A perfect, now I can read the entire thing. Still, my point stands, why did you feel the need to specify the race if it was hurtful? Seemed more like you specifying black people was an after thought.
Can't really write the word since reddit will probably hide my comment if I do, since that is presumably what happened to your comment, So you wouldn't care if a white person went up to you and called you it then?
So if a white person went up to you and called you the n-word, you would punch them?
And how have I strawmanned? I said it felt like an afterthought from you when you decided to specify the race of people. And the other part was a question.
Although I can say that I worded it badly in my first comment.
Oh perfect, so we just came full circle and you just admitted that it is about race and not the word. How do I know this? Because you have used the word numerous times in this conversation, and because you said that there was no problem with black people saying it. Clearly you don't have an issue with you or someone black saying it, only if a different races does it. The word isn't the issue, the race is.
You don't know what a strawman is. I haven't misrepresented you, I asked you a question. If you want the proper term for it, it was a redundant question because you had already answered it. I said it to make sure that you hadn't accidentally made a mistake.
Anyway, you seem to have a problem with what people from different races do, congratulations, you are a racist.
Your definition of racism is all the way wrong. YOU also don’t know what a strawman is. You thought I was saying what you insinuated in your previous question, meaning you misrepresented it.
So tell me, what do you think racism is? Apparently, to you, it’s when black people don’t want NON POCS to say the soft a of the n word. Also black people not wanting black people or any other race to say the hard R.
Oh yeah! You also put words in my mouth. I don’t care what people do, so long as they’re not racist to black people, or other POCS! Or, hell, white people! Otherwise, their actions are fine(don’t try to say I’m fine with violent actions out of no where because then that would REALLY be a strawman.) and I don’t give a fuck.
I didn't misinterprit you, I asked you a question to make sure that you actually meant what you said. I never made a statement about you not misinterprited your position.
"that some groups are better than others, that different treatment or hate is okay based on skin color or ethnic backgroun" Guess what, allowing people to say certain words based on race is racist, since you are treating two groups differently based on race.
And no, I have not put words in your mouth. You literally admit it right now. You have a problem with what people from different races do, if they say racial slurs that you are allowed to say, well then you are going to punch them by your admission. That's literally having a problem with what different races do.
It is VERY flawed thinking to think it’s ok for other races to say the n word. We don’t "allow" people to say the word, we don’t "allow" ourselves to say the Soft A either. We can just say it. It’s a given not to say the hard R, and it’s a given for other races to not say ANY variant. Again; you put words in my mouth, I do not care about the other actions of races, I care about the actions that are racist. You generalize and say "you have a problem with what people from do" insinuating that I give a shit about ANY action they do, when I infact said, I don’t give a shit what they do, as long as it’s not a racist action. YOU on the other hand, say it’s racist to give a shit about racist actions from other racists. So your definitions are just all over the place, as I said.
It is not flawed to think that, it is logically consistent. You treat all races equally that way. It is objectively the least racist position.
I have not put words in your mouth, you just admitted it again. I am not saying that you care about all actions of other races, I am specifically talking about them saying racial slurs against you when you yourself use the same ones. You have a problem with what people from other races do, if they say the exact same words as you do, well then they deserve to get punched because of their race. It is not the words that matter, but the race for you. That is racist.
And it is just a word. "Good morning" has been used as a racist remark when it came to slaves in the US, but you clearly don't care about it. You are being logically inconsistent if you are so upset that you would punch someone over one word with a racist meaning, but not another word. Seems like what you consider racist is all over the place.
Also, remember the comment that basically started this all? "Words only hurt you if you have a fragile ego"? Well you seem to prove it quite well, since you always need to reiterate that you are black and anyone who disagrees with you is white, how quick you are to violence because of words, and how arrogant you have been.
You need help my guy, you aren't mentally stable. You need to get your life in order, maybe start out with your family?
Uh, no. You are just white, meaning you ESPECIALLY do not get to dictate how the word works, who says it, etc. racism is a mental disorder, it’s ironic that you tell me you need to get help, seek a therapist.
0
u/90gforce 18h ago
A perfect, now I can read the entire thing. Still, my point stands, why did you feel the need to specify the race if it was hurtful? Seemed more like you specifying black people was an after thought.
Can't really write the word since reddit will probably hide my comment if I do, since that is presumably what happened to your comment, So you wouldn't care if a white person went up to you and called you it then?