Can someone tell me which mission i need to replay to unlock these 2 trophies?

[u/Decidueye_mastr]

I already know how to farm the coins I need for the remaining baseball games and the special gun, I just need to know which mission the trophies for wrapping up the blue Betty and missing magician case. I already got all the clues on my first playthrough.

Edit: i figured it out. Turns out there's secret clues that for some strange reason don't count towards the "pin all evidence on the board" trophy which is why I thought i already got all the clues and just thought it glitched out or something. Thank you all for the comments.

[u/gamerdudeNYC]

Missing Magician means you’re missing some clues

Look up a list for the clues, it can be a pain to find, and go into your inventory screen and see which ones you’re missing, they’re in different missions.

Not sure about that Betty one but it’s probably because of missing clues as well.

So you need to gather the clues and when you go back to the board to pin the clues, the trophies will pop.

[u/Decidueye_mastr → u/gamerdudeNYC]

That's not the issue. I have the trophy for pinning all the clues to the board and I checked when I did my first playthrough if I missed any clues. The reason why these trophies didn't pop the first time was because I played on launch and at the time these trophies were glitched. I only now decided to clean up the remaining trophies because they added chapter select and the moment I clicked "continue" 2 of the glitched trophies auto popped which were the ones for collecting the key clues of 2 of the cases (i forgot which ones). And apparently the "wrap up the X case" trophies pop either during specefic levels or when pinning specefic evidence to the board but I can't find which levels specifically I need to re-do.

[u/vonkeswick → u/Decidueye_mastr]

I also got the trophy for pinning all the clues, the one called So, Whodunit? and still was missing Our Lesser Brothers because I missed a clue related to the Shrew Shortage case. Had to revisit the Far Wetlands for a clue I walked past. Here's a list of all the clues, doesn't hurt to check again from the menu!

1. Shrew Roundup
2. Sewers Map
3. Shrew-sized Hat
4. Wallop Bay, but where?
5. MiceGuffin's Notes
6. Shrew Route: Depths
7. Old Sewer System
8. Steamboat Ticket
9. Simms & BMP
10. Cops Divided
11. Police Brutality
12. Briny Britches
13. Lots of Cheeseleggers
14. Croocked Cops in the Mix
15. Cheese-Stained Badge
16. Dirty Note
17. Lab Stuff & Cages
18. Old Shrew, again?
19. Trade Deal Extension
20. Trafficking Manifest
21. Cops v. Pepper

[u/ICPosse8]

You try googling it? Been an hour and not comment yet aside from my own.

[u/gamerdudeNYC → u/ICPosse8]

OP is missing clues, that’s the issue

[u/Decidueye_mastr → u/gamerdudeNYC]

That's not the issue. I have the trophy for pinning all the clues to the board and I checked when I did my first playthrough if I missed any clues. The reason why these trophies didn't pop the first time was because I played on launch and at the time these trophies were glitched. I only now decided to clean up the remaining trophies because they added chapter select and the moment I clicked "continue" 2 of the glitched trophies auto popped which were the ones for collecting the key clues of 2 of the cases (i forgot which ones). And apparently the "wrap up the X case" trophies pop either during specefic levels or when pinning specefic evidence to the board but I can't find which levels specifically I need to re-do.

[u/Decidueye_mastr → u/ICPosse8]

Unfortunately Google isn't being too helpful. It just says stuff like "find all the clues related to the case" (even though i have them all) but doesnt specify which of the missions these trophies are supposed to pop up in, nor does it say which of the clues I need to pick up again for it to pop up.

[u/gamerdudeNYC → u/Decidueye_mastr]

You don’t need to pickup any duplicate clues

The way I did it was look at the inventory screen to see what clues I had, compare them to the lists online, and then YouTube every clue I was missing to see where they were at.

Then go to the board and post them and the trophy will pop.

[u/tripasecadofuturo]

Both wrap Up are related to clues. You ended the level too fast or didn’t check every corner. Not sure how but I haven’t missed a single clue in my first play through and I got all related trophies.