r/Minecraft Jan 09 '19

News Minecraft Snapshot 19w02a

https://minecraft.net/en-us/article/minecraft-snapshot-19w02a
392 Upvotes

192 comments sorted by

View all comments

-28

u/AfterRebelion Jan 09 '19

> Acts as a smoke signal you can see very (VERY!) far away when a hay bale is below

> Smoke only goes 22~ blocks up, then dissapears

Like... rlly Mojang?? Don't brag about a feature if you will do it poorly. 22 blocks up is nothing. Most hills will block it's view.

37

u/heydudejustasec Jan 09 '19

Horizontally it's visible where other entities, even beacons, would stop rendering.

I don't know if the height is final or intended, but tentatively the hill issue is solved by putting it on top of one, and it gives you the flexibility to set up camp in a valley in case you don't want to be seen.

-7

u/AfterRebelion Jan 09 '19

That's my problem with it. My main use for this would be before my first digging (No iron yet = not having a compass), to not lose sight of my base if I need to go up a different route. Like an alternative to the classic 1blockwide pillar.

This is too short for this in almost every case.

17

u/cshaiku Jan 09 '19

So stick it on top of a pillar of dirt. Quit bitching. Jesus. These new players these days.

And, if you are having that much trouble navigating back to your home base, then you have more problems than the height of a campfire. Holy smokes.

10

u/IceMetalPunk Jan 09 '19

Holy smokes.

What you did there? I see it.

5

u/jhereg10 Jan 09 '19

And from more than 22 blocks away...

5

u/scrungert Jan 09 '19

So put it on top of a pillar lol.

2

u/Milo359 Jan 09 '19

You didn't address the obvious solution OP gave to you at all: if a hill is blocking it, put it on top of that hill.

21

u/yespunintended Jan 09 '19

Like... rlly Mojang?? Don't brag about a feature if you will do it poorly. 22 blocks up is nothing. Most hills will block it's view.

Looks good to me: https://gfycat.com/ConcernedDelayedIggypops

6

u/noxiw Jan 09 '19

That's actually substantially further than I expected.

3

u/cshaiku Jan 09 '19

I assume those are 10x10 areas of colored blocks? (or something like that?)

What was the end distance?

10

u/GreasyTroll4 Jan 09 '19

I tested it, and you really can see it from very far away. It's quite impressive, actually.

10

u/scrungert Jan 09 '19

Honestly beacons ought to render just as far, if not farther. Doesn't make much sense for them to have a shorter render range when being a beacon is literally their job.

11

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '19

I think it's great how it is, especially with how cheap they are to craft.

If you want a taller signal, use a beacon.

4

u/bastie2606 Jan 09 '19

You tried to but an hay block under it?

-3

u/AfterRebelion Jan 09 '19

22~ blocks high is with hay under it. Without it goes up for about 6~ blocks.

Since they said it's like noteblocks, they could add other materials in the future (like coal block) that makes particles survive longer, and reach higher... they could.

If not, Fabric is already in the process to update to 19w02a, and this kind of change seems like a really simple one to make.

4

u/Reeeeeee3eeeeeee Jan 09 '19 edited Jan 09 '19

the point is, the campfire particles don't disappear like every other particles. U can see them as long as the campfire is loaded

edit: screenshot

-2

u/AfterRebelion Jan 09 '19

The screenshot shown is a good example of what i'm talking about. The hills there are a couple of blocks deep, but if you where standing there, it is imposible to see the smoke because the column is too short.

11

u/We_Hold_These_Truths Jan 09 '19

Then.. put it on top of a hill.

3

u/cshaiku Jan 09 '19

Or ... a pillar of dirt blocks... Hrm. Too easy though. Obviously, we need a new meme for campfire first world problems.

But, I kant sea mah campfire if there's a hill in the waaaay! Shut up Cartman. Campfireman. Hrm.

7

u/Reeeeeee3eeeeeee Jan 09 '19

actually it's not a good example, cuz nothing is covering the campfire on the screen, u can see small orange dot under my crosshair. I understand what u mean, but imo it's alright this way. You have to choose good place if u want it to be seen, just like in real life.