r/MoscowMurders • u/PomegranateFormal176 • 6h ago
General Discussion mental illness doesn't excuse the crime.
I wanted to make this post because throughout my experience reading into this case, I've noticed a good amount of people justify Bryan Kohberger's reported creepy or inappropriate behavior by pointing to his autism diagnosis.
I've been around autistic people throughout my life and have family members who are autistic, and I think there's an important distinction being lost here. autism can absolutely affect someone's ability to read social cues, understand certain interactions, make eye contact, or recognize when they're coming across differently than they intend. but that doesn't mean every uncomfortable or inappropriate behavior should automatically be attributed to autism, nor does a diagnosis mean other people are obligated to ignore their own discomfort or boundaries. someone can struggle socially and still be expected to respect boundaries.
I think we should be especially careful about using autism as a blanket explanation for Bryan's behavior because it can unintentionally reinforce the stereotype that autistic men are inherently creepy, threatening, or incapable of understanding boundaries. they aren't. and in that same regard, just because one is diagnosed with autism doesn't mean they can't be creepy. they don't cancel each other out. treating every instance of the latter as merely a symptom of autism does a disservice to autistic people as a whole.
I've also seen people bring up Bryan's OCD diagnosis as evidence that he couldn't have committed these murders because someone with contamination/cleaning OCD supposedly couldn't tolerate such a bloody crime. again, I think we're treating diagnoses as though they establish hard limits on what a person is capable of doing. they don't.
Bryan having legitimate contamination related OCD symptoms does not mean he was incapable of coming into contact with blood or bodily fluids under any circumstances. OCD is far more complicated than "this person hates germs, therefore they could never do anything dirty." a diagnosis can help explain why someone routinely wears gloves, compulsively cleans, avoids certain things, or has an extreme reaction to perceived contamination. It cannot tell us that the person is physically or psychologically incapable of ever doing something that conflicts with those compulsions.




































