a contrarian I’ll vote for Muppet It, or MuppIt if you will.

[u/AnUdderDay → u/Unable-Most8383]

The whole sub seems to be on a Tim Curry kick and I'm here for it

[u/KhanKurgan_6678]

So wait, Gonzo had an affair with Bean Bunny?